Two-Face

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Two-Face, the coin-tossing enemy of Batman, makes his first appearance in Detective Comics #66, published in August 1942. Late in that issue, Batman chases him down and corners him. The hero offers a simple deal: give up and start over. The villain replies that his coin makes every decision for him, and he flips it. The coin lands on its edge, with neither side facing up. The issue ends there, with the matter left to fate. Who was the man behind that coin? Why did he become one of the most enduring foes in Gotham City? And why have writers kept taking his face, his mind, and his history apart for decades?

  472103245

• 2. A Villain Takes Shape

  ›

  Bob Kane, one of Batman's two co-creators, is credited with inventing Two-Face. The other co-creator, Bill Finger, wrote the debut story, titled "The Crimes of Two-Face." Kane pointed to the 1931 film version of Robert Louis Stevenson's The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde as a spark. He called it a "classic story of the good and evil sides of human nature." The 1925 silent film of Gaston Leroux's novel The Phantom of the Opera also shaped the idea. Kane's autobiography, Batman and Me, adds a further suggestion. He wrote that Finger may have been thinking of the pulp hero Black Bat, another district attorney disfigured by acid.

  In that debut, the prosecutor is not yet called Dent. He is Harvey "Apollo" Kent, a handsome, law-abiding district attorney who is trying the mob boss Sal Maroni. At the trial, Kent presents Maroni's lucky two-headed coin as evidence. Maroni, enraged, throws acid at Kent's face and ruins half of it. Kent's wife, Gilda, a sculptor, is introduced in the same issue. Driven out of his mind by the revulsion of others and by his wife's refusal to accept his new look, Kent destroys her sculpture of him so that it matches his wounds. He then scars one side of the two-headed coin, to stand for the beauty and ugliness he now carries. He flips it to choose between a life of crime and waiting for the only plastic surgeon able to repair his face. That surgeon is stuck in a concentration camp in Germany.

  The coin lands scarred side up, and Kent becomes Two-Face. The rule that Kane and Finger set for him is simple. A scarred result sends him on a rampage of looting and destruction. A clean result makes him hand his loot to charity or hold back from the crime. In that first issue he robs a bank on one flip and gives away his takings on another. Police and public split over whether he is a villain at all. The rest of the story is a string of crimes built around the number 2, and Batman stops one of them.

  Batman #50, in 1948, changed the surname from Kent to Dent. Kane explained that the switch separated the character from Clark Kent, the alter ego of Superman. The Golden Age run was short. Plastic surgery cures him in 1943, in "The End of Two-Face" from Detective Comics #80. A reformed man appears in 1952's "The Double Crimes of Two-Face!" in Detective Comics #187, and impostors fill his place in later stories. In 1954, Batman #81 sent him back to crime in "Two-Face Strikes Again," but that tale falls outside the Golden Age version. Only the stories from 1942 to 1952 were assigned to Earth-Two, DC's setting for its Golden Age characters. After that, comics left the villain unused for the entire Silver Age of Comic Books.

  4763651005

• 3. Return to Gotham

  ›

  World's Finest Comics #173, in 1968, holds the only Silver Age trace of the idea, and it is a strange one. A potion turns Batman himself into Two-Face for a story. The real villain had to wait three more years. In July 1971, writer Dennis O'Neil and former DC editor Julius Schwartz revived him in "Half an Evil," Batman #234, drawn by Neal Adams. The issue is a mystery about Two-Face stealing doubloons from a ship, and it also retells his origin with a recap of the earlier stories.

  The climax of "Half an Evil" turns on the coin. Two-Face ties up Batman and leaves the ship to sink. Before he goes, Batman urges him to flip the coin to spare an old man caught unaware in the trap, reminding him that he is both good and evil. Two-Face refuses, but once he is away from the ship he cannot resist the toss. The coin lands unscarred, so he goes back to rescue the old man. He finds that Batman has already slipped his restraints. Batman offers him a chance to surrender, Two-Face attacks instead, and Batman knocks him out.

  After that revival, Two-Face turned up across DC's line, in titles such as The Brave and the Bold, Justice League of America, and Teen Titans. He became one of Batman's most popular enemies. In the first issue of The Joker, titled "The Joker's Double Jeopardy," he and the Joker battle to prove which of them is the better criminal. Justice League of America issues 125 and 126 show him helping the team. In Teen Titans, a young woman named Duela Dent claims to be his daughter.

  The schemes grew large. In Batman #258, a retired United States Army general breaks Two-Face out of Arkham Hospital to help blackmail the government with an atomic bomb. Two-Face betrays the general and takes over the plan. He then interrupts a meeting of Congress in the United States Capitol and demands two billion dollars and gemstones. He means to use the money to bribe people into ignoring his appearance and to end his misery. Batman foils him.

  Batman issues 313 and 314 move the action to New Orleans. Two-Face steals a top secret missile activation code and sells it on a Mardi Gras parade float to an American and a Russian representative, each of whom bargained for it at $22,000,000. He walks away with $44,000,000 and escapes to a blimp, with Batman and the federal agent King Faraday close behind. As Batman hangs from the hatch, Two-Face flips the coin to decide whether to kill him. Faraday shoots the coin out of the hatch. Two-Face declares his life meaningless without it, leaps after the coin, and falls. A later pair of issues would hide him behind plastic surgery and a borrowed name.

  6667686971

• 4. Rewriting the Past

  ›

  Frank Miller's 1986 retelling of Batman's origin, Batman: Year One, appeared after the Crisis on Infinite Earths event rebooted the DC Universe. It presented Harvey Dent as Gotham City's former crusader against crime and a former ally of Batman. Four years later, writer Andrew Helfer reshaped him again in "The Eye of the Beholder," published in Batman Annual #14 in 1990. That story gave Dent dissociative identity disorder, caused by the psychological trauma of childhood abuse from his father. Two-Face became a second personality state. It also made Dent a former partner of Batman and Commissioner James Gordon in the fight against crime.

  The father in that story is Christopher Dent, an alcoholic who beat his son on the flip of a coin. On heads the boy was beaten, and on tails he was spared. The coin had two heads, so he never was spared. A psychiatrist in the story describes "two personalities," and says Dent had managed to "sublimate the second, anti-social one since he was a teenager." The abuse also planted a lifelong struggle with free will, and an eventual inability to choose without the coin.

  Two more books built on that foundation. In 1995, writer J. M. DeMatteis and artist Scott McDaniel published Batman/Two-Face: Crime and Punishment, which explored Dent's mind and his childhood. In 1996, writer Jeph Loeb and artist Tim Sale's limited series The Long Halloween folded in parts of Helfer's story. It follows Batman, Gordon, and Dent as they try to break Gotham's Mob while costumed supervillains begin to rise.

  These stories gave Dent a new rise and a new fall. Diagnosed young, he hid his illness and drove himself so hard that at age 26 he became the youngest district attorney in the city's history. Gordon even suspected that Dent might be Batman, then dropped the idea because Dent lacked the money to fund a vigilante. The mob boss Carmine Falcone bribes a corrupt assistant district attorney, Vernon Fields, to supply Maroni with sulfuric acid. During cross-examination, Maroni throws it at Dent and scars the left side of his face. Dent escapes the hospital and reinvents himself as the gangster Two-Face, scarring one side of his father's coin. He takes revenge on Falcone, Fields, and Maroni, and Batman captures him and sends him to Arkham Asylum.

  In Batman: Dark Victory, a serial killer called the Hangman targets police officers who helped Dent rise to the district attorney's office. Two-Face gathers Gotham's criminals to help bring down the city's crime lords. After a struggle in the Batcave, the Joker betrays him and shoots at him, and he falls into a chasm. Batman says that even if Two-Face survived, Harvey Dent is gone forever. Much later, the comics reveal that Two-Face murdered the father of Jason Todd, the second Robin.

  828351290

• 5. Duality and Dependence

  ›

  The time 10:22 p.m., written as 2222 in military time, is the sort of detail Two-Face loves. Since his 1942 debut, his crimes, hideouts, and henchmen have revolved around the number 2. He robs buildings with a 2 in the address and stages events at that hour. From the 1980s on, the obsession widened into the duality of man, and he commits crimes out of what the text calls a "misguided sense of right and wrong." He sees himself as both good and evil, and his coin decides which side wins.

  Many readers call him Batman's most tragic villain, and the debut already set that tone. He was a lawyer shunned by society after his disfigurement, and that rejection pushed him toward crime. In his early stories he longs to repair his face and win back the love of his life, whom he wrongly believes no longer loves him. The Modern Age added a darker layer. By 1990 he was a man close to a breakdown, weighed down by repressed trauma, by the strain of fighting crime, and by the corruption around him.

  Two-Face has no superpowers. He relies on marksmanship and martial arts, both sharpened by training from Deathstroke and Batman. His craft comes from his years as a lawyer, with deep knowledge of criminal law, criminology, and police procedure that he turns to planning crimes. He is also a charismatic speaker and leader. In battle he uses pistols, shotguns, grenade launchers, Tommy guns, knives, and rocket launchers, though dual pistols are his signature. Dent kept himself in peak shape even as an assistant district attorney, and the story arc Face the Face shows Batman training him in detective work and martial arts shortly before leaving Gotham for a year.

  The coin can even be the only thing holding him together. In Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth, the asylum's doctors replace it with a die and a tarot deck. Instead of becoming self-reliant, Dent becomes unable to make even the smallest choices, such as whether to go to the bathroom. Batman returns the coin and tells Two-Face to use it to decide whether to kill him. Batman walks away safely, and the story implies that Two-Face made his own decision to let him live.

  8687104542

• 6. Bonds and Betrayals

  ›

  Detective Comics #66 already shows Batman calling Harvey his friend, and in that first appearance he emotionally begs him to give up crime. That bond makes Two-Face one of Batman's most personal enemies. In the comics, Bruce Wayne treats Harvey's downfall as a personal failure and has never stopped trying to rehabilitate him. Harvey's knowledge of Bruce's secret identity enters through the story "The Big Burn." Scott Snyder's All-Star Batman then makes them childhood best friends. In Detective Comics #1021, Harvey admits he has kept the secret from his Two-Face personality, to protect Bruce.

  Gilda Dent, in some versions Harvey's wife, is a recurring figure in his stories. In Batman issues 328 and 329, Two-Face takes the name Carl Ternion and reunites with Gilda, after her former husband Dave Stevens died. He then avenges Stevens by killing Sal Maroni, who had changed his own face and name to Anton Karoselle and had killed Stevens. Later, when Ternion's surgery unravels and he runs, Batman disguises himself as Maroni attacking Gilda, and lures Two-Face to the Gotham City courthouse. There the two persuade him to seek rehabilitation in Arkham.

  Gilda's later arc is stranger. In Batman: Two-Face Strikes Twice!, she is Gilda Grace Dent, and Two-Face believes their marriage failed because he could not give her children. She marries Paul Janus, a name that nods to the Roman god of doors and two faces. Two-Face kidnaps Janus and swaps in a stand-in disfigured with makeup, trying to frame him. Years later, Gilda gives birth to twins, and Two-Face takes them hostage, wrongly sure that Janus fathered them with an experimental fertility drug. The book ends by revealing that Two-Face is their natural father.

  His father returns in Batman/Two-Face: Crime and Punishment. Two-Face captures Christopher Dent, planning to humiliate and kill him on live television. Yet Dent has been paying for a costly home so that his father would not live in a slum. In the closing argument between his two personalities, Two-Face calls Dent "spineless." To prove him wrong, Dent decides to jump off a building. The coin comes up scarred, which surprises Two-Face, but he obeys and jumps. Batman catches him, and the shock seems to destroy the Two-Face personality, at least for a time.

  During the No Man's Land storyline, after an earthquake devastates Gotham, Two-Face claims part of the ruined city and takes up residence in Gotham City Hall. He forms a temporary alliance with Gordon, and then Bane, employed by Lex Luthor, destroys his gang. Two-Face kidnaps Gordon and puts him on trial as both judge and prosecutor. Gordon plays on the split mind and demands Harvey Dent as his defense attorney. Dent cross-examines Two-Face and wins an acquittal.

  In that same storyline, he meets the detective Renee Montoya. Writer Greg Rucka introduced their bond in 1999 in Batman Chronicles #16, where Renee reaches out to the Dent persona and is kind to him. Harvey sends her flowers for her birthday, and she visits him in Arkham Asylum. He falls in love, and she does not return it. In the five-part Gotham Central story Half a Life, his obsession turns destructive. He frames her for murder, outs her as a lesbian, and arranges a prison escape that makes her a fugitive, hoping she will be left with nothing but him. Rucka said of them: "It's never been just cop-and-criminal between them." Rucka reunited the pair in Convergence: The Question in 2015, where Renee stops a remorseful Harvey from killing himself and urges him to be a good man.

  5150898859

• 7. Falls and Relapses

  ›

  Batman: Hush, in 2002, shows Dent's face repaired by plastic surgery, which seems to wipe out Two-Face. Dent still takes the law into his own hands twice. He uses his legal skill to free the Joker, and he shoots the serial killer Hush. Gotham's prosecutors will not charge him without a body, so he manipulates the courts into letting him go.

  The next fall comes in Face the Face, which begins in Detective Comics #817 as part of DC's One Year Later storyline. At Batman's request, Dent becomes Gotham's protector during Batman's absence of nearly a year, which Batman presents as atonement for his past crimes. After a month of training, they fight Firebug and Mr. Freeze before Batman leaves. Dent's methods grow more extreme than Batman's. When Batman returns, Dent feels unnecessary, and the Two-Face persona comes back as hallucinations only Dent sees and hears.

  Then come the murders. KGBeast, Magpie, the Ventriloquist and Scarface, and Orca are all shot twice in the head with a double-barreled pistol, and they seem to be Two-Face's work. Asked to confirm he was not responsible, Dent will not give a definite answer, and he blows up a bomb in his apartment to flee. Batman later finds evidence that clears him. The killings were a frame-up, arranged as revenge by the new crime boss Warren White, the Great White Shark. But Dent, resentful and paranoid, has already scarred half his face with nitric acid and a scalpel. He threatens to destroy the Gotham Zoo, which has two of every animal, including two humans, then escapes.

  In September 2011, the New 52 reboot changed his origin. Dent is a defense attorney whose clients include the McKillen crime family twins, Shannon and Erin. After a contract is placed on Gordon and his family, Bruce Wayne funds Dent's campaign for district attorney. Dent wins and sends the sisters to prison for life. Shannon takes her own life, and Erin escapes by swapping places with her sister's corpse. She breaks into Dent's house, kills Gilda in front of him, and pours acid on his face. Years later, Erin returns to Gotham to kill Two-Face. He scars her with the same acid, and Batman stops him from killing her. Two-Face then calls Batman "Bruce," revealing he knows the secret.

  Snyder's My Own Worst Enemy, in All-Star Batman during the 2016 DC Rebirth, sends Batman on a road trip to obtain a cure for Dent. The cure Batman offers turns out to be a sedative. In Deface the Face, Two-Face goes to Batman for help and says: "Harvey's the good one. He has to be. Otherwise, what am I?" The 2020 Detective Comics arc Ugly Heart shows Dent surviving an earlier suicide attempt and starting a cult called the Church of Two. Batman ends it with brain surgery that rids Dent of Two-Face.

  In 2024, as part of DC All In, Christian Ward wrote a Two-Face limited series with art by Fábio Veras. Ward had written the non-canon Batman: City of Madness, and DC approved a solo pitch set in the main Batman continuity. Inspired by Perry Mason, Ward puts Dent back in a courtroom, the Gotham underworld court called the White Church. He uses his criminology skill to settle the underworld's conflicts, while the tension between Dent and Two-Face remains.

  9293982627

• 8. Impostors and Echoes

  ›

  Wilkins, Harvey Dent's butler, is the first of the false Two-Faces. He uses makeup to suggest Dent has relapsed, which gives him cover to commit crimes. The second is Paul Sloane, an actor disfigured on the set of a film biography about Two-Face. A jealous prop boy replaced the water meant for a trial scene with real acid. Sloane's mind snaps and he starts to believe he is Dent. Batman tricks him into a reconstructive surgery that cures his mental illness. Later Earth-Two stories reuse Sloane as Two-Face, while their Harvey Dent stays healed.

  After Crisis on Infinite Earths, Sloane returns with a near-identical history in Detective Comics #580-581. In Double Image, the real Dent hires the Crime Doctor to disfigure Sloane again, out of jealous bitterness. He hopes Sloane will commit crimes based on the number two and confuse Batman. In February 2003, Detective Comics #777 reintroduced Sloan as the Charlatan. Six villains hire him to impersonate Two-Face in a plot against Batman: the Joker, Penguin, Riddler, Mad Hatter, Scarecrow, and Killer Moth. They had first offered the role to Two-Face, but his coin landed on the unscarred side. Batman exposes the fake when he kills a security guard without consulting a coin. The real Two-Face then captures Sloan and disfigures him, and the Scarecrow tests fear toxins on him. Driven mad and fearless, Sloan becomes the Charlatan and is defeated and locked in Arkham Asylum.

  The third impostor, George Blake, is a petty criminal who poses as the manager of an anti-crime exhibition. His makeup sits on the opposite side of his face from Dent's and Sloane's, which lets Batman spot him at once. Batman defeats Blake and clears Dent's name.

  A stranger echo comes in Batman #700, which establishes Terry McGinnis as part of the DC Universe canon. There, Two-Face-Two kidnaps Terry and Professor Carter Nichols and tries to disfigure them in the style of the Joker. Damian Wayne, the fifth Robin, foils him. Unlike the original, this man was born deformed and flips two coins, and a falling machine kills him. In the DC One Million storyline, another Two-Face-Two is mentioned. The Batman of the 853rd century says that a Batman defeated him by arguing that the law of averages guaranteed more good decisions than bad ones.

  The alternate universes stretch even further. In The Dark Knight Returns, plastic surgery heals Dent's face but destroys his personality. In Catwoman: Guardian of Gotham, Darcy Dent is a gender-flipped version, scarred when a rival laces her facial cream with acid; she does not use coin flips. The Tangent Comics line reimagines Dent as an African-American man with psionic powers. In Flashpoint, he is a judge, and in the sequel Flashpoint Beyond, his wife Gilda becomes Two-Face after the Joker kidnaps their children. In the Absolute Universe, Bane cracks Harvey's skull in two. In Batman: Earth One, Sal Maroni kills Harvey Dent, and his sister Jessica Dent takes up the role, developing a split personality modeled on her dead brother.

  9495969945