United Way

• 1. Origins And Community Chests

  ›

  In 1887, Denver, Colorado became the birthplace of a movement that would eventually reshape American philanthropy. Frances Wisebart Jacobs joined forces with Reverend Myron W. Reed and three other religious leaders to launch the Charity Organization Society. This group coordinated services between Jewish and Christian charities while raising funds for twenty-two different agencies. The model proved so effective that similar organizations began appearing across the country in the early twentieth century. By 1913, Cleveland, Ohio established its first Community Chest after the local Jewish Federation demonstrated how federated giving could work. World War I accelerated this spread as wartime fundraising efforts adopted the Community Chest structure. Three hundred to four hundred War Chests existed during the conflict, most converting into permanent Community Chests once peace returned. The number of these organizations grew from two hundred forty-five in 1925 to nearly eight hundred by 1945.

• 2. Evolution Of Workplace Giving

  ›

  The shift from door-to-door solicitation to workplace campaigns marked a turning point in United Way history. After World War II, federal tax incentives for corporate gifts weakened, forcing campaign leaders to look elsewhere for revenue. In 1956, employee contributions accounted for thirty-nine point six percent of United Funds and Community Chests revenue. This was the first time workplace giving exceeded corporate donations, which stood at thirty-eight percent. The technology of payroll deductions became a vehicle for incremental giving following the government's introduction of compulsory Social Security withholdings in 1942. A post-war economic boom helped these campaigns grow at an annual rate of five to ten percent. By 1970, fifty-seven percent of all United Way donations came through automatic payroll deductions while another twenty percent originated from corporate donations. The Ford Company had previously issued a press release stating that each plant solicitation cost them forty thousand dollars in lost executive time and productivity. Business leaders demanded federated solutions or they would stop contributing entirely.

• 3. The Aramony Scandal Era

  ›

  An anonymous tip sent on January 1990 letterhead to board chairman Edward A. Brennan triggered a crisis that would consume the organization for years. The note alleged CEO William Aramony maintained affairs with two sisters including one who was a teenager while using charity funds to keep them quiet. Aramony denied the claims but later investigations revealed he used company money for luxurious expenses including Concorde flights and ninety thousand dollars for limousine service. He spun off two for-profit enterprises called Partnership Umbrella and Sales Service America using United Way funds. These companies purchased and decorated over twelve million dollars worth of real estate across Alexandria, Miami, and New York. One property included a four hundred fifty-nine thousand dollar condominium in New York City specifically for Aramony's personal use. An outside firm hired in December 1991 found sloppy record keeping but avoided specific admissions of wrongdoing initially. Aramony submitted his resignation on the 27th of February 1992 during a teleconference with local United Ways. In April 1995, he was convicted on twenty-three felony counts including conspiracy and fraud. He received a seven-year prison sentence and served six years before release.

• 4. Centralization And Structural Reform

  ›

  Betty Stanley Beene took over leadership in 1997 and pushed for a more centralized system where national standards would apply to all affiliates. United Way of America paid Cap Gemini America twelve million dollars to build charitable-pledge software for the United Way Information Network. This centralized processing center aimed to make donations more efficient for companies with national footprints. The project competed directly with regional pledge centers operated by four large regional United Ways. Deloitte & Touche reviewed the software and discovered four hundred serious problems that prevented it from functioning properly. United Way abandoned the project in 1999 and reached a settlement with Cap Gemini in 2000. Some local United Ways intensely rejected these plans and withheld dues as protest. The United Way in Rochester obtained legal rights to alternative names if the organization broke apart. These conflicts contributed to Beene's departure in 2001. Brian Gallagher became president and CEO in 2002 after serving as head of United Way in Columbus, Ohio. The organization faced internal resistance when attempting to unify its thousand four hundred local affiliates under new national standards.

• 5. Donor Choice And Market Share

  ›

  United Way officially embraced donor designation policies in 1982 allowing donors to select which nonprofits received their gifts. Aramony introduced this concept initially to prevent large employers from allowing alternative funds to solicit alongside United Way campaigns. Despite slow rollout described as glacial pace in a 2000 Fortune piece, designated dollars continued growing over time. In 1990 only fourteen percent of gifts went to outside charities while nearly twenty percent did so by 1999 according to United Way estimates. Allowing donor choice caused donations to general funds to decline significantly. Kevin Ronnie of the National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy noted that offering choice meant people would use it at the expense of community caretaking functions. The growth of donor choice contributed to near-bankruptcy of United Way of Santa Clara County as their general fund pool shrank while allocations remained constant. By 1999, United Way share of US charitable contributions had dropped from three point one six percent in 1988 to just one point nine eight percent. Four federations formed the Charities@Work coalition promoting expanded access to workplace campaigns. Only twenty-five percent of companies conducted traditional United Way-only campaigns according to a 2009 survey.

• 6. Digital Transformation And Competition

  ›

  Technology companies began challenging United Way's dominance over workplace giving during the 2000s with customized platforms for employee volunteering and donations. Charitableway raised forty-three million dollars in 2000 securing agreements with Hewlett-Packard and Morgan Stanley to run their campaigns. After the failure of the United Way Information Network, fifty United Ways developed the online United eWay system with technical assistance from Microsoft. This product ran as a subsidiary until CreateHope Inc purchased it in 2008 and spun off TRUiST Inc as a separate company. Benevity founded in 2008 became the workplace campaign provider for Apple, Microsoft, PayPal, T-Mobile, TripAdvisor, Charles Schwab, and Nike. Benevity processed six hundred forty-nine million dollars in donations during fiscal year 2018 alone. A 2020 report found there were fifty-one employee-giving technology platforms available today. To compete directly, Salesforce.org launched Philanthropy Cloud in partnership with United Way Worldwide in 2018. By January 2020, over two hundred companies including twenty-five local United Ways used this service. The dot-com bubble burst caused Charitableway to fold while other competitors like Benevity thrived.