Hugo van der Goes

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Hugo van der Goes died inside a monastery near Brussels in 1482, a painter who had walked away from the peak of his career just five years earlier. He had been one of the most sought-after artists in the Burgundian Netherlands, painting for dukes, church institutions, Italian merchants, and the city of Ghent itself. Then, at the height of his powers, he closed his workshop and took vows at the Rood Klooster. What drove a celebrated master to abandon everything? And what kind of art could a man like that produce? The answers lie scattered across altarpieces in Florence and Berlin, a Scottish royal portrait, and a chronicle written in Latin by a fellow monk who watched van der Goes unravel.

• 2. Rise in Ghent

  ›

  Ghent's painters' guild admitted Hugo van der Goes as a master in 1467, vouched for by Joos van Wassenhove and a painter named Daneel Ruthaert. Nothing is known about his life before that year, and where he trained remains uncertain. Some historians have pointed to Dieric Bouts as a possible teacher, though no hard evidence supports that claim. Within a year of joining the guild, van der Goes was already working on commissions for the city itself. In 1468 Ghent sent him to Bruges to decorate the celebrations marking the marriage between Charles the Bold and Margaret of York. That same year, on the 18th of October, he and other guild members hosted painters from Tournai at the Ghent assembly for St. Luke's day, the feast day of the patron saint of painters. By 1469 van der Goes was prominent enough to vouch for another painter's guild entry, a man named Alexander Bening, who would later marry a cousin or sister of van der Goes. When Joos van Wassenhove left Ghent for Italy in 1470 to serve as court painter to Federico da Montefeltro, the Duke of Urbino, van der Goes stepped into the role of leading painter in the city. From 1474 to 1476 he served as deacon of the guild, a position he held repeatedly across his career.

• 3. The Portinari Triptych

  ›

  Tommaso Portinari ran the Bruges branch of the Medici Bank, and he commissioned van der Goes to paint an altarpiece for the church of San Egidio in the hospital of Santa Maria Nuova in Florence. The result was the Portinari Triptych, now held at the Uffizi. It arrived in Florence only in 1483, a year after van der Goes had died, transported from Pisa by canal to the Porta San Friano. The raw, weathered faces of the shepherds in the composition immediately struck Florentine painters. Domenico Ghirlandaio likely drew on the altarpiece for his Epiphany in the Sasseti chapel. Giorgio Vasari praised it in his Vite of 1550, calling it the work of "Ugo d'Anversa," or Hugo of Antwerp. That single reference in Vasari is the only contemporary documentation of van der Goes's authorship. Every other attribution to the artist rests on stylistic comparison with this one confirmed work. After van der Goes's death, the triptych was incorrectly credited to Andrea del Castagno and Domenico Veneziano, two painters who had made the frescoes surrounding it but had nothing to do with the altarpiece itself. Karl Friedrich Schinkel identified it correctly in 1824, though the attribution took time to gain general acceptance. The central panel holds the nativity of Jesus, the adoration of the shepherds, and an annunciation scene in the far right background. The foreground flower still life carries deliberate meaning: scarlet lilies, white and purple irises, and carnations are arranged partly in an albarello, a medicinal jar of the kind used to hold apothecaries' ointments. That detail tied the image directly to its hospital setting at Santa Maria Nuova. The side panels depict the male and female members of the Portinari family, and include the journey of Mary and Joseph to Bethlehem on the left wing and the annunciation to the Magi on the right.

• 4. Portraits of Inner Life

  ›

  No independent portraits by van der Goes survive as standalone works. His achievements in the genre are known entirely through the donor portraits embedded in his altarpieces and devotional diptychs. The Trinity Altarpiece, painted between 1473 and 1478 and now in the Scottish National Gallery in Edinburgh, was commissioned for the Church of the Holy Trinity in Edinburgh by its first provost, Edward Bonkil. The church itself had been founded by Scotland's queen consort, Mary of Guelders. The surviving panels show James III, King of Scots, with St. Andrew and his son, the future James IV, alongside his wife, Margaret of Denmark. Bonkil himself also appears. The Portrait of a Man, dated around 1475 and held at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, offers a close look at van der Goes's technique. The small panel was cut down from its original rectangular format into an oval shape at some later point. Van der Goes placed the sitter above the viewer's eye line and set the face against a dark wall, with light entering from outside. He used chiaroscuro to build the modeling of facial features, the stubble on the man's chin, and the rough texture of hands held in prayer. These details were so stark that earlier scholars attributed the painting to the Italian painter Antonello da Messina. At a time when displaying strong emotion publicly was frowned upon, van der Goes worked through the most restrained means: in the Portrait of a Man at Prayer with Saint John the Baptist, now at the Walters Art Museum, the sitter's deep concentration surfaces only in a raised eyebrow and the tension around his mouth.

• 5. The Rood Klooster

  ›

  In 1477, at what the sources describe as the peak of his career, van der Goes shut down his Ghent workshop and entered the Rood Klooster, a monastery near Auderghem, now part of Brussels. The Rood Klooster belonged to the Windesheim Congregation, the monastic wing of the Modern Devotion movement. He entered as a frater conversus, meaning a lay brother rather than a full monk. The monastery extended him unusual privileges. He was permitted to continue receiving painting commissions and to drink wine. He also received visits from eminent figures, including Archduke Maximilian, according to the Latin chronicle written between 1509 and 1513 by his fellow monk Gaspar Ofhuys. In 1482, while still at the monastery, he was asked by the counsel of the City of Leuven to assess the unfinished works that Dieric Bouts had left behind at his death. The city paid him with a jug of Rhine wine. It is believed that van der Goes completed Bouts' unfinished triptych for Hippolyte Berthoz, contributing the portraits of the couple who had funded the work. That same year the monastery sent van der Goes to Cologne alongside his half-brother Nicolaes, who had also taken religious vows. On the return journey, van der Goes suffered an acute mental breakdown. He declared himself damned and attempted suicide. His companions returned him to Brussels and then to the Rood Klooster, where he died after a brief recovery.

• 6. Madness and Memory

  ›

  Gaspar Ofhuys recorded what happened to van der Goes in his chronicle, and that document remained unknown for centuries. In 1863 the Belgian historian Alphonse Wauters published the information after discovering the Ofhuys chronicle. Wauters' account prompted his nephew, the late Romantic painter Emile Wauters, to complete his 1872 canvas Portrait of Hugo van der Goes, now in the Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium. The painting depicts van der Goes during his mental crisis and was awarded a Grand Medal at the Paris salon. A year later, in 1873, Vincent van Gogh mentioned Emile Wauters' painting in a letter to his brother Theo. On two further occasions van Gogh compared his own appearance to the 15th-century painter as Wauters had imagined him and stated that he identified emotionally with van der Goes. A German physician named Hieronymus Munzer wrote in a report dated 1495 that a painter from Ghent had been driven to melancholy by trying to equal the Ghent Altarpiece. That report may or may not describe van der Goes. The monk Ofhuys noted that van der Goes was consumed by worry over his unfinished obligations: it was said that nine years would scarcely suffice to complete what he still had to paint. Art historians have connected his later style, its narrowed palette, its distorted figures, its muted sense of space, to the ideas of the Modern Devotion movement he had joined. The movement's emphasis on meditation is seen by some scholars as the driving force behind his drift away from illusionism. Others argue his career of roughly fifteen years was simply too short for a clear stylistic evolution to emerge.

• 7. Influence and Spread

  ›

  Martin Schongauer made prints after van der Goes's compositions, carrying the Ghent master's imagery across the border into Germany. The Bruges painter Gerard David and his workshop drew clearly on van der Goes's example. Many of the original works have been lost, surviving only through the copies that followers and workshop members made from them. The large number of those copies reflects the high standing van der Goes held in his own lifetime and in the generations immediately after. After van der Goes's death, the book illustrator Alexander Bening likely came into possession of his drawings and design patterns, a natural outcome given that Bening had married into the van der Goes family. Alexander's son Simon Bening is believed to have brought those drawings into Bruges, where compositions by van der Goes appeared in an illustrated book of hours produced by the Ghent-Bruges school of illuminators. One possible autograph drawing survives at the Christ Church Picture Gallery in Oxford: a study of Jacob and Rachel that may have been a preparatory design for a stained glass window. The presence of the Portinari Triptych in Florence from 1483 onward gave Italian painters direct access to his monumental approach, his treatment of light, and his blunt realism, and that contact shaped the development of color and naturalism in Italian Renaissance art.