PanzerBlitz

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  PanzerBlitz arrived in 1970 with a set of components unlike anything wargamers had seen before: vehicle silhouettes instead of abstract military symbols, a board that could be rearranged into dozens of different battlefields, and a rulebook dense with technical data on tank weights, gun sizes, and crew sizes drawn from sources that had rarely reached civilian hands. Published by Avalon Hill, it sold 275,000 copies in its first quarter century, and its designer would later call it the most successful board wargame in the history of the hobby. But the numbers only hint at what made it matter. Here was a game that changed what players expected from the medium, introduced words into the hobby's vocabulary that are still used today, and drew a direct line of influence to games as far removed as SimCity. How did a tactical wargame about the Eastern Front of World War II become the best-selling title of an entire decade? And what did it get wrong that its successors spent years trying to fix?

• 2. A New Scale of War

  ›

  Before PanzerBlitz, board wargames dealt in large formations. Brigades, regiments, and divisions were the standard units; the soldier in the foxhole, the platoon holding a tree line, the tank crew sweating through a hull-down engagement were invisible at that altitude. PanzerBlitz changed the arithmetic. Each hex on the game board represented 250 meters of ground. A single turn covered 6 minutes of real time. The playing pieces stood for companies on the Soviet side and platoons on the German side, along with individual mechanized vehicles. That shift in scale carried a heavy technical obligation. The game packed in specifications for every major tank deployed on the Russian front: weight, speed, gun caliber, crew complement. Much of this data had not previously appeared in civilian publications; it lived in Army field manuals and partially classified intelligence reports. Designer Jim Dunnigan's notes warned players directly that the figures could not be taken at face value without understanding the design decisions behind them, a candid admission that the game was both a history lesson and an abstraction of one. The organizational detail ran deeper still, tracing units all the way down to mortar teams and the trucks and wagons that gave those units strategic flexibility in the field.

• 3. Geomorphic Boards and Open Design

  ›

  The physical presentation of PanzerBlitz became as influential as its rules. Armor units appeared as vehicle silhouettes rather than the standard military symbols that other games of the period used, a choice that linked the game visually to miniatures wargaming and reinforced Avalon Hill's reputation for quality components; the bookcase-style box was part of the same deliberate aesthetic. The mapboards, though, were the structural innovation. They could be arranged in various combinations to produce different battlefields, and from the moment PanzerBlitz shipped, wargamers began calling any modular game mapboard "geomorphic," adding what one account described as a new and peculiar meaning to a word borrowed from geology. Avalon Hill carried the approach forward into its later tactical titles, including Squad Leader, Panzer Leader, and The Arab-Israeli Wars, which added a beach board for invasion scenarios and a canal board representing the Suez Canal. The game also included instructions for constructing a Design-Your-Own scenario, labeled "Situation 13" to sit alongside the twelve published ones. The Designer's Notes even walked players through how many counters it would take to assemble a complete Soviet Tank Corps, though it simultaneously advised against the extravagance and urged players to keep counter density low. That open-ended approach made PanzerBlitz a system that could be replayed indefinitely rather than a fixed sequence of scenarios to work through once.

• 4. Jim Dunnigan and Poultron Press

  ›

  In 1969, Avalon Hill held a near-monopoly on the American wargame market, releasing roughly one game per year with expensive, well-produced components. Across town, at a small new publisher called Poultron Press, co-founder Jim Dunnigan was running a different experiment. His team produced a series of deliberately cheap "Test Series" games, featuring typewritten pages, hand-drawn maps, and thin paper counter sheets packed in plain manila envelopes, to test whether releasing many games per year could sustain a business. One of those test titles was Tactical Game 3, also called Test Series Game 3, which Dunnigan designed and sent to playtesters in 1969. Later that year, a second printing appeared as a free pull-out game in Issue 22 of Strategy and Tactics, Poultron Press's house magazine, making it the first tactical wargame in the history of modern board wargaming. Dunnigan then sold the rights to Tactical Game 3 to Avalon Hill in 1970, retaining royalty rights, and Avalon Hill relaunched it as PanzerBlitz with professionally designed components and twelve combat scenarios. Dunnigan later went on to create several PanzerBlitz-style games for his own company, Simulations Publications Inc., which Poultron Press had evolved into, including Combat Command, Panzer '44, and MechWar '77. Critic Heinz von Sieben noted that Dunnigan's later titles like KampfPanzer and Desert War attempted to fix PanzerBlitz's sequential turn structure by introducing simultaneous movement, but in doing so traded one problem for new difficulties of playability and bookkeeping.

• 5. The Panzerbush Problem

  ›

  Not every reviewer was enthusiastic about what the rules allowed. The most persistent criticism of PanzerBlitz centered on a gap between simulation and reality that players came to call the "Panzerbush Syndrome." A tank that ended its movement in a wooded hex became invisible to all enemy units except those directly adjacent to it, even if the tank had moved to that position in plain sight and had fired from it. Units could therefore hop from one wooded hex to the next without being targeted along the way, a pattern that struck players as deeply implausible and that earned the game a scornful nickname built on its own title. The game offered a cumbersome optional rule to address this, but it was widely considered inadequate. The companion games that followed, Panzer Leader and The Arab-Israeli Wars, introduced better solutions including optional opportunity fire and more realistic spotting rules; under those systems, a hidden unit that fired on the enemy became visible and could be fired upon in return. A separate exploit involved the game's trucks and wagons. Players discovered that a truck driven into woods and parked adjacent to an enemy tank could strip that tank of its invisibility, letting the truck's owner target it with other units. Trucks could also serve as roadblocks on roads because the overrun rule, which allowed tanks to move through hexes containing enemy units, applied only to clear terrain, and roads did not qualify. John Jackson, writing in A Player's Guide to Table Games, summarized the spotting problem by describing units as skulking from hex to hex without drawing the fire they would have earned in reality; he still rated the game as challenging and entertaining.

• 6. A Decade at the Top

  ›

  From 1970 to 1980, PanzerBlitz was the top-selling board wargame in North America. In September 1972, Don Turnbull writing in Issue 5 of the UK magazine Games and Puzzles called it his personal favourite and the game most suitable for a newcomer to the hobby, praising its variety, flexibility, realism, and playability. Nicholas Palmer, in his 1977 book The Comprehensive Guide to Board Wargaming, called it perhaps the most frequently played wargame ever produced. Games magazine placed PanzerBlitz in its Top 100 Games of 1980 list, describing it as the best-selling wargame ever published. Jon Freeman, in The Complete Book of Wargames published that same year, called it a watershed design and an enormously important game, singling out its treatment of the differences between armor and infantry and its development of a real sequence of play as contributions that nothing before it had matched. He rated it Very Good overall despite acknowledging the Panzerbush problem and issues with artillery effectiveness. By August 1996, a quarter century after publication, sales had reached 275,000 copies. In his 2000 book Wargames Handbook, Dunnigan put the figure at 320,000 units over 25 years, calling it an extraordinary sales figure. Computer Gaming World columnist Terry Coleman placed it second on the all-time list of best-selling board wargames, behind Axis and Allies. Heinz von Sieben, writing in Issue 28 of Simulacrum, drew a direct line from PanzerBlitz's popularity to the development of Squad Leader and Advanced Squad Leader, identifying it as the commercial and creative catalyst for the most successful tactical game systems that followed. SimCity designer Will Wright also listed PanzerBlitz as one of his influences, a connection that places its reach well outside the wargaming world.

• 7. Sequels and Legacy

  ›

  Avalon Hill built a small family of games around the PanzerBlitz system. Panzer Leader shifted the setting to the Western Front, while The Arab-Israeli Wars extended the timeline to cover the conflicts of 1956, 1967, and 1973. The designers calibrated The Arab-Israeli Wars so that its numerical values matched the same scales as the two World War II titles, meaning players could construct scenarios that mixed modern equipment with wartime hardware and still preserve the internal consistency of the system. Rights to PanzerBlitz eventually passed to Multi-Man Publishing, which released PanzerBlitz: Hill of Death in 2009, nearly four decades after the original appeared. The core design philosophy that Avalon Hill had prized since the beginning, placing playability and elegance above exact simulation, was baked into PanzerBlitz from its first printing and remained legible in every game that borrowed its innovations. The word "geomorphic," transplanted from geology into the wargaming lexicon by PanzerBlitz's modular mapboards, is still in use among tabletop wargamers today.