Pastoral

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Pastoral is a genre built on a paradox. From ancient Greece to contemporary science fiction, it has survived for over two millennia by imagining the shepherd's life as one of ease, beauty, and erotic possibility. Yet its intended audience has almost never been a shepherd. The pastoral was always a city dweller's fantasy.

  At its core, the genre places herdsmen in idealized landscapes called loci amoeni, beautiful places, where the grinding realities of farm work dissolve into song contests, courtship, and philosophical musing. The setting is almost always Arcadia, the mythological homeland of the god Pan, treated as a kind of earthly Eden. The livestock are there, but they barely intrude. The shepherds, bearing Greek names like Corydon and Philomela, spend their time in near-perfect leisure.

  That contradiction, a rural fantasy produced for and consumed by urban readers, turns out to be generative rather than limiting. Critics from Friedrich Schiller to Raymond Williams have argued that the pastoral says more about the anxieties of city life than about anything that ever happened in a field. What drives so many centuries of writers to keep reimagining this fantasy? And what happens when the fantasy starts to crack?

• 2. Ancient Roots

  ›

  Hesiod's Works and Days is the earliest text the tradition claims as its ancestor. It describes a golden age when people lived in harmony with nature, a harmony the ancient Greeks already sensed was lost. That backward-looking grief, the feeling that the good life lies somewhere behind us, would become the emotional engine of the pastoral for the next two thousand years.

  Theocritus, the Hellenistic Greek poet, gave the pastoral its first recognizable literary form. Several of his Idylls are set in the countryside, probably drawing on the landscape of the island of Cos where he lived, and they stage dialogues between herdsmen who sing to each other and compete for small prizes. Theocritus may have drawn on authentic folk traditions of Sicilian shepherds. He wrote in the Doric dialect but chose the dactylic hexameter, the meter of Homer and Greek epic. That blend of rustic subject and sophisticated form became the pastoral's defining tension.

  The Roman poet Virgil then adapted Theocritus into Latin in his Eclogues, and the results were transformative. Virgil introduced two moves that would echo for centuries: the contrast between urban and rural lifestyles, and the use of pastoral as political allegory, most notably in Eclogues 1 and 4 respectively. Crucially, Virgil was the first poet to set his pastoral in Arcadia, the idealized location. Later Latin poets Calpurnius Siculus, Nemesianus, and the author or authors of the Einsiedeln Eclogues all modeled their pastoral verse principally on Virgil's Eclogues.

  Horace offered a more ironic angle in his Epodes. His poem Country Joys features Alfius, a usurer who dreams of escaping his hectic professional life for the countryside but is too consumed in his career to actually leave. The poem names what the pastoral almost never admits: for most of its readers, the rural retreat will stay a dream.

• 3. Renaissance Flowering

  ›

  Petrarch and Pontano helped revive the pastoral in Latin from the 14th century onward, before Italian poets including Sannazaro and Boiardo carried the form into the Italian vernacular. From Italy, the fashion spread across Renaissance Europe, reaching French court poets like Marot and Pierre de Ronsard, who was called the prince of poets in his own day.

  In England, Alexander Barclay wrote the first English pastorals, his Eclogues, around 1515, drawing heavily on the Italian poet Mantuan. The landmark, however, arrived in 1579, when Edmund Spenser published The Shepheardes Calender. Spenser organized his poem as twelve eclogues, one for each month of the year, and wrote in dialect. The collection wove together elegies, fables, and a sustained discussion of what poetry should do in contemporary England. Spenser and his friends appear in the text under pseudonyms; Spenser himself takes the name Colin Clout. Poets like Michael Drayton and William Browne subsequently imitated Spenser's model.

  The pastoral romance emerged in Italy as another new form entirely. Writers mixed pastoral poetry with prose narrative, drawing some inspiration from ancient Greek novels set in the countryside, such as Daphnis and Chloe, while having no classical precedent for the combination. The most influential example was Sannazaro's Arcadia in 1504. Within a century, the form had spread: Bernardim Ribeiro's Menina e Moca appeared in Portuguese in 1554, Montemayor's Diana in Spanish in 1559, Sir Philip Sidney's Arcadia in English in 1590, and Honoré d'Urfé's L'Astrée in French between 1607 and 1627.

  Pastoral drama arrived in Renaissance Italy around the same period. Poliziano's Orfeo in 1480 marked an early experiment in the form, and it reached its height in the late 16th century with Tasso's Aminta in 1573, Isabella Andreini's Mirtilla in 1588, and Guarini's Il pastor fido in 1590. John Lyly brought the Italian-style pastoral play to England in 1579 with Endimion. Shakespeare's As You Like It, whose plot derived from Thomas Lodge's pastoral romance Rosalynde, and The Winter's Tale both use pastoral elements extensively.

• 4. Pastoral Against Itself

  ›

  Christopher Marlowe's 1588 poem The Passionate Shepherd to His Love is one of the genre's most quoted works, but it bends the rules in a telling way. The shepherd speaker does not appeal to the simple pleasures of country life; instead, he tempts his love with luxurious urban goods, listing lined slippers, purest gold, silver dishes, and an ivory table. He takes a voyeuristic stance and does not actually interact with other shepherds or with nature itself. The poem is technically pastoral while quietly mocking the pastoral's own values.

  Sir Walter Raleigh answered it directly. His 1600 poem The Nymph's Reply to the Shepherd gives voice to a character who refuses the shepherd's idealization and instead insists on the true course of nature and its incompatibility with the love the shepherd imagines. Sir Philip Sidney also worked both sides of the divide. His prose romance Arcadia is full of pastoral landscape description, while two of his poems, The Twenty-Third Psalm and The Nightingale, take an explicitly anti-pastoral view, presenting nature as something to be protected from rather than retreated into.

  Terry Gifford later formalized this counter-tradition, defining the anti-pastoral in his 2012 essay Pastoral, Anti-Pastoral and Post-Pastoral as Reading Strategies as a correction of pastoral that emphasizes realism over romance, highlights tensions, disorder, and inequalities, challenges literary constructs as false distortions, and demythologizes locations like Arcadia and Shangri-La. In 1994 Gifford had already proposed the concept of a post-pastoral that does not simply succeed the pastoral but reaches beyond its constraints while preserving its core concerns. He described it as more about connection than the disconnections essential to the pastoral, and he gave examples including Cormac McCarthy's The Road from 2006, Margaret Atwood's The Year of the Flood from 2009, and Maggie Gee's The Ice People from 1999.

• 5. Country House and Elegy

  ›

  The 17th century saw English poets develop a variant known as the country house poem, which shifted the pastoral setting from open fields to landed estates. Emilia Lanier's The Description of Cooke-ham in 1611 described a woman through her relationship to an estate and its grief at her departure. In 1616 Ben Jonson wrote To Penshurst, addressing the estate owned by the Sidney family, celebrating its harmonious culture in iambic pentameter, and invoking Pan and Bacchus as suitable company for the manor.

  Andrew Marvell wrote Upon Appleton House in 1651 while employed as a tutor for Lord Fairfax's daughter Mary. The poem moved through the house, its history, its gardens, meadows, woods, the river, his pupil Mary, and the future, using nature as the thread tying the poem together. Marvell returned repeatedly to a comparison between nature and art, suggesting that art cannot on purpose achieve what nature accomplishes spontaneously.

  Robert Herrick's The Hock-cart, or Harvest Home took an unusual angle in the same century: it celebrated labor rather than leisure, painting the benefits of hard work instead of the effortless ease that pastoral convention usually staged. Raymond Williams later acknowledged Herrick's poem in his book The Country and the City.

  The pastoral elegy, one of the genre's most durable subgenres, used rural imagery to lament death. The most celebrated English example is John Milton's Lycidas from 1637, written on the death of Edward King, a fellow student at Cambridge University. Milton used the form to explore his own calling as a poet and to attack what he saw as abuses of the Church. Thomas Gray's Elegy in a Country Churchyard from 1750 also belongs to this line.

• 6. Pastoral in Music

  ›

  Theocritus's Idylls already contained strophic songs and musical laments, and in them, as in Homer, the shepherds play the syrinx, the pan flute considered the quintessentially pastoral instrument. Virgil's Eclogues were performed as sung mime in the first century, and there is evidence of the pastoral song as a recognized form in classical times.

  The pastoral genre shaped the development of opera in profound ways. Italian composers moved from polyphonic and then monodic madrigals that set pastoral poetry to larger forms like the cantata and the serenata, where pastoral themes remained a constant. The texts of over 500 madrigals were drawn from Guarini's Il pastor fido alone. As opera developed, it absorbed the pastoral directly: Jacopo Peri's Dafne and, most notably, Monteverdi's L'Orfeo were among the defining works. Pastoral opera remained popular throughout the 17th century across Europe, from French pastorale heroique to Henry Lawes's music for Milton's Comus and John Blow's Venus and Adonis in England, and the zarzuela in Spain.

  In the 18th century, Metastasio's libretto Il re pastore was set to music over 30 times, with Mozart's setting among the most famous. Rameau stood as an outstanding figure in French pastoral opera. Handel collaborated with John Gay on the sincere pastoral cantata Acis and Galatea, even though Gay had also satirized the pastoral in The Beggar's Opera.

  Beethoven wrote his Pastoral Symphony deliberately avoiding his usual dynamism in favor of slower rhythms. He labeled the work more the expression of feeling than realistic painting, signaling that the pastoral had shifted from landscape depiction to interior psychology. Wagner included the shepherd's alte Weise in Tristan und Isolde, and Tchaikovsky placed a pastoral ballet at the center of The Queen of Spades. In the 20th century, Maurice Ravel's Daphnis et Chloe, Debussy's Prelude a l'apres-midi d'un faune as choreographed by Nijinsky, and Stravinsky's Le sacre du printemps and Les Noces all extended the pastoral into ballet.

• 7. Critics and Theorists

  ›

  George Puttenham was among the first theorists to examine what the pastoral was actually doing. He did not see it as a straightforward record of rural life but as a vehicle for political discourse, arguing that it had a didactic duty to contain and enforme morall discipline for the amendment of mans behaviour.

  Friedrich Schiller connected the pastoral to childhood itself. For Schiller, nature presents the listener with an image of our infancy irrevocably past, tying the genre's nostalgia to something universal in human development. William Empson described the pastoral process as putting the complex into the simple and argued that good proletarian art is usually covert pastoral, using Soviet Russia's propaganda about the working class as his evidence. He also pointed to the double plot as a mechanism allowing writers to discuss controversial subjects without repercussions.

  Raymond Williams challenged the entire emotional foundation of the pastoral in The Country and the City. Williams argued that the pastoral's golden age of rural simplicity is a myth functioning as a memory, a literary construction rather than a historical fact. He traced how the city's economic relationship with the countryside generated social stratification there, with paper money bringing a hierarchy to the working system and encouraging the inheritance of titles and the making of family names.

  Paul Alpers, in his 1996 book What is Pastoral?, insisted that pastoral is best understood as a mode rather than a genre, defined by a humble attitude toward nature and by the recurring figure of simple herdsmen in pastoral encounters. He observed that pastoral lyrics allow a speaker to slip in and out of pastoral guise and reveal directly the sophistication which prompted him to assume it in the first place. Ken Hiltner, in What Else Is Pastoral?, pushed further, arguing that Renaissance pastoral is more often a form of nature writing than critics like Alpers acknowledge, and that historical records show many people at the time were genuinely aware of urban sprawl and attempted to stop it.