Magical Mystery Tour

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Magical Mystery Tour arrived in British record shops on the 8th of December 1967, packaged in a format that had never existed before in the UK: a double EP, two discs tucked inside a gatefold sleeve alongside a 24-page full-colour booklet. The Beatles had nowhere else to put six songs, too many for a standard EP and too few for a proper LP, so they invented a new container for the music. What listeners found inside was a record that confounded scholars, infuriated some critics, topped charts on two continents, and would eventually become the only American-configured release to outlast the band’s own preferred formats and enter their permanent catalogue. How did six songs recorded in the fog of grief, psychedelic drugs, and competing creative ambitions become one of rock music’s most debated records? And what exactly was a double EP anyway, and why did it matter?

• 2. After Epstein

  ›

  Paul McCartney first proposed the film that would become Magical Mystery Tour in April 1967, inspired by author and LSD proponent Ken Kesey’s Merry Pranksters on the US West Coast. The idea was simple and deliberately loose: ordinary people on a coach would have unspecified magical adventures. No script. No fixed plan. The band recorded the title song between the 25th of April and the 3rd of May, then set the whole project aside.

  They were busy. Work continued on songs for the United Artists animated film Yellow Submarine, and Lennon’s composition “All You Need Is Love” was prepared for the Our World satellite broadcast on the 25th of June. The summer passed with travel and the launch of Apple Corps. Magical Mystery Tour sat dormant.

  In late August, while the Beatles were attending a Transcendental Meditation seminar with Maharishi Mahesh Yogi in Wales, their manager Brian Epstein died of a prescription drug overdose. At a band meeting on the 1st of September, McCartney pushed to proceed. He was determined to give the group a focus after the loss. Publicist Tony Barrow later wrote that McCartney saw the project as opening doors personally and positioning himself as the band’s executive producer for films.

  George Harrison was, by multiple accounts, far more interested in pursuing meditation than filmmaking. John Lennon later complained the project was typical of McCartney’s eagerness to work the moment he had songs ready, while Lennon himself had to scramble to write new material. The sessions that followed would carry that tension all the way to the final mix.

• 3. Disorganised Chaos

  ›

  Recording began in earnest on the 5th of September, according to Beatles historian Mark Lewisohn, with filming starting on the 11th. The two activities became increasingly intertwined as October progressed. Early pre-overdub mixes of some songs were prepared on the 16th of September, before the band performed music sequences during a six-day shoot at RAF West Malling, a Royal Air Force base in Kent.

  George Martin, the group’s producer, chose to keep his distance. He described much of the recording as “disorganised chaos”. Senior recording engineer Ken Scott put it plainly, recalling that the Beatles had taken over to such a degree that he was more their assistant than Martin’s. Many biographers characterise the 1967 post-Sgt. Pepper sessions as aimless and undisciplined; author Ian MacDonald tied this to the band’s use of LSD, which he argued produced a loss of judgment as they embraced randomness.

  McCartney and Lennon clashed over the film’s content during the editing process, which took place in a Soho suite mostly overseen by McCartney. A specific flashpoint was the treatment of “I Am the Walrus”: Lennon’s song was assigned the B-side of the accompanying single, behind McCartney’s pop-oriented “Hello, Goodbye”. Lennon later said simply, “I began to submerge.”

  Recording wrapped on the 7th of November. That same day, McCartney recorded a new barker-style introduction for the title song, replacing Lennon’s version, though Lennon’s recording was kept in the film’s own cut. Traffic sounds were overdubbed and the sessions closed. The 17th of October had brought the four band members together for the memorial service for Epstein at the New London Synagogue on Abbey Road, and for the world premiere of Lennon’s acting debut in How I Won the War the following day. Both events took place while recording was still under way.

• 4. The Sound Laboratory

  ›

  Lennon wanted his voice on “I Am the Walrus” to sound like it came from the moon. The engineers gave him a low-quality microphone and saturated the preamp signal. George Martin then wrote separate parts for sixteen backing vocalists, the Mike Sammes Singers, choreographing their laughter, exaggerated vocalising, and other noises to conjure the LSD-tinged mood Lennon was after. The orchestral parts and the vocal score were recorded to a separate four-track tape, which Martin and Scott manually synchronised with the tape of the band’s performance. Lennon then overdubbed live radio signals captured at random, finally landing on a BBC Third Programme broadcast of Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of King Lear.

  Harrison’s “Blue Jay Way” made use of three techniques the Beatles had been developing across 1966-67: flanging, signal rotation through a Leslie speaker, and, in the stereo mix only, reversed tapes. A recording of the completed track was played backwards and faded in at key moments, so that the backing vocals appeared to answer each line of Harrison’s lead vocal in the verses. Because of multitracking’s technical limits at the time, the reversed sounds had to be fed in live during the final mixing session.

  Musicologist Thomas MacFarlane noted that across these sessions the Beatles treated colour and texture as compositional elements equal in weight to melody and harmony. Musicologist Walter Everett pointed to specific touches he considered effective: the slow guitar tremolo on “Flying”, the combination of female and male chorus, cello glissandi, and found sounds on “I Am the Walrus”, and the interplay between the lead vocal and violas on “Hello, Goodbye”. A tape loop of decelerated guitar sounds was used on “The Fool on the Hill” to produce a swooshing, bird-like effect near the song’s close.

• 5. Songs and Their Origins

  ›

  “I Am the Walrus” began with a letter. A student at Quarry Bank, Lennon’s former school, wrote to him to say that an English literature teacher was analysing the Beatles’ lyrics in scholarly fashion. Amused, Lennon wrote a lyric specifically designed to confound that kind of analysis. He drew on Lewis Carroll’s poem “The Walrus and the Carpenter” from Through the Looking Glass, reworked a nursery rhyme from his schooldays, and referenced Edgar Allan Poe and, in the vocalised phrase “googoogajoob”, James Joyce. Author Jonathan Gould called it “the most overtly ‘literary’ song the Beatles would ever record”.

  “Blue Jay Way” was named for a street in the Hollywood Hills of Los Angeles where Harrison stayed in August 1967. The lyrics track his wait for music publicist Derek Taylor to navigate the fog-ridden hills to find him, while Harrison fought to stay awake after the flight from London. Musicologist David Reck noted the song incorporates scalar elements from the Carnatic raga Ranjani and marked a rare use of the Lydian mode in pop music.

  McCartney wrote the melody for “The Fool on the Hill” during the Sgt. Pepper sessions, but the lyrics were not completed until September. He said the idea was partly inspired by the Dutch design collective the Fool, who named themselves after the tarot card, and possibly also by the Maharishi. The song’s sequence in the film required a dedicated location shoot, with McCartney filmed on a hillside overlooking Nice, in the South of France, which added considerably to production costs.

  “Flying” was the first Beatles track credited to all four members. Originally titled “Aerial Tour Instrumental”, it appears in the film over footage of clouds and outtakes from Stanley Kubrick’s Dr. Strangelove. Lennon and Starr prepared seven minutes of tape loops intended as a coda, but the loops were cut, leaving the track to end with a 30-second burst of Mellotron sounds.

• 6. Packaging as Argument

  ›

  Six songs posed a logistical problem for the Beatles and their British label EMI. Too many for a standard EP, too few for an LP. One option considered was an EP that played at 33 1/3 rpm, but the audio fidelity loss was judged unacceptable. The solution was a double EP, the first of its kind in Britain.

  The gatefold sleeve held a 24-page booklet compiled by publicist Tony Barrow with input from McCartney. It contained song lyrics, photographer John Kelly’s colour stills from the shoot, and colour story illustrations in a comic strip style by Beatles Book cartoonist Bob Gibson. The cover showed the Beatles in animal costumes photographed during the “I Am the Walrus” shoot, making it the first time the band’s faces were not visible on one of their EP or LP releases.

  Film studies academic Bob Neaverson later observed that while the double EP format solved the song count problem, it was also clearly born of the Beatles’ desire to experiment with conventional packaging. The packaging was deliberate: the band wanted buyers to understand they were receiving a film soundtrack, not a follow-up to Sgt. Pepper, which was still selling strongly in late 1967.

  For the US release, Capitol’s head of the art department, John Van Hamersveld, enlarged the photos and illustrations to LP size and augmented the cover because Capitol’s vice-president of distribution worried that hiding the Beatles’ faces might damage sales. Van Hamersveld added the song titles in art-deco lettering against what author Jonathan Gould described as a border of op-art clouds, giving the LP cover “the garish symmetry of a movie poster”. The artwork later attracted attention from proponents of the Paul is dead theory, who read meaning into the black walrus costume Lennon wore, a black carnation McCartney wore in one image, and a sign reading “I WaS” visible behind McCartney on another page.

• 7. Release and Reception

  ›

  In the US, Capitol issued the album on the 27th of November 1967, earlier than the planned mid-December date. In its first three weeks on sale, it set a record for the highest initial sales of any Capitol LP. It reached number 1 on Billboard’s Top LPs listings for eight weeks at the start of 1968 and was nominated for the Grammy Award for Album of the Year in 1969. By the 31st of December 1967, American sales had reached 1,936,063 copies.

  The UK EP release, on the 8th of December, landed a day after the opening of the Apple Boutique in central London, retailing at 19 shillings and 6 pence. It became the Beatles’ ninth release to top the national EPs chart compiled by Record Retailer, and in the Melody Maker singles listings it briefly replaced “Hello, Goodbye” at number 1. The EP sold over 500,000 copies in Britain.

  The film, broadcast by BBC Television on Boxing Day to an audience estimated at 15 million, was savaged by critics. It was the Beatles’ first significant public failure. As a direct result, the American broadcaster withdrew its bid for North American broadcast rights.

  Contemporary reviews of the record itself were sharply divided. Writing for the NME a month before the film aired, Nick Logan praised the band for “stretching pop music to its limits”. Rex Reed of HiFi/Stereo Review dismissed the LP as “a platter of phony, pretentious, overcooked tripe” and ridiculed “I Am the Walrus” specifically. Robert Christgau, writing in Esquire in May 1968, called “The Fool on the Hill” potentially the worst song the Beatles had ever recorded, though he still found the album valid for its singles and for Harrison’s “Blue Jay Way”.

  Music historian Clinton Heylin later argued that the release of Magical Mystery Tour, alongside the Rolling Stones’ Their Satanic Majesties Request, inadvertently brought psychedelic pop to a close as a viable commercial mode.

• 8. Catalogue Permanence

  ›

  When EMI standardised the Beatles’ releases for the worldwide compact disc rollout in 1987, a significant decision was made: Magical Mystery Tour would be the only American-configured LP to supersede the band’s own intended format and enter their core catalogue. Every other country had received the six-track double EP; the eleven-track Capitol LP, with its five additional singles, was the American anomaly. Yet the breadth of its track listing made it comparable in length to the band’s original albums, which meant the extra songs did not need to appear on Past Masters, the two-volume compilation gathering non-album singles for CD.

  In November 1976, EMI had already released the Capitol LP configuration in the UK after continued demand for the American import, though that pressing used Capitol’s fake-stereo masters for three of the singles. The first true-stereo version of the full LP had appeared in West Germany in 1971, after true-stereo mixes of “Penny Lane”, “Baby, You’re a Rich Man” and “All You Need Is Love” were created in 1968 and 1971.

  Retroactive critical standing has been generous. In The Ambient Century, Mark Prendergast called it “the most psychedelic album The Beatles ever released” and placed it at number 27 in his list of the essential hundred recordings of the twentieth century. Writing for Mojo in 2002, Charles Shaar Murray said it was the Beatles album he turned to most often after Harrison’s death the previous year. “The Fool on the Hill” became one of the most covered Lennon-McCartney compositions, especially among cabaret performers. Jazz musician Bud Shank recorded an album called Magical Mystery in 1968 that included five of the EP’s tracks and “Hello, Goodbye”. The record that began as a logistical problem, six songs that fit no standard format, ended up outlasting the format the Beatles intended for it.