Heart-burial

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Heart-burial is one of the stranger customs history has left us: the deliberate removal of the heart after death, carried far from the body, and laid to rest somewhere else entirely. A silver casket hangs around the neck of a Scottish knight as he rides toward Jerusalem, carrying the heart of Robert the Bruce. A Polish composer's sister smuggles an urn through borders to place her brother's heart inside a church pillar in Warsaw. A mayor's heart sits in a storage room at a city hall for four decades while bureaucrats argue over what to do with it.

  How does a burial practice reach from a 12th-century king dying too far from home, all the way to a film set in 1994 Montana? What compelled the living to divide the dead across multiple resting places? And what happened to those hearts when empires fell, wars erupted, and regimes changed?

• 2. Origins and Practicality

  ›

  Heart-burial traces back to the beginning of the 12th century in medieval Europe, and it did not begin as ceremony. It began as logistics.

  When someone of high rank died far from home, transporting the full body back without it decaying beyond recognition was often impractical. Infection made long journeys with a corpse dangerous. Evisceration was already standard in embalming, so it was a short step to separating what could travel from what could not. The heart or entrails could be carried home as a token stand-in for the person, while the body itself was buried wherever death had found them.

  From that practical beginning, something richer developed. The separate burial of organs became a way to memorialise a person in more than one place at once. A king could rest with his family, be honored where he ruled, and be interred where he died, all at the same time. The parallel practice of burying entrails or wider viscera developed alongside heart-burial, and both were common among the higher ranks of medieval society.

• 3. Kings and Crusaders

  ›

  Otto the Great, who died in 973, was one of the earliest traced examples: his body went to Magdeburg while his entrails were interred at Memleben.

  Henry I, who died in 1135, pushed the practice further. His body was buried at Reading Abbey, but his heart, together with his bowels, brains, eyes, and tongue, was placed in Rouen Cathedral in Normandy. Richard I, who died in 1199, also had his heart preserved in a casket and placed at Rouen Cathedral, making that Normandy church an unusual repository for royal remains.

  The most dramatic story belongs to Robert the Bruce, who died in 1329. His body lies in Dunfermline Abbey, but he wanted his heart to rest at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem. On his deathbed he gave that mission to Sir James Douglas. Douglas set out, but broke his journey to fight alongside Spaniards in their war against the Moorish kings of Granada. He was killed in battle there, the heart of Bruce in a silver casket hanging around his neck the entire time. The casket was recovered and the heart was eventually buried at Melrose Abbey in Roxburghshire.

  Saer de Quincy, 1st Earl of Winchester, who died at Acre in 1219, had his heart returned to Garendon Abbey. Eleanor of Castile, Queen of Edward I, who died in 1290, was divided three ways: her body at Westminster Abbey, her heart at Blackfriars, and her other viscera at Lincoln Cathedral.

• 4. The Bishops of Ebrach

  ›

  Starting in the 13th century, the bishops of Würzburg established a collective tradition that played out over several hundred years. Each bishop directed his heart to the monastery at Ebrach in Germany, his entrails to the Marienkirche, and his body to Würzburg Cathedral.

  About 30 bishops' hearts came to rest at Ebrach over those centuries. During the German Peasants' War, some of those hearts were desecrated. The tradition held nonetheless, until Prince-Bishop Julius Echter von Mespelbrunn, who died in 1617, broke from it and chose to have his heart buried at the Neubaukirche instead.

• 5. Exile, Smuggling, and Safekeeping

  ›

  Frederic Chopin died in 1849 and had asked, before he died, that his heart be returned to his homeland. His sister carried it out in an urn, preserved in alcohol, possibly brandy. She brought it to Warsaw, where it was sealed inside a pillar of the Holy Cross Church on Krakowskie Przedmieście, beneath an epitaph sculpted by Leonard Marconi. The inscription came from Matthew VI:21: "For where your treasure is, there will your heart be also."

  The heart stayed there, except for a period during World War II when it was removed for safekeeping. The church itself was virtually destroyed in the 1944 Warsaw Uprising and later rebuilt. The Holy Cross Church stands only a short distance from the Krasiński Palace on Krakowskie Przedmieście, where Chopin had lived during his last years in Poland.

  Louis XVII, the uncrowned French claimant who died in 1795, had his heart preserved in distilled wine and later placed in a crystal urn in the 1830s. That urn was formally reburied in 2004 at the St Denis Basilica.

• 6. Hearts Under Changing Regimes

  ›

  Queen Marie of Romania, who died in 1938, left precise instructions. Her heart was to be placed inside a jewelry box she had received from Romanian noblewomen when she arrived in Bucharest in 1893, her first wedding gift from the Romanians. The box was to rest in the Stella Maris Chapel at Balchik, her favorite residence.

  After the Treaty of Craiova transferred Southern Dobruja to Bulgaria, the box was moved to Bran Castle, an estate the people of Brașov had given her as a gift after the Great Union. Her daughter Princess Ileana, who inherited the castle, built a replica of the Stella Maris Chapel and a marble crypt at the castle's base to hold it. When the communists overthrew King Michael and the Royal Family was forced to leave, Ileana tried to take the heart into exile. She could not open the marble sarcophagus, and the heart stayed behind.

  In 1968 the director of the castle's new state museum secretly opened the crypt and took the box to study it. Authorities discovered the action in 1971 and moved the box to the National Museum of History, where it remained until 2015. At that point, by wish of the Royal Family, the heart was moved in an official ceremony to Pelişor Castle and displayed in the Golden Room, the room where Queen Marie had died. Her body, meanwhile, had been buried at the Argeş Monastery, the necropolis of the Romanian Dynasty, near her husband King Ferdinand I.

  Tsar Boris III of Bulgaria died in 1943. His heart was interred in the Rila Monastery in 1994, but the main portion of his body has gone missing entirely, removed and lost across successive regime changes.

• 7. Forgotten, Disputed, and Rediscovered

  ›

  Pierre David, mayor of Verviers, died in 1839. His heart was removed to be buried separately, but disagreements over the type of memorial and the funding for it meant that the heart sat in storage at the city hall for four decades. It was eventually interred in a fountain. In 2020, extensive renovation works on that fountain led to the heart's rediscovery.

  Thomas Hardy died in 1928. His ashes were interred in Poets' Corner of Westminster Abbey, but his heart was buried in his beloved Wessex alongside his first wife. A biography of Hardy details the arguments that surrounded that decision, and also addresses the long-standing rumour that the heart was stolen by a pet cat, requiring a pig's heart to be used as a replacement.

  Peter I of Brazil and IV of Portugal, who died in 1834, requested that his heart remain in Porto, where he had endured a siege between 1832 and 1833 during a war against his brother. His remains were to go back to Brazil. Only in 1972, on the 150th anniversary of Brazilian independence, were his remains finally returned and interred in the Monument to the Independence of Brazil at Ipiranga.

• 8. Into the Modern World

  ›

  Ignacy Jan Paderewski, pianist, composer, and third Prime Minister of Poland, died in 1941. His heart is encased in a bronze sculpture at the National Shrine of Our Lady of Czestochowa near Doylestown, Pennsylvania.

  Otto von Habsburg, former head of the House of Habsburg, died in 2011. His heart was buried at the Pannonhalma Archabbey in Hungary, continuing a practice his family line had followed for centuries. John Crichton-Stuart, 3rd Marquess of Bute, who died in 1900, had his heart buried on the Mount of Olives in Jerusalem, reaching back to the same destination Robert the Bruce had wished for six centuries earlier but never achieved.

  The practice found its way into fiction as well. In the 1994 film Legends of the Fall, a character named Samuel, played by Henry Thomas, is killed while serving in the Canadian Army in World War I. His brother, played by Brad Pitt, cuts out the heart and sends it home to be buried on their father's ranch in Montana, treating an ancient medieval custom as a recognizable act of devotion for a modern audience.