Civil rights movement (1896–1954)

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The civil rights movement from 1896 to 1954 was bookended by two Supreme Court decisions that could not have been more different from each other. The first, Plessy v. Ferguson in 1896, gave legal blessing to racial segregation across America. The second, Brown v. Board of Education in 1954, tore that blessing apart. Between those two rulings lay nearly six decades of marches, legal battles, lynchings, migrations, and organized resistance that reshaped American law and society.

  This was not a single movement with a single leader. It was a tangle of competing strategies, rival organizations, and bitter internal debates. Some leaders believed Black Americans should build economic power within segregation. Others demanded integration immediately, through the courts. Still others organized workers, defied party machines, or built churches and schools where the state would not. What holds them together is a question worth carrying through this documentary: how do you fight a system designed to make you invisible?

• 2. The Legal Architecture of Oppression

  ›

  Plessy v. Ferguson did not invent racial segregation, but it gave it the full force of constitutional doctrine. The ruling in 1896 held that "separate but equal" facilities were legal under the Fourteenth Amendment, providing the legal foundation for what became known as Jim Crow laws across the South.

  Justice Harlan, the only member of the Court to dissent, warned in plain terms what the ruling would enable. His dissent asked: if a state can force Black and white passengers into separate railroad coaches, why not compel them to walk on opposite sides of the street? Within years, his rhetorical question had become daily reality. African Americans in many cities and towns could not share a taxi with white passengers, enter buildings through the same entrance, drink from the same water fountains, use the same restrooms, attend the same schools, or be buried in the same cemeteries. Some parks posted signs that read "Negroes and dogs not allowed." One municipal zoo listed separate visiting hours.

  The social etiquette ran deeper than signs. Black men were expected to step aside for white passersby and dared not meet a white woman's eyes. Adults were addressed not as "Mr." or "Mrs." but as "Tom" or "Jane," or by slurs. The Court soon extended Plessy to cover private institutions: in Berea College v. Kentucky, it upheld a state law barring a private college from teaching Black and white students together.

  The Mississippi Constitution of 1890 had already built the administrative machinery to back all of this up. Poll taxes, literacy tests administered by white registrars with arbitrary discretion, and residency documentation requirements stripped most Black men of the vote. The Supreme Court upheld this system in Williams v. Mississippi in 1897. From 1890 to 1908, ten Southern states copied the Mississippi model. In Alabama by 1941, it is estimated that no more than 1,500 Black residents were registered to vote.

• 3. Violence and Its Uses

  ›

  During the last decades of the 19th century and the first decades of the 20th, white vigilante mobs lynched thousands of Black men, often with the open assistance of state officials, almost always in the South. No whites were charged with crimes in any of those murders. Confidence in total immunity was so complete that participants photographed the victims and made postcards of the images.

  The Ku Klux Klan, which had largely disappeared after Reconstruction, reappeared in 1915. Its revival was inspired in part by the film Birth of a Nation, which dramatized racist stereotypes and glorified the earlier Klan. The revived Klan grew most rapidly in industrializing cities of the South and Midwest, places undergoing swift population change from 1910 to 1930. It attracted members anxious about their place in a rapidly shifting society and built political power in states such as Indiana on a platform that combined racism with anti-immigrant, anti-Semitic, anti-Catholic, and anti-union appeals. The Klan reached its peak of membership and influence around 1925, then declined quickly as opponents organized.

  Paramilitary groups had been doing similar work at the polls for decades. The Red Shirts in Mississippi and the Carolinas, and the White League in Louisiana, practiced open intimidation on behalf of the Democratic Party in the 1870s and 1880s. Their violence and electoral fraud from 1868 to 1876 had driven down Black voter turnout and allowed Southern white Democrats to retake state legislatures, which in turn allowed those legislatures to design the disenfranchisement statutes that followed.

  The criminal justice system was itself a weapon. In some states, particularly Alabama, convict-lease arrangements amounted to a restoration of forced labor: the state sentenced Black men to years of imprisonment and leased them to private employers, including Tennessee Coal, Iron and Railroad Company, a subsidiary of United States Steel Corporation. Because the state earned money from the arrangement, it created incentives to jail more men, who were disproportionately Black, with almost no oversight of how they were treated.

• 4. Two Visions, One Struggle

  ›

  By the turn of the 20th century, Booker T. Washington was widely regarded, especially among white Americans, as the leading spokesman for Black America. Washington led the Tuskegee Institute and preached self-reliance. He urged Black Americans to improve their economic position before demanding social equality, publicly accepting the continuation of Jim Crow in the short term while privately helping to fund court challenges to discriminatory laws.

  W. E. B. Du Bois and others rejected Washington's approach as an apology for segregation. In 1905, Du Bois and William Monroe Trotter convened a meeting of Black activists on the Canadian side of Niagara Falls. They issued a manifesto calling for universal manhood suffrage, the elimination of all racial segregation, and a broad nondiscriminatory education, explicitly not limited to the vocational training that Washington promoted. The Niagara Movement faced active opposition from Washington and collapsed due to internal divisions by 1908.

  Du Bois then joined with other Black leaders and white activists, including Mary White Ovington, Oswald Garrison Villard, Julius Rosenwald, and Rabbi Emil G. Hirsch, to found the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People in 1909. Du Bois became editor of its magazine The Crisis. The NAACP focused its early energy on the courts, winning a ruling in Buchanan v. Warley that struck down a Louisville, Kentucky ordinance requiring residential segregation, and in 1915 persuading the Supreme Court to void Oklahoma's "grandfather clause" in Guinn v. United States.

  Marcus Garvey's Universal Negro Improvement Association offered a third path entirely. Garvey claimed eleven million members for the UNIA, which became broadly popular in Northern Black communities in the early 1920s. His program of Pan Africanism rejected integration into white-dominated society, promoted economic independence within segregation, and urged African Americans to "return to Africa," at least in spirit. Garvey married themes of self-reliance familiar from Washington with a worldwide rejection of colonialism. The federal government convicted Garvey for mail fraud in 1922 in connection with the financially troubled Black Star Line, and he was deported to his native Jamaica in 1927. Though the movement collapsed without him, it seeded later self-help and separatist movements, including Father Divine and the Nation of Islam.

• 5. Building in the Margins

  ›

  Historian Juliet Walker calls the 1900s to 1930s the "Golden age of black business." According to the National Negro Business League, the number of Black-owned businesses doubled from 20,000 in 1900 to 40,000 in 1914. The number of Black-owned drugstores rose from 250 to 695. Local retail merchants grew from 10,000 to 25,000. Madame C. J. Walker, born in 1867 and died in 1919, built a national franchise business based on her development of the first successful hair straightening process. Charles Clinton Spaulding, born in 1874 and died in 1952, founded North Carolina Mutual Life Insurance Company, which became the largest Black-owned business in America, with assets of more than $40 million at his death.

  Black churches were the organizing spine beneath all of this economic activity. Black congregations had split from white churches and from the Southern Baptist Convention during and after the Civil War to establish institutions free of white supervision. By 1895, several Black Baptist associations had joined to form the National Baptist Convention. Independent denominations such as the African Methodist Episcopal Church and the AME Zion Church had made hundreds of thousands of converts across the South, founding congregations that served as centers of community life, education drives, and eventually civil rights organizing.

  Education was treated with particular urgency. By 1900, the African American community had trained and put to work 30,000 Black teachers in the South, and a majority of the Black population had achieved literacy, despite segregated and chronically underfunded schools. A collaboration between Julius Rosenwald, the Jewish-American president of Sears Roebuck, and Booker T. Washington resulted in nearly 5,000 schools constructed in eleven Southern states as well as in Oklahoma, Missouri, Kentucky, and Maryland. It is estimated that at one time around forty percent of rural Southern Black children were learning in these Rosenwald Schools. Congress's second Morrill Act of 1890, requiring states that excluded Black students from existing land grant colleges to open separate institutions with equitable funding, led to the founding of what are today's public historically Black colleges and universities.

• 6. Workers, Soldiers, and the New Negro

  ›

  A. Philip Randolph introduced the term "New Negro" in 1917 to describe the militancy and impatience that Black veterans brought home from World War I. Some returning soldiers were assaulted in their uniforms. One serviceman's statement, quoted in the source, captured the mood precisely: "I spent four years in the Army to free a bunch of Dutchmen and Frenchmen, and I'm hanged if I'm going to let the Alabama version of the Germans kick me around when I get home."

  Randolph channeled that energy into labor organizing. He took leadership of the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters at its founding in 1925, facing opposition not only from the Pullman Company but from Black newspapers and churches that benefited financially from the company's support. After a ten-year campaign, the union won recognition from Pullman in 1935 and a contract in 1937. The BSCP became the only Black-led union within the American Federation of Labor in 1935. BSCP members such as Edgar Nixon would go on to play significant roles in civil rights struggles in the following decades.

  The labor movement's relationship with Black workers was complicated. While the Congress of Industrial Organizations made strenuous efforts to organize African American workers and made civil rights advocacy part of its strategy, many white workers resisted. A wildcat strike launched in Philadelphia in 1944, when the federal government ordered a private transit company to desegregate its workforce, lasted two weeks and ended only when the Roosevelt administration sent troops and arrested the ringleaders.

  Randolph eventually threatened a March on Washington in 1942 if the government refused to outlaw racial discrimination by defense contractors. He dropped the threat only after winning substantial concessions. From 1940 to 1946, the NAACP's membership grew from 50,000 to 450,000, a measure of how the war years had galvanized Black political organization.

• 7. The Long Road to Brown

  ›

  Thurgood Marshall and the NAACP's legal department, led by Charles Hamilton Houston, pursued a litigation campaign spanning several decades to reverse Plessy. Their first cases did not attack segregation directly but worked to prove that segregated facilities were not in fact equal, laying factual groundwork case by case. Smith v. Allwright in 1944 struck down white primaries. Shelley v. Kraemer in 1948 ended enforcement of racially restrictive housing covenants. Sweatt v. Painter in 1950 targeted segregation in graduate education.

  The NAACP eventually issued a directive that their goal was "obtaining education on a nonsegregated basis and that no relief other than that will be acceptable." The first case Marshall argued on that direct basis was Briggs v. Elliott. In Topeka, Kansas, the NAACP identified Oliver Brown, an assistant pastor and father of three daughters, as an ideal plaintiff. He was instructed to apply to enroll his daughters at a local white school; after the expected rejection, Brown v. Board of Education was filed. Several similar cases were later consolidated at the Supreme Court under Brown's name, a choice apparently made so the question would not look like a purely Southern one.

  In December 1952, the Court heard the case but could not reach a decision, pushing it back a year to allow research into the original intent of the Fourteenth Amendment's Equal Protection Clause. Chief Justice Fred Vinson, whom Marshall's allies feared would entrench Plessy, died of a heart attack in September 1953. Justice Felix Frankfurter reportedly remarked: "This is the first indication I have ever had that there is a God." Vinson was succeeded by Earl Warren, known for moderate views on civil rights. After the case was reheard in December, Warren persuaded his colleagues toward a unanimous ruling, swaying Justice Stanley Reed by suggesting that a lone Southern dissent could be more incendiary than a unified Court.

  In May 1954, Warren announced the decision: segregation of children in public schools solely on the basis of race was unconstitutional because it deprived minority children of equal educational opportunities. Some 19 Senators and 77 House members signed "The Southern Manifesto" pledging resistance. The Governor of Virginia, Thomas B. Stanley, vowed to use every legal means to keep Virginia's schools segregated. By the fall of 1955, Cheryl Brown, Oliver Brown's daughter, started first grade at an integrated school in Topeka.