Malet coup of 1812

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  At four in the morning on the 23rd of October 1812, a man in a general's uniform slipped out of a Parisian sanatorium and walked calmly toward the headquarters of the French National Guard. His name was Claude François de Malet, a republican general who had spent years behind bars and clinic walls for his opposition to Napoleon Bonaparte. Within hours, he had freed two imprisoned generals, arrested the Minister of Police, and shot the commander of the Paris garrison in the jaw. He had convinced nearly everyone he met that Napoleon was dead.

  The coup would collapse before noon. But the questions it left behind were far more dangerous than the coup itself. Why had so many officers simply believed him? Why had no one, in the first moments of panic, thought to proclaim Napoleon's infant son as the new emperor? Napoleon, still fighting his way back from the wreckage of the Russian campaign, asked exactly that question when he heard the news.

• 2. A General's Long Dissent

  ›

  Claude François de Malet was born in 1754 and built his reputation in the French Revolutionary Wars. He was not a marginal figure or a crank. He was a decorated officer who had risen to brigadier general by 1804. What turned him against the regime he had served was Napoleon's transformation from military hero to absolute monarch.

  Malet resigned his commission the moment Napoleon was crowned Emperor of the French. That resignation did not save him from the system he had renounced. He was given administrative posts as governor, first of Pavia and then of Rome, both occupied territories under French control. When Napoleon's stepson Eugène de Beauharnais, the Viceroy of Italy, accused Malet of conspiring against the emperor, those posts were stripped away and Malet was imprisoned in France. He spent years as a prisoner before being permitted, at his wife's request, to retire to a sanatorium in 1812.

• 3. The Plan Takes Shape

  ›

  The sanatorium was not the isolation its name implied. While confined there, Malet made contact with agents of the House of Bourbon, who were working to restore the monarchy and replace the First Empire. Despite those connections, the source makes clear that Malet's own convictions remained firmly republican rather than royalist. He was using the royalists; they were not using him.

  With a small group of co-conspirators, Malet drafted detailed plans for a seizure of power. They scheduled the attempt for late October, a moment when Napoleon was deep in Russia and could not quickly intervene. The provisional government they designed had a specific president in mind: Lazare Carnot, a republican statesman with revolutionary credentials. The plan was not impulsive. It was carefully staged and assigned specific targets to specific men.

• 4. Six Hours of a False Emperor's Death

  ›

  Colonel Gabriel Soulier commanded the 10th Cohort of the French National Guard. When Malet approached him at four in the morning with forged documents announcing Napoleon's death in Russia, Soulier was stunned not just by that news but by his own apparent promotion, which was included among the forged papers. Ill and disoriented, he assembled his cohort without question.

  The cohort followed Malet to La Force Prison, where he ordered the release of two imprisoned generals, Victor Lahorie and Maximilian-Joseph Guidal. Both were republicans and both agreed to join the coup. Malet sent Lahorie to arrest the Duke of Rovigo, the Minister of Police. Guidal was meant to seize General Henri Clarke, the Minister of War, and Archchancellor Cambacérès. Guidal, who held a personal grievance against Rovigo, insisted on accompanying Lahorie instead. The two men arrested Rovigo and deposited him in La Force, but they neglected to arrest the other two officials. That omission would matter.

  Malet, meanwhile, confronted General Pierre-Augustin Hulin, commander of the Paris garrison, in his own home. When Hulin demanded to see official papers authorizing the transfer of command, Malet shot him in the jaw.

• 5. A Date That Didn't Add Up

  ›

  The coup unraveled not through heroism but through arithmetic. At military headquarters, Malet presented his forged documents to Colonel Doucet, the senior officer on duty. Doucet noticed something the others had missed: the letters stated that Napoleon had died on the 7th of October. Doucet knew of correspondence written by Napoleon and sent after that date. The timeline was impossible.

  Doucet also recognized Malet as a sanatorium inmate. Once alone with him in his office, the colonel overpowered him and placed him under arrest. He then ordered the 10th Cohort back to its barracks, released the imprisoned officials, and notified Clarke, the Minister of War, of what had happened. Clarke moved quickly, dispatching Imperial Guard units to protect the Ministry of Police and sending word to Archchancellor Cambacérès that Empress Marie-Louise and Napoleon's infant heir, the King of Rome, should be moved to Saint-Cloud.

• 6. Trials and What They Revealed

  ›

  Malet, Lahorie, and Guidal were tried before a military council and executed by firing squad on the 29th of October. Colonel Soulier, who had been deceived rather than complicit, was shot on the 31st of October. The commander of the Paris Guard, who had also been fooled into supporting the conspirators, was spared. The 10th Cohort, whose members had simply followed orders they believed to be legitimate, was dispatched to Bremen.

  Minister of War Clarke suspended from service every general officer he believed had acted in a way that showed support for the conspirators. He also worked to portray his rival Rovigo as incompetent in the affair. Napoleon, racing back from Russia, declined to punish Rovigo, to Clarke's evident disappointment. But Napoleon's most pointed reaction was not directed at any of the people involved in the coup. It was directed at the system itself. He reportedly asked why no one, upon hearing of his death, had immediately proclaimed Napoleon II as the new emperor. The question answered itself: after more than a decade of empire, the succession had not been internalized. The coup had lasted only hours, but the silence around the question of an heir echoed for much longer.