Pantheon Books

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Pantheon Books began its life in 1942 in New York City, founded by two refugees who had crossed an ocean to escape fascism and the Holocaust. Kurt and Helen Wolff brought with them a vision: introduce progressive European thought to American readers who had barely encountered it. What they built over the following decades would become one of the most contested properties in American publishing history. Who were the editors who shaped it? What happened when the profits-first era collided with a house built around ideas? And how did a small imprint become the unlikely center of a battle over what books get published at all?

• 2. The Wolff Vision

  ›

  Helen and Kurt Wolff arrived in the United States carrying an editorial philosophy that was genuinely unusual for the American market of the 1940s. Their early catalog reflected their sensibility immediately. Among the first works Pantheon issued was Zen and the Art of Archery by German scholar Eugen Herrigel, a book that introduced Eastern philosophy to readers who had no frame for it. They also took on the Bollingen series, which gathered C. G. Jung's collected works in English alongside books by noted Jungian scholars. The first complete English translation of the I Ching appeared under the Pantheon imprint, and so did Boris Pasternak's Doctor Zhivago. These were not commercial bets. They were acts of editorial conviction, grounded in the belief that ideas travel across borders and deserve an audience wherever they land. That founding philosophy would define what editors at Pantheon saw as their mission for decades to come, and it would eventually put them on a collision course with the corporate machinery that surrounded them.

• 3. The Schiffrin Years

  ›

  André Schiffrin arrived as executive editor in 1961, the same year Random House absorbed Pantheon into the Knopf Publishing Group. Random House itself had just bought Alfred A. Knopf in 1960, and the front page of the New York Times had described that merger as uniting two of the nation's most celebrated publishers of quality writing. Under Schiffrin, Pantheon published The Tin Drum by Günter Grass, who would later receive a Nobel Prize. Michel Foucault's Madness and Civilization appeared under the imprint, as did The Lover by Marguerite Duras and Adieux by Simone de Beauvoir. By the late 1960s, the list expanded to include American writers Noam Chomsky, James Loewen, and Studs Terkel, bringing their work to European readers as well. The editors at Pantheon prided themselves on something specific: subsidizing less commercially successful but socially or intellectually important works with the profits from books that sold better. They described themselves as publishing throughout the 1970s without a profit-and-loss sheet in sight. That arrangement depended on goodwill from above, and goodwill from above was not guaranteed. In 1965, RCA had purchased Random House. Then in 1980, RCA sold it to Samuel Irving Newhouse, Jr., and the pressure on Pantheon to produce stronger financial returns began to mount.

• 4. The 1990 Crisis

  ›

  Alberto Vitale replaced Robert L. Bernstein as chairman and president of Random House in December 1989. Vitale was a former banker, and his priorities showed. In February 1990, Schiffrin was asked to resign after he refused to reduce the number of titles published by Pantheon or to trim the imprint's thirty-member staff. The response was immediate. Editors and staff including Tom Engelhardt, Wendy Wolf, Sara Bershtel, Jim Peck, Susan Rabiner, David Sternbach, Helena Franklin, Diane Wachtell, and Gay Salisbury resigned in the months that followed. Authors whose books had appeared under Pantheon, Random House, and affiliated imprints gathered outside the Random House offices in March 1990. Studs Terkel, Kurt Vonnegut Jr., Princeton historian Arno Mayer, and Barbara Ehrenreich were among them. They argued that forcing out Schiffrin amounted to corporate censorship of the books that would not exist without him. At the March 1990 National Book Critics Circle award ceremony, novelist E. L. Doctorow used his acceptance speech for a fiction prize to criticize Random House for ousting Schiffrin. In the week following the protests, forty Random House editors and publishers signed a counter-statement defending the personnel changes, arguing that they had preserved their independence through fiscal responsibility and had never experienced censorship. A separate critic dismissed the protests and resignations as a specimen of people intoxicated by self-importance. The fight produced no clear winner, and the imprint continued under new editorial leadership.

• 5. Bertelsmann and the Bigger Picture

  ›

  In 1998, Random House changed hands again, this time purchased by Bertelsmann, the German media company that already owned Bantam Books, Doubleday Publishing, and Dell Publishing. The acquisition brought Pantheon Books, Modern Library, Times Books, Everyman's Library, Vintage Books, Crown Publishing Group, Schocken Books, Ballantine Books, Del Rey Books, and Fawcett Publications under one corporate roof, making Bertelsmann the largest publisher of American books and the largest publisher of English-language trade books overall. The Authors Guild argued to the Fair Trade Commission that the $1.4 billion acquisition would create a new economic behemoth capable of restricting readers' choices and authors' ability to market their work. Bertelsmann was allowed to make the purchase regardless. Schiffrin, still watching from the outside, noted that in the eight years since Vitale had taken over, Random House's literary translations and books of criticism, cultural history, and political analysis had been sacrificed to the bottom line. He published a memoir in 2000 titled The Business of Books: How International Conglomerates Took Over Publishing and Changed the Way We Read, in which he warned that the resulting control on the spread of ideas is stricter than anyone would have thought possible in a free society. Former Pantheon editor Tom Engelhardt reflected in a 2003 interview that what had happened at Pantheon was the beginning of the gargantuan feasting on the independent publishing house and not-so-independent houses as well. Dan Frank served as editorial director from 1996 until his death in May 2021, and Lisa Lucas joined the imprint from 2020 to 2024 as Senior Vice President and Publisher.

• 6. Comics and a New Identity

  ›

  While the corporate battles played out in boardrooms, the editors at Pantheon were building something unexpected on the page. Art Spiegelman's Maus: A Survivor's Tale appeared in 1986 as one of the first original graphic novels Pantheon published, and it drew immediate critical attention. Spiegelman eventually became something of a comics consultant to the imprint, advising editor-in-chief Dan Frank. Graphic designer Chip Kidd joined the Pantheon graphic novels team. In 2000, Pantheon published The Acme Novelty Library by Chris Ware. In 2005, The Rabbi's Cat by Joann Sfar arrived, a graphic novel about a rabbi, his daughter, and their talking cat. The imprint also published earlier work in the comics-based For Beginners series, which had originally appeared through Writers and Readers Cooperative in the 1970s and 1980s; Pantheon brought that series back in 2003. Among the notable cartoonists whose work appeared under the Pantheon imprint were Dan Clowes, Charles Burns, Ben Katchor, Marjane Satrapi, and David Mazzucchelli. Many of these publications were high-quality collected editions of works originally serialized by other publishers such as Fantagraphics Books. In early 2009, long-time Pantheon publisher Janice Goldklang was laid off as part of a general restructuring of Random House. Pantheon is now part of the Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group under Penguin Random House, and its graphic novel catalog remains one of the most substantial commitments to that form in American trade publishing.