Buddhist paths to liberation

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Buddhist paths to liberation have never been a single road. The phrase the Buddha is recorded as using in the Sutta Pitaka is marga, meaning path, yet the Pali Nikayas alone preserve at least a dozen distinct sequences describing how a person moves from ordinary life to full awakening. The Noble Eightfold Path is the one most people recognize, but scholars of early Buddhist texts point out that it may actually be a later, more stylized formulation. Older sequences, possibly predating the four noble truths, run through the same canonical texts like hidden rivers beneath the famous route. What does each of these maps share? What do they disagree on? And why does a tradition devoted to direct experience produce so many competing itineraries? Those questions open onto a surprisingly diverse landscape, one that stretches from the forests of ancient India to the courts of Tang-dynasty China, and from the meditation halls of Theravada monasteries to the Tibetan tantric traditions of deity yoga and Kundalini practice.

• 2. The Eightfold Path and the Dhyanas

  ›

  The Blessed One said, according to the Sutta Pitaka: "Now what, monks, is the Noble Eightfold Path? Right view, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, right concentration." That definition has become, for most of the world, the summary of Buddhism itself. Yet scholars note that the four dhyanas, the four stages of meditative absorption, are actually embedded within the Eightfold Path as its eighth limb, samadhi. Some argue that the dhyana scheme may be the more prominent organizing principle in the early texts, even if it is less famous in popular culture. The four dhyanas chart a journey inward: a practitioner first purifies the mind of what the texts call the hindrances, the nivarana, by finding an isolated spot for meditation. The first rupa-jhana arises when those hindrances are sufficiently cleared. Each subsequent jhana represents a further settling and refinement of awareness. The Cula-Hatthipadopama-sutta, the Lesser Discourse on the Simile of the Elephant's Footprints in the Majjhima Nikaya, describes the fourth jhana as a staging ground for three further kinds of knowledge: recollection of former existences, observation of the death and rebirth of beings according to their karmas, and the destruction of the asavas, the cankers, accompanied by a direct realization of the Four Noble Truths. From that final knowledge, the text says, "he perceives that he is now liberated, that he has done what was to be done."

• 3. Older Paths in the Pali Canon

  ›

  The Tevijja Sutta, verses 40 through 75 of the Digha Nikaya 13, preserves what may be one of the oldest surviving path sequences in Buddhist literature. A Tathagata appears in the world and makes his knowledge known. A householder hears that teaching, acquires faith, and goes forth from the household life into the homeless state. What follows is not a list of doctrines but a description of a changed life: self-restraint, guarding the senses, mindfulness, contentment with little, and the simplicity of life. Each step produces something: a confidence of heart, a joy, a peace that eventually fills the practitioner's whole being. The Maha-Assapura-sutta takes a slightly different angle, cataloguing the things "that are to be done by recluses and brahmans." Its list begins with hiri-ottappa, the cultivation of a sense of shame and a fear of blame. Pure conduct of body, speech, and mind follow, then pure livelihood, then restraint in eating and the practice of wakefulness. The Sekha sutta assigns this same sequence to a teaching that the Buddha prompted Ananda to deliver, calling it a "learner's course" for a group of disciples. Rod Bucknell, whose work the source draws on, identifies this cluster of sequences as revealing a common underlying structure: moral training, sense restraint, mindfulness, the four jhanas, and three types of knowledge culminating in liberation.

• 4. The Chinese Madhyama Agama

  ›

  Bhikkhu Sujato has noted that the Chinese Madhyama Agama of the Sarvastivada school contains expositions of the gradual path not available in the Pali Nikayas of the Theravada school. Three sutras stand out: MA 44, MA 54, and MA 55. MA 44 opens with mindfulness and clear comprehension and moves through repulsion, fading of lust, and liberation to Nibbana. MA 54 adds a preparatory social dimension: honouring and attending upon a teacher, approaching, listening, giving ear, and considering the meaning of the teaching before the sequence narrows down to meditation and insight. MA 55 is the most structurally ambitious of the three. It begins not with a first step toward liberation but with ignorance itself, following the chain of dependent origination through conceptual activities, cognition, name and form, six senses, contact, feeling, craving, grasping, existence, birth, aging, death, and suffering. Only then does it pivot: faith arises, right consideration follows, and the sequence rejoins the path shared by the other two sutras, arriving finally at liberation and Nibbana. Taken together, these three Chinese sequences suggest that early Buddhist communities were experimenting with how far back to begin the story of liberation.

• 5. Seven Aids to Awakening

  ›

  Rupert Gethin describes a short formula that recurs throughout the Pali Canon as one of its most frequent summaries of the path: abandon the hindrances, practice the four establishings of mindfulness, and develop the awakening factors. The seven awakening factors, the bojjhanga, are not merely instrumental tools. According to Gethin, they are both the means to awakening and the constituents of it. Those seven factors are mindfulness, investigation, energy, joy, tranquillity, unification, and equanimity. The source notes a "definite affinity" between the four jhanas and the bojjhanga, with a range of meditation practices aiding their development. Satipatthana, mindfulness practice, and anapanasati, breath-meditation, together produce what the texts describe as a "heightened awareness" and the overcoming of distracting and disturbing emotions. The seven awakening factors sit within a larger framework called the bodhipakkhiya dhamma, a term from the Pali commentaries for seven sets of qualities collectively referred to throughout the canon as aids to awakening. Counted together, these seven sets contain thirty-seven factors in total, many of them overlapping. Among those seven sets are the four foundations of mindfulness, the four right efforts, the four bases of mental power, the five spiritual faculties, the five strengths, the seven factors of awakening, and the Noble Eightfold Path itself.

• 6. Theravada Purification and Sarvastivada Five Paths

  ›

  Buddhaghosa, the fifth-century commentator, organized the Theravada path into a system of Seven Purifications in his work the Visuddhimagga. Purification of Conduct stands first; Purification of Knowledge and Vision last. Between them run five further stages, including Purification by Overcoming Doubt and Purification by Knowledge and Vision of What Is Path and Not Path. That sixth purification itself contains nine sub-knowledges, from the knowledge of contemplation of rise and fall through to the knowledge of equanimity about formations and a final conformity knowledge. The culmination is a four-stage sequence of paths and fruits leading to liberation. The system places particular weight on understanding the three marks of existence, dukkha (suffering), anatta (non-self), and anicca (impermanence), and this emphasis on insight, vipassana, over calm meditation, samatha, has carried forward into the contemporary vipassana movement. A quite different organizational logic shaped the Sarvastivada tradition's approach. The Vaibhashika school developed what they called the five paths, a scheme preserved in Vasubandhu's Abhidharmakosa. The path of accumulation begins with morality, learning, and mindfulness. The path of preparation involves analytical observation of the four noble truths across sixteen aspects. The path of seeing continues that observation until eighty-eight afflictions, the kleshas, are abandoned. The path of cultivation removes ten further kleshas. At the end stands the path of no more learning, where one is fully freed of all obstructions and described as fulfilled, nishtha. Mahayana traditions later adapted this five-path framework for their own purposes.

• 7. The Bodhisattva Path

  ›

  Mahayana Buddhism built its path around the figure of the bodhisattva, a being who vows to work for the complete enlightenment of all sentient beings before entering Nirvana alone. The bodhisattva takes formal vows and trains in six paramitas, or perfections: generosity, virtue, patience, energy, one-pointed concentration, and wisdom. The Prajnaparamita Sutras, the Lotus Sutra (Saddharma Pundarika Sutra), and a large number of other Mahayana texts enumerate these six perfections. The Abhisamayalamkara, a Mahayana commentary, adapted the Sarvastivada five-path scheme and added the ten bhumis, or bodhisattva grounds, as subcategories within those five paths. The Sanskrit word bhumi literally means "ground" or "foundation," and each stage serves as a basis for the next. The Avatamsaka Sutra names all ten. The first bhumi is called the Very Joyous, in which one rejoices at realizing a partial aspect of the truth. Subsequent stages include the Stainless, the Luminous, the Radiant, and the Difficult to Cultivate. The tenth bhumi, the Cloud of Doctrine, is described in the sutra as benefiting all sentient beings with the Dharma, "just as a cloud sends down rain impartially on all things." Stream-entry, the first stage of liberation in Theravada, corresponds in Mahayana reckoning to the path of seeing and the first bodhisattva bhumi.

• 8. Tibetan, Zen, and the Sudden-Gradual Debate

  ›

  Tsong Khapa's Lam Rim, the stages of the path in Tibetan Buddhism, identifies three essential elements of the path: the aspiration for awakening, bodhicitta (the aspiration to attain awakening for all living beings), and insight into emptiness. The highest class of Tibetan tantras, the annuttara-yoga tantras, divides practice into a generation stage and a completion stage. In the generation stage, the practitioner engages in deity yoga, visualizing what the texts call the Four Purities: seeing one's own body as the body of the deity, seeing one's environment as the deity's pure land or mandala, perceiving one's enjoyments as the deity's bliss free from attachment, and performing all actions only for the benefit of others. The completion stage then moves either through Kundalini yoga, directing wind energy into the heart chakra until Mahamudra remains, or through a path of liberation that applies mindfulness toward realizing the inherent emptiness of all things. Mahāmudrā itself is sometimes divided into four yogas: one-pointedness, simplicity, one taste, and non-meditation, with the final yoga described as "the state of not holding to either an object of meditation nor to a meditator." In Chinese Chan, the axis of debate was different. In the 8th century, Shenhui, a student of Huineng, made the distinction between sudden and gradual enlightenment a live political contest at the Tang imperial court. Guifeng Zongmi, who was simultaneously fifth patriarch of Hua-yen and a Chan master, worked to soften that boundary: sudden awakening points to seeing into one's true nature, he argued, but must be followed by gradual cultivation. Chinul, a 12th-century Korean Seon master, followed Zongmi's analysis. Chan Master Sheng Yen of the contemporary Sanbo Kyodan articulated the position plainly: "Even though Ch'an says that at the time of enlightenment, your outlook is the same as of the Buddha, you are not yet a full Buddha." The source notes that the Rinzai tradition preserves this dual structure in specific teaching frameworks such as the Three Mysterious Gates of Linji and the Four Ways of Knowing of Hakuin, while the Soto school traces a related developmental arc in Tozan's description of the Five Ranks of Enlightenment.