Thomas Lucy

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Sir Thomas Lucy was knighted in 1565 not by Queen Elizabeth herself, but by her favourite, Robert Dudley, the 1st Earl of Leicester, acting at the queen's behest. That detail tells you something about where Lucy stood in the world: close enough to power to receive its favours, but always one step removed from the centre. He was a magistrate and Member of Parliament for Warwickshire, a man of property and Protestant conviction, a pursuer of Catholics and a keeper of game. He might have faded entirely from history were it not for one lasting connection. A young playwright from Stratford-upon-Avon, William Shakespeare, may have clashed with Lucy, mocked him in a ballad, poached from his estate, and eventually satirised him on the London stage. Whether any of that is true is a question scholars have argued over for centuries. What is certain is that Lucy and Shakespeare occupied the same Warwickshire world at a charged and dangerous moment in English history.

• 2. Charlecote and the Lucy Line

  ›

  Thomas Lucy was born on the 24th of April 1532 as the eldest son of William Lucy of Charlecote near Stratford-on-Avon. His father died in 1551, and the inheritance was substantial. Lucy took on Charlecote Park, Sherborne, and Hampton Lucy, and through his marriage he added Sutton Park in Worcestershire. The family traced their origins to the Anglo-Norman de Lucy line, a pedigree that stretched back well before the Tudor period. On his father's side, his grandmother was Elizabeth Empson, daughter of Richard Empson, one of Henry VII's chief ministers. Charlecote Park was rebuilt for Lucy in red brick around 1558 by a builder known as John of Padua, also recorded as John Thorpe. Queen Elizabeth herself visited the park in 1572, the year after Lucy first entered Parliament.

• 3. Protestant Zeal and Catholic Enemies

  ›

  John Foxe, who had witnessed the persecution of Protestants under Queen Mary, spent time as a tutor in the Lucy household around 1547. That early proximity to Protestant martyrology seems to have shaped Lucy's outlook. He became a loyal defender of Queen Elizabeth and an ardent Protestant activist, and he took his religious duties into the courts and the countryside with considerable force. When the Jesuit missionary Edmund Campion moved through the region, Lucy arrested and interrogated Catholic families in the area. After John Somerville plotted against the queen's life in 1582, and Edward Arden was arrested as a conspirator, Lucy raided homes of the Arden family, the very family to whom Shakespeare was related on his mother's side. Lucy later took his share in Arden's arrest in 1583. In 1584, a dispute arose between Ananias Nason, one of Lucy's servants, and Hamnet Sadler, a known friend of Shakespeare's; Lucy arbitrated between them.

• 4. The Poaching Legend

  ›

  Richard Davies, writing in the late 17th century, was the first to set down the claim that the young Shakespeare had stolen venison and rabbits from Lucy's estate. Davies wrote that Lucy "oft had him whipped and sometimes imprisoned" and eventually drove him to flee Warwickshire. Shakespeare's first biographer, Nicholas Rowe, went further, linking the poaching to a bitter ballad that Shakespeare supposedly wrote in retaliation. Rowe described the ballad as so sharp that it intensified the prosecution against Shakespeare and forced him to leave his family and business and shelter himself in London. No surviving legal record confirms or disproves any of this. Lucy had introduced a bill into Parliament in 1585 concerning game preservation, which at least establishes his interest in the matter. The story gained considerable cultural traction in the Victorian period, appearing in numerous illustrations and paintings. In 1834, Walter Savage Landor published a piece called Citation and Examination of William Shakespeare, presenting an imagined interrogation of Shakespeare by Lucy, who is portrayed as a mildly pretentious figure longing for the days when social classes knew their place. Critics of the poaching story point out that there were no deer kept at Charlecote until after Shakespeare's death, and Edmond Malone argued that Lucy did not own a licensed deer park at the relevant time. Samuel Schoenbaum, however, noted that Lucy held a free warren, which could have supported rabbits, hares, pheasants, and other birds, as well as larger animals including roe deer.

• 5. Ballads and Mockery

  ›

  Two ballads mocking Lucy circulated in Stratford and were written down by collectors in the late 17th century. One turns his surname into an insult with the lines: "A parliament member, a justice of peace, / At home a poor scarecrow, at London an ass, / If lousy is Lucy as some folks miscall it / Then Lucy is lousy whatever befall it." The second ballad, noted by Edmond Malone, appeared to ridicule Lucy's marriage and was still being sung in Stratford around 1687-90 when Joshua Barnes heard it and wrote it down. There is no evidence that Shakespeare wrote either ballad.

• 6. Justice Shallow and the Luces

  ›

  The theory that Shakespeare satirised Lucy through the character of Justice Shallow dates to roughly 1688-1700, when Davies noted that Lucy "is his Justice Clodpate" and claimed that, in allusion to Lucy's name, the character bears three louses on his arms. Justice Shallow appears in both Henry IV, Part 2 and The Merry Wives of Windsor. The Merry Wives contains a scene in which Shallow and his dim-witted relative Slender discuss the luces, meaning pike fish, in their coat of arms; the pun collapses into lice when it becomes a "dozen white louses". Lucy's actual coat of arms did contain luces. Samuel Schoenbaum argued against a direct parody, asking why Shakespeare would risk offending well-placed friends of a man who had served the state. Schoenbaum also observed that in physical form, social condition, and personality, Lucy was nothing like the Shallow of Henry IV, Part 2. Leslie Hotson proposed a different target altogether: William Gardiner, a corrupt Justice of the Peace whose coat of arms also contained luces, and with whom Shakespeare had come into conflict during Gardiner's attempts to close the Swan Theatre. Hotson allowed that Shakespeare may have remembered the luces-louses pun from anti-Lucy jokes circulating in Stratford.

• 7. Final Years and Legacy

  ›

  Lucy married Joyce Acton, daughter of Thomas Acton of Sutton, Worcestershire. Their daughter Anne married Sir Edward Aston of Tixall, and she became the mother of Walter Aston, 1st Lord Aston of Forfar, a diplomat. Lucy served as high sheriff of Warwickshire in 1586 and appeared regularly at Stratford-upon-Avon as justice of the peace and commissioner of musters. He died on the 7th of July 1600, in the middle of a local scandal: one of his granddaughters had eloped with a family servant, and the humiliation was still fresh when he died. His son inherited the estate, and his grandson Thomas would also serve as MP for Warwickshire, carrying the family's political presence into the next generation.