Mencius

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Mencius, born Meng Ke in the state of Zou, carried a question that would define his life's work: are people fundamentally good, or are they something worse? In a China fractured by war and competing kings, that question was not philosophical. It was political. It was urgent. Mencius spent roughly forty years travelling across the warring states, offering counsel to rulers, watching them accept or ignore it, and drawing his own conclusions. His conclusions proved so durable that later philosophers would name him the Second Sage, placing him just below Confucius himself. What made a roaming advisor become the defining voice of Confucian thought? And why did an argument about human nature matter so much to a world at war?

• 2. The Itinerant Sage

  ›

  Zou, the state where Meng Ke was born, now sits within modern Zoucheng in Shandong province. He came of age during the Warring States period, a stretch of near-constant conflict running from around 475 to 221 BC. Like Confucius before him, Mencius chose travel over tenure, riding from court to court and offering his ideas about governance to whoever would hear them. He was, according to tradition, a pupil of Confucius's grandson Zisi, who was born around 481 BC, placing him in the fourth generation of Confucian disciples. Between 319 and 312 BC, he held an actual post as an official and scholar at the Jixia Academy in the state of Qi. When his mother died during those years, he took three full years of leave to mourn her, setting aside his official duties entirely as an act of filial piety. Eventually, disappointed at his failure to move the rulers of his day toward genuine reform, he withdrew from public life. He was buried in the Cemetery of Mencius, which stands about twelve kilometres northeast of Zoucheng's central urban area, marked by a stele carried on the back of a giant stone tortoise and crowned with carved dragons.

• 3. A Mother's Influence

  ›

  Mencius's father, Meng Ji, died when his son was very young, leaving Meng Mu, born Zhang, to raise him alone. Her reputation became so formidable that Liu Xiang included four stories about her among the 125 women's biographies in his Biographies of Exemplary Women. The most famous of those stories gave Chinese culture a lasting idiom. Meng Mu moved houses three times before settling on a location she judged right for her son. First they lived near a cemetery, where she noticed the boy imitating funeral rites. She moved. Near a market, he began mimicking traders. She moved again. Only when they settled beside a school did he begin to study in earnest, and there she stayed. The idiom that grew from this story became a shorthand for the importance of environment in raising children, an idea that later appears at the core of Mencius's own philosophy. A second story is equally stark: when Mencius played truant from school, Meng Mu responded by picking up a pair of scissors and cutting through the cloth she had been weaving, ruining her own work mid-task to show him that stopping a task halfway destroys its value. A third story shows her using the same logic in reverse, turning a would-be divorce into a lesson. Mencius came home and found his wife sitting improperly, and he demanded to end the marriage for violating ritual. His mother reminded him that The Book of Rites requires a person to announce their arrival before entering a room. He had not done so. He had committed the violation. Mencius admitted his fault.

• 4. The Four Beginnings

  ›

  To argue that human beings are naturally good, Mencius reached for a scene almost anyone could recognize. Imagine a child falling down a well, he said. Any witness, before thinking about gaining the parents' friendship or earning the neighbours' praise, immediately feels alarm and distress. That involuntary feeling, Mencius argued, is proof of something innate. He named four such feelings as the four beginnings: commiseration is the beginning of humanity; shame and dislike are the beginning of righteousness; deference and compliance are the beginning of propriety; the sense of right and wrong is the beginning of wisdom. Humans carry these four beginnings, he wrote, just as they carry their four limbs. To say they cannot develop them is to destroy oneself. This position put him in a distinct philosophical space. Xunzi, his near contemporary, held that human nature is evil. The Taoists held that people need no cultivation at all, only acceptance of their natural goodness. Mencius threaded between them: people start with good tendencies, but those tendencies must be cultivated. Bad environments can corrupt the will without proving the will was bad to begin with. A clear-thinking person, he said, would simply avoid causing harm. The object of education, in his view, is the cultivation of benevolence, the quality the Chinese tradition calls ren. He took that argument even further on the question of learning itself, saying that one who believes everything in the Book of Documents would be better off without the Book at all. Texts must be interrogated, tested for internal consistency, and weighed against lived experience.

• 5. Politics and the People's Claim

  ›

  King Zhou of Shang was, by Confucian reckoning, a tyrant. When Mencius was asked about the king's overthrow, he gave an answer that rulers of his own era must have found unsettling: "I have merely heard of killing a villain Zhou, but I have not heard of murdering him as the ruler." A king who rules unjustly, in Mencius's view, is no longer a ruler in any meaningful sense. He placed the common citizens above the ruler in the hierarchy of what mattered to a state. This was not an instigation to constant rebellion; it was a logical extension of the Confucian principle that every relationship carries mutual obligations. A ruler must act benevolently before he can expect loyalty from the people. In that frame, the king is more like a steward than a sovereign. Mencius carried this logic into economics as well. He advocated free trade, low tax rates, and a more equal sharing of the tax burden. He argued against import taxes, on the grounds that merchants bringing goods into a market ultimately serve the villagers who need those goods. Taxes on property were acceptable, and he envisioned them as progressive, with families owning larger, more fertile land paying proportionally more than families with smaller allotments. State monopolies troubled him; so did the prospect of private monopolies forming, which he believed the government had a duty to prevent. Resources, he argued, should be understood as abundant rather than scarce, renewed through work and harvested according to natural cycles of replenishment. His guiding principle was plain: posterity holds priority over profit.

• 6. Legacy and the Four Books

  ›

  Zhu Xi, who lived from 1130 to 1200, gathered the Mencius into a grouping of texts he called the Four Books, designating them as the core of orthodox Neo-Confucian thought. The Mencius itself is unlike the compact sayings of Confucius; it runs to long dialogues, full arguments, and extensive prose. That scope gave it lasting influence among subsequent Chinese philosophers, particularly in the Song dynasty. Mencius's disciples included many feudal lords, and tradition holds that he proved more influential in the end than Confucius himself had been. His reach into European scholarship, however, was slower and more contested. The Jesuit missionaries who first translated Confucian texts into Latin tended to pass over the Mencius, partly because they regarded Neo-Confucian thought as contaminated by Buddhist and Taoist ideas. Matteo Ricci took particular exception to what the Jesuits read as a condemnation of celibacy, though later analysis identified that reading as a mistranslation of a word concerned with personality rather than with sexual renunciation. It was Francois Noel who finally brought a full edition of the Mencius to a European audience, publishing it at Prague in 1711, shortly after the Chinese Rites controversy had been decided against the Jesuits. His edition circulated mainly in central and eastern Europe and did not achieve wide influence beyond that region. The first Mencius Institute, a research and educational body devoted to theoretical Confucianism, was established in Xuzhou, China, in 2008, through a collaboration between Jiangsu Normal University, the China Zoucheng Heritage Tourism Bureau, and the Xuzhou Mengshi Clan Friendship Network. The first such institute outside China opened in 2016 at Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman's Kampar Campus in Malaysia.