The Dish

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Dish is a 2000 Australian historical comedy-drama film about a radio telescope in the small town of Parkes, New South Wales, and the night its operators kept a dish pointed at the Moon in winds that could have brought the whole structure crashing down. On that night in July 1969, the world was watching the first human beings walk on another world. What many people did not know was that the pictures they saw very nearly did not arrive at all.

  The film plants two questions early. First: how did a quiet Australian country town end up at the center of one of history's defining moments? Second: what does it take to keep a secret from NASA while simultaneously saving the mission? The answers involve a power cut, a wrongly maintained generator, a carefully told lie, and a wind that kept climbing past the safety limit.

• 2. The Town and the Dish

  ›

  Parkes mayor Bob had played a personal role in securing the dish's construction in his town, and he knew what its prominence in the Moon landing could mean for his political future. When news spread that the Parkes Radio Telescope would serve as a primary receiving antenna for Neil Armstrong's first steps, major dignitaries descended on the sleepy community, including the U.S. Ambassador and Australia's Prime Minister.

  The dish's regular staff, Mitch, Glenn, and their supervisor Cliff, found their working lives transformed overnight. NASA sent a liaison named Al Burnett to work alongside them. Mitch took Al's presence as an insult, reading it as proof that NASA thought the Australians were incompetent and unreliable. Cliff disagreed: he told Mitch that Al was there simply to make sure the Moon landing went smoothly, and that the hostility was unwarranted. That tension between the two men would be tested sooner than either of them expected.

• 3. The Power Cut

  ›

  A blackout hit Parkes, and when it did, the dish's backup generator failed. Mitch had run a maintenance procedure on it incorrectly, and now the station's tracking computers had lost all their programming. The dish could no longer locate the signal from Command Module Columbia.

  Houston noticed the silence from Parkes and asked what was happening. Rather than admit the mistake and risk being demoted from their role in the mission, Cliff told NASA the dish was receiving a clear signal. Al Burnett, the NASA liaison who had come to watch over them, reluctantly backed the lie. Mitch then went to Al and confessed his own responsibility for the generator failure. Al forgave him immediately. That single exchange dissolved the friction between them, and all four men turned their full attention to the problem of finding Apollo 11 again. After several hours and further setbacks, they locked onto the spacecraft's signal with only minutes to spare before their scheduled shift as primary receiver was due to begin.

• 4. Wind at 30 Knots

  ›

  After the Lunar Module Eagle landed on the Moon, Cliff noticed the wind was strengthening. The station's regulations were clear: if the wind reached 30 knots, the dish had to be stowed, meaning it could not be pointed at the Moon, and the video feed of Armstrong's first steps would be lost. Circumstances on that night made Parkes the only antenna on Earth in a position to receive the historic footage.

  The wind reached 30 knots. Then it kept climbing. All four men at the station, Cliff, Mitch, Glenn, and Al, chose to keep the dish aimed at the Moon. They were risking the total collapse of the structure and their own lives to do it. The dish withstood winds of over 60 mph, which works out to 52 knots, and the footage of humanity's first moonwalk reached the world. A title card at the film's end confirms this detail.

• 5. What Really Happened

  ›

  The film is honest about where it departs from history. NASA's Honeysuckle Creek antenna near Canberra, and the Goldstone station in California, both had the signal before Parkes did. Armstrong's actual first step, along with his words "That's one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind", was received by the Honeysuckle Creek antenna, not by Parkes. Parkes's signal was used eight and a half minutes after the moonwalk began.

  No power failure occurred at Parkes during the real mission. There was no friction with NASA, and the real NASA contingent consisted of several representatives, not just one. Prime Minister John Gorton visited Honeysuckle Creek that night, not Parkes. What the film does preserve accurately is the wind: the real dish operated at 60 degrees inclination in gusts reaching 110 km/h, which converts to 59 knots, and the team kept it running despite the risk of damage to the antenna and injury to themselves. The full Moon shown in the film in the two weeks before the landing is also an invention; the actual Moon was not full during that period.

• 6. Making the Film

  ›

  Rob Sitch directed the film, which was written by Santo Cilauro, Tom Gleisner, Jane Kennedy, and Sitch himself. Much of the production was shot on location: the cricket match and hayride sequences were filmed on and around the real Parkes dish, and researchers at the observatory sometimes postponed their experiments to let the production team position the antenna for photography.

  The interior control room set was built to an extreme level of period accuracy, down to details as small as ashtrays. Some of the objects on set were not props at all but original NASA equipment from the Apollo 11 mission, left in Australia after the landing because the cost of shipping them back to the United States was prohibitive. Former Parkes staff who had worked there during the actual 1969 mission visited the set and said the experience was like stepping through a time warp. The majority of the non-telescope scenes were shot not in Parkes itself but in the nearby town of Forbes, 33 km to the south, chosen for its historic buildings. Additional filming took place at Old Parliament House in Canberra and at Crawford Studios in Melbourne.

• 7. Reception and Legacy

  ›

  The Dish opened in Australia on the 19th of October 2000, preceded by three days of paid previews. Its four-day opening weekend set a record for an Australian film at the time, with a gross of $2.98 million from 281 screens. Including the preview period, that figure rose to $4.3 million, equivalent to US$2.25 million. The film went on to earn $17,999,473 at the Australian box office, making it the top-grossing Australian film in Australia that year.

  On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds a 96% approval rating based on 99 reviews, with an average score of 7.4 out of 10. The site's critics consensus describes it as a feel-good film without an excess of sentimentality. The closing scene, in which the technician hints to an elderly Cliff that his face might be familiar from the visitor centre display, leaves one specific question open: how much of the truth about that November night, the lie to Houston, the failed generator, the wind at 52 knots, ever made it into the official record.