Wirtschaftswunder

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Wirtschaftswunder, a German word meaning "economic miracle," describes one of the most dramatic reversals of fortune in modern history. West Germany and Austria lay in ruins at the end of World War II. Cities were rubble, factories were stripped, and the currency was worthless. Food circulated by barter rather than in shops. Within a single decade, both countries had rebuilt themselves into prosperous modern economies. How did nations so thoroughly destroyed recover so fast? The answers involve a currency swap that happened overnight, a bureaucrat who defied the orders of occupying armies, a war on the other side of the world that unexpectedly opened new markets, and millions of displaced workers who became the engine of recovery.

• 2. The Currency That Changed Everything

  ›

  In 1948, West Germany swapped the Reichsmark for the Deutsche Mark, and the effect was almost immediate. Rampant inflation stopped. For two years before that swap, the Allied directive JCS 1067 had instructed U.S. occupation forces to take no steps toward the economic rehabilitation of Germany. That prohibition had frozen the reforms West Germany needed.

  Ludwig Erhard, West Germany's Minister of Economics, paired the new currency with a decree abolishing price controls. The Allied powers opposed this move. The Social Democratic Party opposed it. Most West German manufacturing interests opposed it. Even some of Erhard's own advisers reportedly did. Erhard issued the decree anyway. The logic was straightforward: once producers could charge prices that reflected their actual costs, they had a reason to produce. The shortages dissolved.

  At the same time, the government cut taxes sharply on moderate incomes. Walter Heller, a young American economist with the U.S. occupation forces who would later chair the Council of Economic Advisers under President John F. Kennedy, wrote in 1949 that Military Government Law No. 64 had cut "a wide swath across the German tax system at the time of the currency reform." Before the reform, any income above 6,000 Deutschmark had faced a tax rate of 95 percent. After the reform, that 95 percent rate applied only to annual incomes above 250,000 Deutschmark. For a West German worker earning roughly 2,400 Deutschmark a year in 1950, the marginal tax rate dropped from 85 percent to 18 percent.

• 3. The Costs of Defeat

  ›

  Recovery did not happen in a vacuum. The Potsdam Conference had authorized the dismantling of West German coal and steel industries, and that process was virtually complete by 1950. Equipment had been removed from 706 manufacturing plants. Steel production capacity had been cut by 6,700,000 tons. The Saarland, an industrially important region with rich coal fields, was returned to West Germany only in 1957, remained in a customs union with France until 1959, and France continued extracting coal from the area until 1981.

  Intellectual property was another form of extraction. Immediately after the German surrender in May 1945, the U.S. launched Operation Paperclip, a vigorous program of collecting German scientific and technical knowledge. All German patents, at home and abroad, were confiscated. Thousands of leading researchers and engineers ended up working in either the Soviet Union or the United States. John Gimbel's book Science Technology and Reparations concluded that the intellectual reparations taken by the U.S. and the United Kingdom amounted to close to $10 billion. For context, the entire Marshall Plan expenditure from 1948 to 1952 totaled $13 billion. The effect was direct: during the more than two years this policy was in place, new industrial research in Germany went unprotected and was freely available to overseas competitors.

  What the Allies provided in Marshall aid, West Germany gave back many times over. West Germany received roughly $1.4 billion under the Marshall Plan, mostly as loans. The occupation charges the Allies imposed for stationing troops ran to about $2.4 billion per year. Germany repaid $1.1 billion of its received aid, with the final repayment made in June 1971.

• 4. Korea, Migration, and the Guest Workers

  ›

  West Germany entered the 1950s with an unusually large pool of skilled workers. Deportations and migrations of Germans during and after the war involved up to 16.5 million people. That displacement, devastating for individuals, gave the recovering economy a workforce that could scale rapidly. West Germany more than doubled the value of its exports during and shortly after the Korean War of 1950-1953, partly because the global shortage of goods the war created helped overcome lingering resistance to buying West German products.

  150,000 U.S. occupation troops, whose numbers swelled to over 250,000 during exercises, contributed an often-overlooked economic stimulus. Earning as much as 4 Deutschmark to the dollar, these soldiers spent within West Germany on food, beer, cars, luxury items, and local services. From the mid-1950s onward, thousands of foreign guest workers supplied additional labour, sustaining the upswing as the domestic workforce approached full employment. Unemployment reached a record low of 0.7-0.8 percent in 1961-1966 and again in 1970-1971.

  Capital investment rates stayed very high through the 1950s, driven by low consumption and the fact that a small existing capital stock required little replacement spending. Every new machine or factory added directly to output. British journalist Terence Prittie, writing in the early 1960s, observed that productivity growth had enabled most workers to obtain significant improvements in their living standards and what he called "security of life."

• 5. A Nation of New Owners

  ›

  The purchasing power of wages rose 73 percent from 1950 to 1960. Between 1962 and 1973, the share of households owning a refrigerator climbed from 52 percent to 93 percent. Vacuum cleaner ownership went from 65 percent to 91 percent over the same span. Television sets went from 34 percent of households to 87 percent. Car ownership nearly doubled, from 27 percent to 55 percent.

  The Volkswagen Beetle became an icon of this transformation. A special one-off version of the car was manufactured to mark the production of one million vehicles of the type. West Germany had no army before the establishment of its military in 1955, which meant government spending that in other countries went to defence flowed instead into civilian goods and investment. From the late 1950s onward, West Germany held one of the world's most powerful economies. Ludwig Erhard served as Chancellor from 1963 to 1966, carrying his reputation as the father of the West German economic miracle into the country's highest office.

• 6. Austria's Parallel Path

  ›

  Austria followed a distinct but parallel route. Its economic policy acquired a name in journalistic circles: the Raab-Kamitz-Kurs, named after Chancellor Julius Raab, who took office in 1953, and his Finance Minister Reinhard Kamitz. The label echoed the West German Adenauer-Erhard-Kurs, recognising that both countries had pursued broadly similar philosophies.

  Austria joined the Marshall Plan and nationalised key industries, including VOEST, AMAG, and Steyr-Puch. Long working hours drove the country toward full economic capacity. Major state infrastructure projects played a specific role: the Kaprun hydroelectric plant and the West Autobahn absorbed labour, reduced unemployment, and helped maintain social peace. By the 1950s, the first guest workers from southern Italy and Greece were arriving in Austria, drawn by the same demand for manual labour that was reshaping West Germany. When the European Common Market was founded in 1957, West Germany's growth stood in sharp contrast to the struggling conditions then prevailing in the United Kingdom, a marker of how completely the two defeated nations had reversed their positions from just a decade before.