Irvin McDowell

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Irvin McDowell's name is permanently attached to one of the most humiliating afternoons in American military history. On a summer day in 1861, the Union Army he commanded streamed back toward Washington in a chaotic rout, civilians who had driven out from the capital to watch the battle scrambling alongside terrified soldiers. It was the First Battle of Bull Run, the first large-scale clash of the Civil War, and McDowell would spend the rest of his life in its shadow.

  How did a man who spent most of his career as a logistics officer end up commanding the opening battle of a war? What did the politicians and generals around him see, and what did they miss? And what does a career of lost battles, transferred blame, and quiet banishment to the Pacific coast tell us about how the Union Army handled failure?

• 2. A Soldier Shaped Abroad

  ›

  McDowell was born in Columbus, Ohio, on the 15th of October 1818, the son of Abram Irvin McDowell and Eliza Seldon McDowell. His family was of English and Scots-Irish descent, and his connections extended across the officer corps in ways that would matter later. His cousin-in-law was John Buford, the cavalry general. His brother John Adair McDowell would become the first colonel of the 6th Iowa Volunteer Infantry.

  Before West Point, McDowell attended the College de Troyes in France, an unusual path that distinguished him from most American officers of his era. He graduated from the Military Academy in 1838, and one of his classmates was P. G. T. Beauregard, the man who would command Confederate forces against him at First Bull Run. That coincidence shaped both their careers. McDowell was commissioned a second lieutenant in the 1st U.S. Artillery and went on to teach tactics at West Point, serving under General John E. Wool as an aide-de-camp during the Mexican-American War.

  At Buena Vista, McDowell earned a brevet promotion to captain. After the war he moved into the Adjutant General's department, where he was promoted to major on the 31st of May 1856. Between 1848 and 1861, he accumulated deep experience in logistics and supply, working for a succession of senior commanders including future Confederate general Joseph E. Johnston.

• 3. Pushed Into Battle

  ›

  McDowell's most influential friendship was with General Winfield Scott, on whose staff he served. That relationship, combined with the patronage of Treasury Secretary Salmon P. Chase, vaulted him over more experienced field commanders when the Union needed a general in the spring of 1861. On the 14th of May 1861, he was promoted to brigadier general in the regular army. Thirteen days later, on the 27th of May, he received command of the Army of Northeastern Virginia.

  McDowell protested. He told the politicians pressing him that he was a supply officer, not a field commander, and that his troops were inexperienced and not ready to fight. Washington was not listening. The pressure from politicians demanding a swift offensive against Confederate forces in Northern Virginia overrode his objections.

  The strategy McDowell devised for the First Battle of Bull Run was, by later accounts, imaginative. It was also ambitiously complex for a force that had never maneuvered at scale. His soldiers could not execute it. The result was an embarrassing rout that sent Union troops streaming back toward Washington and delivered the Confederacy a propaganda victory at the very opening of the war. Beauregard, McDowell's old classmate, commanded the Confederate side.

• 4. Demotion, Despair, and the Valley

  ›

  After Bull Run, Major General George B. McClellan took command of the new Army of the Potomac defending Washington. McDowell was reduced to a division commander within that army. Then, on the 14th of March 1862, President Lincoln reorganized the army into corps, and McDowell was given command of the I Corps, along with a promotion to major general of volunteers.

  When McClellan's army moved toward the Virginia Peninsula in April 1862, McDowell's corps was held back. The concern was Stonewall Jackson's movements in the Shenandoah Valley, and McDowell was assigned to the Rappahannock area instead. One of his divisions was eventually sent down to the Peninsula, but McDowell's main force remained separated from McClellan's main effort.

  The three independent commands of McDowell, John C. Fremont, and Nathaniel P. Banks were eventually consolidated into Major General John Pope's Army of Virginia. McDowell led the III Corps. His conduct at Cedar Mountain earned him a brevet to major general in the regular army. But when Pope's army was crushed at the Second Battle of Bull Run in August 1862, McDowell bore a share of the blame. His own troops despised him. Many believed he was secretly working against the Union cause. The 1879 board of review later concluded he had been indecisive and uncommunicative, had repeatedly failed to answer Fitz John Porter's requests for information, and had neglected to pass intelligence about Longstreet's positioning to Pope.

• 5. The Porter Affair

  ›

  McDowell escaped formal punishment for Second Bull Run through a maneuver that had little to do with battlefield performance. Pope court-martialed Major General Fitz John Porter for alleged insubordination during the battle, and McDowell testified against him. The testimony helped redirect accountability away from McDowell himself.

  The arrangement was not without its calculations. Pope and McDowell reportedly disliked each other, but McDowell understood the postwar arithmetic: he held a regular army commission and would remain a general after the fighting ended, while Pope, lacking that standing, would revert to colonel. Testifying served McDowell's interests regardless of the personal friction.

  Porter was convicted and cashiered. Years later, in 1879, the board of review convened by President Rutherford B. Hayes examined the case and issued a report recommending Porter's pardon. That report attributed much of the loss at Second Bull Run to McDowell himself, depicting him as indecisive, uncommunicative, and inept. Despite the formal escape McDowell had engineered earlier, the board's findings left a lasting mark on his reputation.

• 6. The Pacific Years

  ›

  For two years after Second Bull Run, McDowell received no new assignments. The army had, in practical terms, set him aside. In July 1864, he was given command of the Department of the Pacific, the kind of posting that could be described as a geographic exile from the main conflict.

  After the war, his commands rotated across the country. He commanded the Department of California from the 27th of July 1865 to the 31st of March 1868, then briefly the Fourth Military Department, then the Department of the East from the 16th of July 1868 to the 16th of December 1872. On the 25th of November 1872, he was promoted to major general. The following month, on the 16th of December 1872, he succeeded General George G. Meade as commander of the Military Division of the South, a post he held until the 30th of June 1876. From the 1st of July 1876, he commanded the Division of the Pacific.

  In 1882, Congress imposed a mandatory retirement age of 64 for military officers. McDowell retired on the 14th of October of that year, his career ending by statute rather than by choice or disgrace.

• 7. Gardens at the Presidio

  ›

  After retiring, McDowell turned to landscape gardening, a passion he had apparently carried through decades of military assignments. He served as Park Commissioner of San Francisco, California, and in that role he transformed a neglected section of the Presidio into a public park, laying out drives designed to command views of the Golden Gate.

  It was a quieter monument than the ones most Civil War generals pursued. McDowell died of a heart attack on the 4th of May 1885, and he is buried in San Francisco National Cemetery in the Presidio, the same ground where he had built his park. The drives he laid out overlooking the Golden Gate remained long after the battles that defined his name had faded from living memory.