The Cranes Are Flying

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Cranes Are Flying opened on Soviet screens in 1957 and almost immediately made the world reconsider what a war film could be. Directed by Mikhail Kalatozov at Mosfilm, written by Viktor Rozov, and starring Aleksey Batalov and Tatiana Samoilova, it is a story that begins on the morning of the 22nd of June, 1941 -- the very day Germany invaded the Soviet Union. Two young people in Moscow are watching cranes drift across a sunrise sky, and within hours their world is gone. What followed on screen was something Soviet audiences had not seen before: a heroine who is flawed, a war that is brutal, and a love story that refuses a clean ending. One year after the film's release, it walked away with the Palme d'Or at the 1958 Cannes Film Festival, an honour no Soviet film has claimed before or since. How did a state-produced film from behind the Iron Curtain conquer the most celebrated stage in Western cinema? And what made its lead actress Tatiana Samoilova so striking that a French critic set her against Brigitte Bardot -- and meant it as a compliment to Samoilova?

• 2. A War Told Through One Woman

  ›

  Veronika's story opens in peacetime joy and closes in public grief, and the distance between those two moments is the film's whole argument. On the morning Germany invades, she and her boyfriend Boris are still slipping quietly back to their separate apartments after watching cranes together. Hours later, Boris has volunteered for the front. His grandmother presses a stuffed squirrel into Veronika's hands -- "squirrel" was Boris's pet name for her -- with a love note tucked inside it. Veronika arrives at the assembly station too late to see him march off. Her parents are then killed in a German air raid that destroys their building, leaving her an orphan absorbed into Boris's family. Film scholar Josephine Woll has argued that Veronika was instrumental in shaping post-Stalin Soviet cinema by heralding more complicated, multi-dimensional celluloid heroines. Where earlier Soviet war films often centred on collective heroism, Kalatozov and Rozov fixed their camera on one young woman's interior collapse and slow reassembly. The damage done to ordinary people -- not soldiers on a battlefield but civilians in Moscow apartments -- became the film's subject.

• 3. Betrayal and Survival

  ›

  Boris's cousin Mark tells Veronika he loves her while she is still waiting faithfully for Boris to return. When an air raid traps them alone in the apartment, Mark rapes her. The film does not flinch from this. Veronika and Mark then marry, but she despises him, and the family despises her in return, convinced she has betrayed Boris. At the front, Boris himself is shown dying: he saves a comrade named Volodya from another soldier's argument, is shot, and in his final moments has a vision of the wedding that will never happen. The film holds both threads simultaneously -- his death and her survival -- without resolving the moral weight between them. Guilt overwhelms Veronika to the point where she tries to throw herself before a train. She stops only because she spots a young child about to be struck by a car. The boy's name, as she soon learns, is also Boris. Fyodor, Boris's father, eventually uncovers that Mark bribed his way out of conscription into the Red Army, exposing his cowardice. Mark is expelled from the family, and Veronika is forgiven. The forgiveness arrives quietly, without ceremony, which makes it feel earned rather than staged.

• 4. Samoilova Crosses Europe

  ›

  Tatiana Samoilova was frequently identified with her role, and that identification traveled far beyond the Soviet Union. She took Europe by storm after the film's release, in the words of Josephine Woll. A commentator for the French Liberation contrasted Samoilova's purity and authenticity favourably with that of Brigitte Bardot, then at the height of her fame as a French cultural icon. East German fans gave Samoilova a watch at a festival, engraved with the words: "Finally we see on the Soviet screen a face, not a mask." At the 1958 Cannes Film Festival, she received a Special Mention for her performance alongside the film's Palme d'Or. The 12th British Academy Film Awards nominated her for Best Foreign Actress. That a Soviet actress could move audiences in Paris, East Berlin, and London with the same performance, while playing a character who is raped, pressured into marriage, and nearly driven to suicide, marked a significant shift in how Western audiences were willing to engage with Soviet storytelling.

• 5. Cannes and the Palme d'Or

  ›

  At the 1958 Cannes Film Festival, The Cranes Are Flying won the Palme d'Or. It remains the only Soviet film ever to receive that distinction. The source draws an important distinction: in 1946, a Soviet film called The Turning Point was among eleven films that shared the Grand Prix, the award that preceded the Palme d'Or -- a group honour, not a singular one. The Cranes Are Flying stood alone. The 12th British Academy Film Awards also nominated the film for Best Film from any Source, a category that put it in competition with the full range of international cinema that year. For a film produced by a state studio -- Mosfilm -- to win the most prestigious prize at a Western festival during the Cold War was a cultural event that went beyond cinema. The film was also nominated at the British Academy Film Awards alongside Samoilova's individual nomination, giving it a foothold in two of the major Western film institutions at once.

• 6. A Miracle, Not Cinema

  ›

  French director Claude Lelouch placed The Cranes Are Flying in his personal "cinema pantheon" in his autobiography, alongside Citizen Kane and a film called Napoleon. He described it in terms that rejected conventional critical language: "It has not become outdated in any way, it is still magnificent. I have not seen a more beautiful film from Russia. I think I have not seen a better film in principle. Not cinema, but a miracle." That last phrase is the one that sticks. The film ends where it began: cranes flying over Moscow. Boris is confirmed dead. Veronika, clutching a bouquet she had intended for him, stumbles through a crowd celebrating the war's end in 1945. She begins handing her flowers to returning soldiers and their families. A comrade named Stepan gives a speech insisting that those who died will never be forgotten. The cranes return to the sky. The film does not offer resolution so much as it offers continuation -- the sense that the living must carry the dead forward, even in the middle of someone else's celebration. Volodya, the soldier Boris saved at the cost of his own life, has by then found Boris's family and joined it, a quiet human echo of what the war took and what it left behind.