Jim Shooter

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Jim Shooter was fourteen years old on the 10th of February 1966. That day, editor Mort Weisinger called from DC Comics to say he wanted to buy the scripts Shooter had mailed from Pittsburgh. Weisinger wanted more.

  "I was doing this to save the house," Shooter recalled in a 2010 interview. His father worked as a steelworker, and the family car had already failed before the first DC check arrived. That paycheck went toward a rebuilt engine. Shooter wrote and sold stories through high school to help keep his family afloat.

  Born on the 27th of September 1951 in Pittsburgh to parents Ken and Eleanor Shooter, he had submitted those first DC scripts with no professional training. He had no industry connections and no prior contact with anyone in the field. What turned a teenager with no credentials into a writer major publishers were paying for is worth understanding. And why the same qualities that made him effective at Marvel would eventually cost him that job is equally important.

  113694

• 2. A Year of Study

  ›

  In 1963, Shooter was twelve years old and recovering from minor surgery in a hospital when he first engaged seriously with Marvel Comics. The publisher had been in operation for only about two years. What caught his attention was a structural quality in how Marvel's stories worked.

  DC's books, Shooter concluded, "needed the help." Marvel had built its appeal on characters who had real problems, distinct personalities, and lives that extended beyond any given fight. He studied both companies' output for roughly a year, analyzing what was working and why.

  Aged thirteen, Shooter wrote and drew a batch of Legion of Super-Heroes stories and mailed them to DC in mid-1965. He had reasoned that a writer who understood Marvel's approach would be useful to DC, the company he felt was lagging. The strategy yielded more than a simple purchase. Weisinger also commissioned Shooter to write Supergirl and Superman stories, and eventually offered a regular position on the Legion. His first published story ran in Adventure Comics #346 in July 1966.

  11361328

• 3. Characters and Creation

  ›

  Four of Shooter's inventions for the Legion of Super-Heroes became lasting parts of DC's roster. These were the Legionnaires Karate Kid, Ferro Lad, and Princess Projectra, and the villainous coalition known as the Fatal Five. A writer at DC who grasped Marvel's approach to character was, at that point, rare.

  Action Comics #340, published in August 1966, introduced Parasite, a Superman villain Shooter created who would continue appearing in DC comics for decades. He and artist Curt Swan devised the first race between the Flash and Superman; that story ran in Superman #199 in August 1967. In October-November 1968, Shooter wrote the first issue of Captain Action, DC's first comic built around a licensed toy.

  In 1969, Shooter was accepted into New York University but chose a job at Marvel instead. After three weeks, he left due to financial difficulties and returned to Pittsburgh. Several years of advertising work, writing, and illustration followed.

  Both Marvel and DC offered him assignments when a fanzine interview about the Legion of Super-Heroes drew him back to the industry. He returned to DC, drawn by the chance to write Superman and to work on the Legion in its own dedicated book, Superboy and the Legion of Super-Heroes. His working relationships with Superman editor Julius Schwartz and Legion editor Murray Boltinoff were strained. Both, he claimed, subjected him to unnecessary rewrites.

  In December 1975, Marvel editor-in-chief Marv Wolfman called to offer an editorial position. This time, Shooter accepted.

  111012367

• 4. Rising Through Marvel

  ›

  On the 2nd of January 1976, Shooter joined the Marvel staff as an assistant editor and writer. He was arriving into an unusual period of instability at the top. Roy Thomas, Len Wein, Marv Wolfman, Gerry Conway, and Archie Goodwin had all held the editor-in-chief role in a relatively short span. Each had found the expanding workload overwhelming as the company continued to add titles and staff.

  On the first working day of January 1978, Shooter succeeded Archie Goodwin to become Marvel's ninth editor-in-chief. Publisher Stan Lee had moved to Los Angeles to oversee the company's work in animation, television, and film. This left Shooter largely in charge of creative decisions at Marvel's New York headquarters. He was twenty-six years old.

  "The Dreaded Deadline Doom" was the name the industry had given to Marvel's chronic failure to publish on schedule. Shooter ended it. Over his nine-year tenure, he kept the line of books on time, added titles, and developed new talent. Work produced under his oversight included Chris Claremont and John Byrne's run on Uncanny X-Men and Byrne's Fantastic Four. Frank Miller's Daredevil, Walt Simonson's Thor, and Roger Stern's runs on both Avengers and The Amazing Spider-Man came from the same period.

  In 1979, Shooter and artists George Perez, Sal Buscema, and David Wenzel received the Eagle Award for Best Continuing Story. The nomination was based on their run on The Avengers issues 167, 168, and 170-177. The Inkpot Award followed in 1980.

  1317161518

• 5. Building the Machine

  ›

  Dazzler #1, released in 1981, was the first ongoing series from a major publisher to sell exclusively through specialty comics shops. The character was a disco-themed heroine with ties to the X-Men, based on an unmade film that had been intended to star Bo Derek. Other Marvel titles, including Marvel Fanfare and Ka-Zar, soon followed the same route into the specialty market.

  Also in 1981, Shooter wrote Marvel Treasury Edition No. 28, which featured the second Superman and Spider-Man crossover between the two publishers. That year, the New York chapter of Junior Chamber International recognized him as one of six "New Yorkers of the Year." The award cited his contributions to revitalizing the comics industry.

  In 1982, Shooter established the Epic imprint for creator-owned material and put a royalties program in place. Creators received a share of the proceeds when their books passed certain sales benchmarks. They also received a share when characters they had worked on were licensed as toys. Shooter also implemented a program to return original artwork to the creators who had produced it.

  Marvel Super Hero Contest of Champions and Secret Wars were both Shooter initiatives, introducing the company-wide crossover as a publishing format. In 1986, to mark Marvel's 25th anniversary, Shooter launched a new line called the New Universe. By that point, complaints about his editorial style had been building among a number of long-time Marvel creators.

  1518163650

• 6. The Reckoning

  ›

  Roy Thomas left Marvel following a contract dispute with Shooter. In a 2005 reflection, Thomas acknowledged that an editor-in-chief had the right to impose his vision on writers. "I thought it was kind of dumb," Thomas said of the approach, "but I don't think Jim was dumb." John Romita Sr. described a more explicit turning point. Shooter had been great for the first two or three years, Romita said, getting creators treated with more respect and sent to conventions first-class. But once Secret Wars hit, Romita said, "he decided he knew everything and he started changing everybody's stuff."

  John Byrne said Shooter had come along "just when Marvel needed him" but had stayed too long. After fixing most of what was broken, Byrne wrote, "he could not stop fixing." Secret Wars, Byrne argued, began as a toy promotion. Shooter, Byrne wrote, "turned it into a way to reshape the Marvel Universe in his image."

  Steve Gerber, Marv Wolfman, Gene Colan, John Byrne, and Doug Moench were among the long-time creators who left Marvel during this period. Most went to DC or other publishers. DC's publisher Jenette Kahn had been actively recruiting those who departed.

  Shooter enforced a policy forbidding the portrayal of gay characters in the Marvel universe. According to John Byrne, Shooter personally told him that a gay character would not be allowed. Byrne was required to conceal the character Northstar's sexuality as a result. Comics historian Frederick Luis Aldama later described Marvel under Shooter as "widely considered homophobic." The only gay-themed story Marvel published during those years was written by Shooter himself. In it, two gay men attempted to rape Bruce Banner.

  On the 15th of April 1987, Shooter was fired from Marvel. Within two years, he would enter the market as a publisher competing directly with the company he had run.

  2022233231

• 7. Valiant and the Pseudonym

  ›

  Shooter and his investors founded Voyager Communications, entering the comics market in 1989 under the Valiant Comics banner. The initial titles were built on Nintendo and WWF licensed properties. Two years later, Valiant moved into superhero publishing with a relaunch of Magnus, Robot Fighter, a Gold Key Comics character from an earlier era. Solar, Man of the Atom, another Gold Key property, followed later that same year.

  Bob Layton and Barry Windsor-Smith came from Marvel to join Valiant, alongside industry veterans including Don Perlin. The company developed a training process it called "knob row," through which creators learned to render work in the Valiant house style.

  Shooter sometimes took on penciling duties himself when money and talent were scarce at Valiant. To conceal this, he signed those pages under the name Paul Creddick, borrowing the surname of his brother-in-law. He was ousted from Valiant in 1992. In early 1993, Shooter and several colleagues founded Defiant Comics, entering a market that had grown considerably more crowded since the Valiant launch.

  3738394048

• 8. The Long Tail

  ›

  Defiant's first title arrived to some initial success, but the company could not hold a lasting audience. After thirteen months of publishing, Defiant closed. In 1995, Shooter founded Broadway Comics as an offshoot of Broadway Video, the production company behind Saturday Night Live. When Broadway Video's parent sold the properties to Golden Books, the line ended.

  In September 2007, DC Comics announced that Shooter would return as the writer of Legion of Super-Heroes beginning with issue #37. His previous run on the Legion had ended more than thirty years earlier. He co-created a new Legionnaire named Gazelle with artist Francis Manapul. The run ended with issue #49, one issue before the book's cancellation.

  In July 2009, Dark Horse Comics announced at San Diego Comic-Con that Shooter would oversee new Gold Key Comics series. These included Turok, Doctor Solar, and Magnus: Robot Fighter. Valiant Entertainment sued Shooter over the move, arguing he had interfered with their ability to license those characters. Shooter had agreed to write them for Dark Horse instead. The lawsuit was dropped as of January 2010. His Gold Key work for Dark Horse, which began publishing in 2010, also included Mighty Samson, a character Valiant had not acquired.

  Shooter was diagnosed with esophageal cancer in 2024. He died on the 30th of June 2025, at his home in Nyack, New York. He was 73. In 2017, the University Press of Mississippi published a volume on him in its Conversations with Comic Artists series. The archive the series builds is of people the field would not stop arguing about.

  4546475152