Napoleon complex

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Napoleon complex, also called Napoleon syndrome or short-man syndrome, is a label for short men who seem overly aggressive or domineering. The term is mostly aimed at men, and sometimes at people with dwarfism. The unspoken claim is that the swagger is a cover. The man is supposedly making up for a physical or social shortcoming, or for a private insecurity. Ordinary speech and psychology both treat the label as a derogatory stereotype. It is named after Napoleon Bonaparte, the first emperor of the French. Yet the emperor's own height is more disputed than the nickname suggests. Did he ever deserve the reputation? Who turned a military ruler into a symbol of small men with big tempers? And when researchers put short men in front of heart monitors, competitive games and long-running surveys, what did they actually find?

  13

• 2. The Emperor's Real Height

  ›

  Five feet two inches is the figure usually attached to Napoleon Bonaparte, but it was given in the old pre-metric French system of measurement. In imperial units that comes to just under 5 feet 6 inches, or about 1.67 metres. Depending on the source consulted, this matched the average adult male height of his era. Some historians argue for a different number, 5 feet 7 inches. Their reasoning is that he was measured on the island of Saint Helena, 28 years after the French adopted the metric system. A conversion between old and new units could easily have muddied the record. Either way, the best estimates put him close to average. The shortness, it turns out, was drawn rather than measured.

  356

• 3. Caricature and Conquest

  ›

  James Gillray, a British cartoonist, is the person credited with popularizing the myth of a short Napoleon. He was not alone in the effort. British political cartoonists repeatedly drew the emperor as small, and they did so to mock both the man and his expansionist ambitions. Size became a shorthand for overreach. Over time, cultural depictions settled into a familiar story. A little man, unhappy with his height, reaches for power and glory through aggressive military campaigns. That story gave the complex its name, and it handed psychologists a claim they could test.

  347

• 4. Evidence in Favor

  ›

  Abraham Buunk, a professor at the University of Groningen in the Netherlands, reported findings that fit the stereotype. Researchers at the university found that men standing 1.63 metres tall were 50 percent more likely to show signs of jealousy than men standing 1.98 metres tall. In 2018, evolutionary psychologist Mark van Vugt and his team at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam reported evidence of the Napoleon complex in human males. In laboratory conditions, short men played competitive games against taller men. They behaved more aggressively toward those opponents, though mostly in indirect ways. The team's evolutionary hypothesis starts from a simple trigger. When a male, human or not, gets cues that he is physically outcompeted, he shifts strategy to level the playing field. Those alternative tactics include indirect aggression and coalition building. Not every researcher read the pattern as a matter of height at all.

  8911

• 5. Dissatisfaction Over Height

  ›

  A 2022 study led by Bleeker examined how height relates to the Dark Triad, a group of traits made up of narcissism, Machiavellianism and psychopathy. The researchers reported that antagonistic traits were more strongly tied to dissatisfaction with one's height than to a person's actual height. On this reading, it is not shortness that predicts a prickly personality. It is how a man feels about being short. The result is consistent with wider findings in social psychology. Perceived social status, more than physical characteristics alone, is associated with differences in antagonistic and competitive behavior. Other experiments went further and concluded that the whole idea was a myth.

  1213

• 6. Testing the Myth

  ›

  In 2007, a study at the University of Central Lancashire set out to test the stereotype directly. Subjects dueled each other with sticks, and one participant deliberately rapped the other's knuckles. Heart monitors tracked how each person reacted. The result ran against the stereotype. Short men were less likely to lose their temper than men of average height, and it was the taller men who were more likely to hit back. Lecturer Mike Eslea offered an explanation for why the myth survives. He said, "when people see a short man being aggressive, they are likely to think it is due to his size, simply because that attribute is obvious and grabs their attention". A British community-based project, the Wessex Growth Study, took a longer view. It followed children from school entry to adulthood and controlled for gender and socioeconomic status. It found that "no significant differences in personality functioning or aspects of daily living were found which could be attributable to height". The traits it checked included generalizations tied to the Napoleon complex, such as risk-taking behaviours.

  101415

• 7. A Song About It

  ›

  The Divine Comedy, a Northern Irish chamber pop band, released a song called "Napoleon complex" in 2016. It appears on Foreverland, the band's eleventh studio album. The track is tongue-in-cheek and lampoons the complex, treating the stereotype as a subject for gentle satire rather than serious diagnosis. A nickname that began in the political cartoons of Gillray's era has since found its way onto a pop record.

  16