Joseph Chamberlain

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Joseph Chamberlain never became Prime Minister. And yet Winston Churchill wrote that he was the man who "made the weather" in British politics. Born on the 8th of July 1836, Chamberlain spent his life splitting parties, building empires, and remaking cities, all from outside the office he wanted most. How did a screw manufacturer from Birmingham become the most consequential British politician never to hold the top job? That is the question threading through this story.

• 2. Screws, Steel, and Self-Made Men

  ›

  At 18, Joseph Chamberlain joined his uncle's screw-making business in Birmingham, a firm called Nettlefolds. His father had invested in the company, and when Chamberlain became a partner alongside Joseph Nettlefold, the name changed to Nettlefold and Chamberlain. During its peak years, the company produced two-thirds of all metal screws made in England. By 1874, when Chamberlain retired from business, the firm was exporting worldwide.

  Chamberlain had never attended university. He worked first for his family's leather shoe trade as an apprentice at the Worshipful Company of Cordwainers, and that outsider identity shaped his politics for life. He held the aristocracy in contempt. He entered the House of Commons at 39, which was late by the standards of men from more privileged backgrounds. His path into public life ran not through Eton or Oxford but through the Edgbaston Debating Society and the radical traditions of Birmingham's Unitarian church.

  His first marriage, in July 1861, was to Harriet Kenrick, daughter of a Birmingham holloware manufacturer. Their son Austen was born in October 1863, but Harriet had confided a premonition that she would die in childbirth; she fell ill two days after Austen's birth and died three days later. Chamberlain threw himself back into business. In 1868 he married Harriet's cousin Florence Kenrick. Florence gave him four more children, including the future Prime Minister Neville, born in 1869. On the 13th of February 1875, Florence died giving birth to a fifth child, who also did not survive. Both losses eroded Chamberlain's religious faith completely. He stopped requiring any religious adherence from his children.

• 3. Mayor of a New Kind of City

  ›

  In November 1873, Chamberlain was elected mayor of Birmingham, and he immediately set about transforming a city where roughly half the population depended on polluted well water and piped water arrived only three days a week. Two competing gas companies were constantly tearing up the city's streets to lay mains. Chamberlain forcibly purchased both companies for a combined price of £1,953,050. In its first year of municipal operation, the gas scheme turned a profit of £34,000.

  In January 1876, he did the same for water, purchasing Birmingham's waterworks for £1,350,000 and creating the Birmingham Corporation Water Department. He explained his motives plainly, declaring that "We have not the slightest intention of making profit... We shall get our profit indirectly in the comfort of the town and in the health of the inhabitants."

  Slum clearance came next. In July 1875, Chamberlain tabled an improvement plan that involved buying 50 acres of overcrowded city-centre property to carve a new road through it, named Corporation Street. He contributed £10,000 of his own money to the scheme. The land was ultimately leased on a 75-year basis as a business proposition, because the Improvement Committee judged it too expensive to rehouse slum-dwellers in municipally built accommodation. Even so, the death rate on Corporation Street fell from approximately 53 per 1,000 between 1873 and 1875 to 21 per 1,000 between 1879 and 1881.

  Contemporaries noticed Chamberlain's personal style as much as his policies. They remarked on his youthfulness and his habit of wearing "a black velvet coat, jaunty eyeglass in eye, red neck-tie drawn through a ring." His biographer later credited him with constructing "arguably his greatest and most enduring accomplishment": a model of municipal socialism admired across the industrial world.

• 4. The Radical Programme

  ›

  Chamberlain entered Parliament in 1876 through a Birmingham by-election, after George Dixon resigned. He was introduced to the House of Commons by John Bright and Joseph Cowen. On the 4th of August 1876, speaking for twenty minutes on elementary schools, he gave his maiden speech with Benjamin Disraeli present in the chamber. He had earlier called Disraeli "a man who never told the truth except by accident", was forced to apologise publicly, and seems to have rather enjoyed the controversy.

  On the 31st of May 1877, the National Liberal Federation was founded at Bingley Hall in Birmingham, with Gladstone giving the inaugural address and Chamberlain serving as president. Chamberlain used the NLF to tighten party discipline, organise political meetings, and publish pamphlets. Contemporary commentators drew unflattering comparisons between the Federation and American political machines, with Chamberlain cast as the political boss.

  By 1885, Chamberlain was ready for something bolder. In July of that year he wrote the preface to the Radical Programme, which he described as the first campaign handbook in British political history. It called for land reform, free public education, the disestablishment of the Church of England, universal male suffrage, and greater protection for trade unions. His campaign slogan, "Three Acres and a Cow," promised smallholdings to rural labourers newly enfranchised by the Representation of the People Act 1884. He kicked off the campaign at Hull on the 5th of August 1885, under posters declaring him "your coming Prime Minister."

  The campaign attracted large crowds and captivated the young Ramsay MacDonald and David Lloyd George. It also alarmed senior Liberals. George Goschen called it the "Unauthorised Programme," a name that stuck. Conservatives compared Chamberlain to Dick Turpin.

• 5. The Irish Rupture

  ›

  On the 17th of December 1885, Herbert Gladstone revealed that his father, needing Irish Nationalist support, intended to implement Home Rule for Ireland. Chamberlain's opposition was rooted in imperial logic: he believed that granting Ireland a separate Parliament would weaken Westminster's hold over the United Kingdom and threaten the empire's coherence. He declared that five million Irishmen had no greater right to govern themselves than the five million inhabitants of London.

  On the 13th of March 1886, Gladstone's proposals for Ireland were formally revealed. Two days later, Chamberlain wrote to inform Gladstone of his intention to resign. His resignation was made public on the 27th of March. He launched an immediate campaign against the Home Rule Bill, and on the 8th of June its second reading was defeated, with 93 Liberals voting alongside Conservatives and Whigs in opposition.

  The Liberal split was complete. Chamberlain helped form the Liberal Unionist Association, and from the 1895 general election onward, the Liberal Unionists were formally in coalition with the Conservatives under his former enemy Lord Salisbury. When Chamberlain walked into the House of Commons as part of this new alignment, Gladstonians shouted "Judas!" and "Traitor!" at him from across the chamber.

  Gladstone himself was withering. Comparing Chamberlain to the Whig grandee Lord Hartington, Gladstone observed that "there is a difference between Hartington and Chamberlain, that the first behaves like and is a thorough gentleman. Of the other, it is better not to speak." Historian David Nicholls, less diplomatic than Gladstone, later described Chamberlain as arrogant, ruthless, and widely hated.

• 6. Colonial Secretary and the Boer War

  ›

  In 1895, Chamberlain surprised the Cabinet by asking for the Colonial Office rather than the Exchequer or Home Secretary, positions considered more prestigious. Salisbury and Balfour had offered him any post except Foreign Secretary or Leader of the House. Chamberlain took formal charge on the 1st of July 1895 and held the position for eight years.

  He pressed forward on multiple fronts. In West Africa, he sanctioned the conquest of the Ashanti Confederacy and ordered railway construction in the newly acquired territory. He backed Frederick Lugard's risky "chequerboard" occupation of disputed territory against the French, at moments placing British and French troops a few yards from each other. In March 1898, the French proposed a settlement that returned Bussa to Britain in exchange for the town of Bona, eventually consolidating British control over what became Nigeria.

  With Chamberlain's backing, Patrick Manson founded the London School of Tropical Medicine in 1899, described in the source as the world's second medical facility dedicated to tropical medicine. His press nickname was "Joseph Africanus."

  In South Africa, Chamberlain directed steady military pressure on the Transvaal and Orange Free State, ostensibly on behalf of the British Uitlanders living there. He played a major role in bringing about the Second Boer War, which began on the 12th of October 1899 when the South African Republic and Orange Free State declared war. By that point, nearly 20,000 British troops were already based in the South African colonies.

  The war went badly at first. In mid-December 1899, the British Army suffered defeats at Stormberg, Magersfontein, and Colenso in what became known as "Black Week." Fortunes reversed after January 1900, with Bloemfontein falling on the 13th of March, Johannesburg on the 31st of May, and Pretoria on the 5th of June. The Treaty of Vereeniging formally ended the war on the 31st of May 1902. Britain had committed nearly 450,000 troops and spent nearly £200 million.

  The concentration camps established for Boer refugee families became a major scandal. Chamberlain had originally questioned the wisdom of establishing them, but had deferred to military authority. As public pressure mounted in autumn 1901, he strengthened civilian oversight of the camps, stipulated that unhealthy camps be evacuated, and asked Milner directly whether medical provisions were adequate. By 1902, the death rate in the camps had halved.

• 7. Tariff Reform and Final Collapse

  ›

  Chamberlain's third wife, Mary Crowninshield Endicott, was the daughter of United States Secretary of War William Crowninshield Endicott. Chamberlain met her in 1887 while leading a British delegation to Washington to resolve the Newfoundland fisheries dispute. He described her as "one of the brightest and most intelligent girls I have yet met." Before leaving the United States in March 1888, he proposed, and they married at St John's Episcopal Church in New York City. Mary became a steady political supporter and helped ease his entry into upper-class society.

  By 1903, Chamberlain had settled on a new cause: tariff reform, meaning import taxes to bind the empire together through preferential trade. He resigned from the Cabinet on the 9th of September 1903 to campaign for it free from collective responsibility. Most Unionist MPs came around to his position. But the Unionists were devastated at the 1906 general election, suffering a landslide defeat.

  Shortly after public celebrations of his 70th birthday in Birmingham, Chamberlain suffered a stroke that ended his public life entirely. He lived until the 2nd of July 1914, dying just days before the First World War began, and just six days before what would have been his 78th birthday.

  Churchill's assessment endured: Chamberlain was, in Churchill's words, "incomparably the most live, sparkling, insurgent, compulsive figure in British affairs." His son Austen later won the Nobel Peace Prize. His son Neville became Prime Minister. Joseph Chamberlain, who split the Liberals over Irish Home Rule and the Unionists over tariff reform, achieved neither office nor the policies he spent his career promoting, but no one who came after him was quite able to ignore what he had built.