Toronto Argonauts

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Toronto Argonauts were founded on the 4th of October 1873, making them the oldest professional sports team in North America still playing under their original name. That is not a boast drawn from some corner of the record books. It is a fact with no asterisk. The Atlanta Braves of Major League Baseball are older, but they changed both their name and their city more than once. The Argonauts have been the Argonauts, in Toronto, without interruption, for more than 150 years.

  They play Canadian football, a game that does not look like American football but grew from the same soil. Twelve men per side, three downs to gain ten yards, end zones that stretch a full 20 yards deep. The game itself traces back to a modified English rugby that spread through Canadian cities in the 1860s, but the Argonauts' specific origin is even stranger: a rowing club decided to form a football team so its athletes had something to do in the off-season.

  That rowing club gave the team its name, drawn from Greek mythology. Jason and the Argonauts sailed aboard the Argo to find the Golden Fleece. The rowers of Toronto loved the nautical association. They adopted it in 1872, founded the football club a year later, and a century and a half of wins, collapses, ownership dramas, and championship comebacks followed.

  The Argonauts have won the Grey Cup, Canadian football's championship game, a record 19 times. They have the best winning percentage in that game of any franchise in the league. They have faced every western team the league currently fields. And yet they have also spent decades at the very bottom of their division, been owned by a convicted fraudster, nearly folded under a mountain of debt, and consistently drawn the smallest home crowds in the league. How one club can hold both of those realities at once is the story worth telling.

• 2. Born From Oars

  ›

  The Argonaut Rowing Club formed its rugby-football squad on the 4th of October 1873, with a one-dollar subscription fee per player. Their first game was against a club from Hamilton on October 18 of that year. They won. H.T. Glazebrook was their first captain and head coach, and the club's formal establishment a year later, on the 17th of September 1874, set the foundation for what would become the longest-running franchise name in North American professional sport.

  The colours of the team trace back to England. In the 19th century, the most renowned rowing clubs in the world belonged to the University of Oxford and the University of Cambridge. Many of the Toronto rowers had connections to those institutions, and they adopted the light blue of Cambridge alongside the dark blue of Oxford. The footballers inherited those colours. The phrase "double blue" became synonymous with the team and, in time, blue became the traditional colour of top-level Toronto sports franchises more broadly.

  The name itself carries mythological weight. According to legend, Jason and the Argonauts were a band of heroes who sailed the ship Argo in search of the Golden Fleece, sometime before the Trojan War. A group of Toronto amateur rowers adopted the name in 1872, and the football club followed a year later. The Argonaut Rowing Club, which gave the team its identity, still exists today. The team's current helmet design reflects those nautical roots: a Cambridge blue background with a logo depicting a boat incorporating a football.

  The team's first recorded home was Rosedale Field, near Mount Pleasant Road and MacLennan Avenue. The site hosted the very first Grey Cup game in 1909, with the Canadian Football League listing the attendance at 3,807 people. That field still exists as part of Rosedale Park, though the grandstands are long gone.

• 3. Building the Game

  ›

  The Argonauts did not merely participate in Canadian football's early decades. They were present at the moments that shaped the sport into what it is today. In 1883, the Toronto Football Club joined with other Ontario city teams and university squads from Queen's University and Royal Military College to form the Ontario Rugby Football Union, the first rugby football organization in North America with a league and playoff structure.

  Starting in 1884, a Dominion Championship pitted the best of the eastern and western leagues against each other. The Montreal Football Club defeated the Toronto Football Club in that first true national championship on the 6th of November 1884, by a score of 30-0. The Argonauts did not earn the title of national champion until their first Grey Cup win in 1914, when they defeated the University of Toronto 14-2. Their star that year was Jack O'Connor, a runner and kicker who scored a league-record 44 points in a single championship season.

  Over those three decades from 1880 onward, the rules of the game changed incrementally. The line of scrimmage was adopted, scoring evolved toward its modern form, and the Burnside rules introduced the structure of ten yards in three downs that now defines Canadian football at every level. These were contentious changes. The dispute over the Burnside rules created serious disagreement between Ontario, Quebec, and the intercollegiate league. The professionalism debate was so sharp that the Argonauts withdrew from the Canadian Rugby Union entirely in 1903.

  Player-coach Joe Wright Sr. was among the popular personalities of this era, considered one of the best all-around Canadian athletes at the turn of the century. The Argonauts merged with the Toronto Football Club in 1905, and W.A. Hewitt managed the club until 1907, also serving as vice-president of the ORFU and pushing for uniform rules across governing bodies. When the CRU declined to adopt the snap-back system of play, it was Hewitt's motion that sent the ORFU to adopt the CRU rules in 1906, one small step in the long process of standardizing a game still finding its shape.

• 4. Dynasties and Dark Ages

  ›

  Lionel Conacher, known as the "Big Train" and considered one of Canada's greatest ever sportsmen, led the Argonauts to two perfect 6-0 seasons in 1921 and 1922. In 1921 alone he accounted for 85 of his team's 167 points and 15 of the points in the Grey Cup, a 23-0 victory over the Edmonton Eskimos. That game was the first east-west Grey Cup championship in Canadian history.

  From 1933 to 1941, coach Lew Hayman ran the team with a winning ratio of 45-15-2, a record that has never been matched in the franchise's history. The team won eight of twenty Grey Cups between 1933 and 1952, including back-to-back titles in 1937 and 1938. The Stukus brothers, Annis, Bill, and Frank, were a potent all-purpose trio during those championship years. Joe "King" Krol and Royal Copeland, known as the Gold Dust Twins, led the Argos to a Grey Cup threepeat between 1945 and 1947, threatening from every position: running, passing, catching, kicking, and playing defence.

  In 1948, the team signed Ken Whitlock, their first Black player, though he played only four games as a halfback and punter before being released. His signing opened a new era for player acquisitions. By 1949 and 1950, the team had begun large-scale importation of American players for the first time, and in 1950 they signed Ulysses "Crazy Legs" Curtis, their second ever Black player, who went on to play five strong years as their featured running back. Coach Frank Clair took the team to Grey Cup wins in 1950 and 1952, including the notorious Mud Bowl, a 13-0 victory over Winnipeg played in conditions so foul that one Winnipeg player reportedly came close to drowning in the muck at Varsity Stadium.

  The crash that followed the 1952 championship was severe. A year after winning the Grey Cup, the Argos fell to dead last. The three decades after 1952 have been called the team's Dark Ages. A salary cap introduced in 1953 stripped them of talented players. Management under new owner John W.H. Bassett was blamed for trading away young talent and cycling through coaches at a rapid rate. The team went 31 years without a championship, and for the first 19 of those years rarely advanced past the second round of the playoffs. Their all-time low came in 1981 when they finished 2-14, having begun the year 0-10. By that point the notion of an "Argo Bounce," the team's historic reputation for lucky breaks, had inverted: the phrase now described the Argonauts' uncanny ability to lose critical games in the dying minutes by committing an improbable blunder.

• 5. Hollywood, Heartbreak, Ownership Chaos

  ›

  In 1991, three names transformed the Argonauts from a struggling franchise into front-page news: Bruce McNall, owner of the NHL's Los Angeles Kings, bought the team. Hockey great Wayne Gretzky became a minority owner. And Canadian-born comedian John Candy took a 20% share. The group stunned the league by signing Raghib "Rocket" Ismail for an unheard-of $18.2 million over four years.

  Ismail delivered immediately, particularly on kickoff returns, and was named player of the game in the 1991 Grey Cup, which the Argonauts won 36-21 over the Calgary Stampeders. Quarterback Matt Dunigan played that final with a broken collarbone. Michael "Pinball" Clemons, who had set a CFL record for all-purpose yards with 3,300 in his first full season in 1990, was another critical piece of that championship.

  The era lasted just over three years. McNall concluded he could no longer justify the losses from an asset 3,000 miles from his base in Los Angeles. He sold to the Labatt Brewing Company in May 1994 for $4.5 million. The closing of that deal was delayed by John Candy's unexpected death in March of that year. McNall confessed to conspiracy and fraud later in 1994; the sale would likely have been forced regardless. Attendance collapsed in the mid-1990s, with per-game averages just above 16,000 in 1994 and 1995, less than half the team's 1970s peak.

  In July 2003 the CFL stripped control of the team from owner Sherwood Schwarz entirely. The club had accumulated debts of over $20 million, including $17.4 million owed to Schwarz himself. New ownership under David Cynamon and Howard Sokolowski brought an immediate turnaround and a Grey Cup win in 2004, with veteran Damon Allen leading a 27-19 victory over the B.C. Lions. Allen continued with the team until 2007, retiring with professional football's all-time leading passing yardage total of 72,381. Doug Flutie, signed in 1996 under coach Don Matthews, had meanwhile set team records for single-season passing yards with more than 5,500 in each of 1996 and 1997, and for touchdowns thrown with 47 in 1997, one short of his own CFL record of 48. The back-to-back Grey Cups those years were the franchise's last before a long lean stretch.

• 6. The Attendance Paradox

  ›

  Regular season average attendance at Exhibition Stadium reached 47,356 per game in 1976, a figure driven partly by the stadium's enlargement to accommodate the Blue Jays expansion baseball team arriving in 1977. That peak came during one of the worst stretches in team history, with the Argonauts posting consistent losing records throughout the decade. Toronto was filling the seats even when the team gave them little reason to.

  The subsequent decades reversed that relationship almost completely. Since 2015, the Argonauts have averaged the lowest home attendance in the CFL every year. Their lowest average in a non-pandemic year was 12,431 in 2015. This figure stands in hard contrast to what the team was achieving on the field: Grey Cup championships in 2012, 2017, 2022, and 2024. A franchise winning at historic rates was struggling to fill its stadium.

  Part of the stadium problem was structural. Rogers Centre, where the Argonauts played from 1989 to 2015, seats up to 50,000 people. Even crowds of about 30,000 looked sparse inside it. The move to BMO Field in 2016 was meant to fix this. The $120 million renovation raised the stadium's capacity to 25,000 in CFL configuration, with temporary endzone seating expandable to 40,000 for major events like a Grey Cup. The renovation included an unusual compromise: end zones only 18 yards deep rather than the standard 20, with parts of both end zones covered in artificial turf while the remainder of the field uses natural grass.

  Varsity Stadium, the team's home through its great dynasties of the 1930s and 1940s, still holds the record for hosting the most Grey Cups with 30. A plan to revamp it for CFL-sized crowds was blocked by community opposition in 2004. The following year the Argonauts withdrew from an alternative proposal at York University. The BMO Field move remained the only viable path, and it was finalized on the 20th of May 2015, concurrent with the sale to Maple Leaf Sports and Entertainment's Larry Tanenbaum and Bell Canada.

• 7. The Grey Cup Record

  ›

  Nineteen Grey Cup championships, the most of any franchise in the CFL. A .760 winning percentage in the championship game, also the best in the league. Eight consecutive victories in Grey Cup appearances, a streak that dates to 1987, when the Argonauts lost 38-36 to the Edmonton Eskimos in Vancouver. Every Grey Cup appearance since that loss has ended with a Toronto victory.

  The 2017 title is perhaps the most improbable entry on that list. The team hired former Montreal Alouettes general manager Jim Popp and head coach Marc Trestman on the 28th of February 2017, after a front-office purge that saw general manager Jim Barker fired on January 24 and head coach Scott Milanovich resign four days later to join the Jacksonville Jaguars. Popp and Trestman had together won consecutive Grey Cups with Montreal in 2009 and 2010. Despite missing most of free agency and assembling roster and coaching staff on short notice, the Double Blue finished 9-9, good enough for first in a weak East Division. They came back in the last minute to defeat Saskatchewan 25-21 in the Eastern Final, then won their 17th championship 27-24 over Calgary in what the source describes as true Cinderella fashion.

  The most recent championship came on the 17th of November 2024, in Vancouver, the 111th Grey Cup. The Argonauts defeated the Winnipeg Blue Bombers 41-24, their second title in three seasons. Head coach Ryan Dinwiddie, appointed after the 2019 season, led the team to victories in both 2022 and 2024. The 2022 title, a 24-23 win over the same Winnipeg Blue Bombers in Regina, was the franchise's 18th. Current general manager Mike "Pinball" Clemons, appointed in October 2019, has overseen both championships. Clemons previously set a CFL record for all-purpose yards in 1997 with 3,840, won three Grey Cups as a player, coached the team from 2000 to 2007, and has his number 31 retired by the franchise, making him one of only four players to receive that distinction.