Gottfried van Swieten

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  When Gottfried van Swieten pressed Frederick the Great of Prussia to return Silesia to Austria, the 60-year-old king stopped him with a single sentence. "That's the sort of suggestion you could make if I had gout in the brain," Frederick replied, "but I've only got it in my legs." Van Swieten was serving as Austria's ambassador in Berlin, tasked with a negotiation that a later account would call "thankless." He shifted to his backup plan and the First Partition of Poland proceeded, Silesia remaining Prussian.

  That exchange in 1772 offers one window into a man who spent his life working near the edges of great events. Van Swieten was born Godefridus Bernardus van Swieten in Leiden on the 29th of October 1733. He grew up in the Dutch Republic until he was eleven. His father, the physician Gerard van Swieten, accepted a post as personal doctor to Empress Maria Theresa in 1745. The family moved to Vienna, where Gottfried was educated at an elite Jesuit school, the Theresianum, and became fluent in many languages. He rose through Habsburg service to become imperial librarian, then head of the state's education and censorship apparatus. One historian rated the latter position the equivalent of minister of culture. His musical protégés included Joseph Haydn, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, and Ludwig van Beethoven. Yet he remains nearly invisible beside them, a figure whose rooms, manuscripts, and money helped make some of the most enduring music ever written.

  20195

• 2. The Musical Diplomat

  ›

  Count Cobenzl, van Swieten's supervisor in Brussels, wrote in a 1756 report that "music takes up the best part of his time." Van Swieten had arrived at his first diplomatic posting in Brussels in 1755. By the time he left in 1757, he was already pursuing music alongside his official duties.

  His subsequent postings took him to Paris from 1760 to 1763, then briefly to Warsaw as envoy in 1763-1764. The posting that shaped him most was his final one: ambassador to the court of Frederick the Great in Berlin, serving from 1770 to 1777. In Berlin, van Swieten studied counterpoint with Johann Philipp Kirnberger, who had been a direct pupil of Johann Sebastian Bach. He also joined the musical circle of Princess Anna Amalia, where the works of Bach and Handel were regularly performed and studied.

  Performers in that era typically played only newly composed music, often their own. The circle around Princess Anna Amalia was doing something unusual, treating the works of earlier generations as worthy of sustained attention. Van Swieten absorbed that conviction and carried it back to Vienna, where it would shape the direction of music for decades. A comic opera of his own composition was staged during his time in Paris, suggesting that musical practice, not just appreciation, occupied him throughout his diplomatic years.

  201927

• 3. The First Card Catalog

  ›

  In 1780, van Swieten introduced the world's first card catalog to the Imperial Library in Vienna. Libraries had previously recorded their holdings in bound volumes, fixed lists that could not be updated without recopying entire sections. Van Swieten's innovation of using individual cards allowed new entries to be inserted wherever they belonged, in a continuously searchable order.

  He had been appointed prefect of the library in 1777, when he returned to Vienna from his posting in Berlin. The position had stood vacant for five years since the death of his father, who had held the same post. Van Swieten remained in the role for the rest of his life.

  The card catalog spread quickly. Revolutionary France adopted it, and from there the system moved across the literate world. Van Swieten also expanded the library's holdings, acquiring books on science and salvaging volumes from monasteries dissolved under the decrees of Emperor Joseph II. By 1781, van Swieten had been drawn far deeper into that same Emperor's reform agenda, into a set of appointments that would give him authority over Austrian cultural life that no librarian alone could wield.

  42120

• 4. Reform and Ruin

  ›

  In 1781, Emperor Joseph II appointed van Swieten Councillor of State and Director of the State Education Commission. The following year brought a third post: Director of a newly created Censorship Commission. Braunbehrens estimated that taken together, these positions were roughly the equivalent of serving as minister of culture.

  Scholar Edward Olleson describes Joseph's ambition: the Emperor's goal of building a politically engaged middle class depended on "great advances in elementary education, and on the universities." Van Swieten's liberal outlook fitted him, in Olleson's assessment, to implement those plans. The same reforms that expanded press freedom triggered a flood of pamphlets critical of the government, adding new responsibilities to the Censorship Commission. Van Swieten's letters from this period describe an extremely heavy workload.

  In 1784, van Swieten proposed that the Holy Roman Empire adopt a copyright law. England had possessed such a law since 1709. The Emperor rejected the proposal. Scholar Nicholas Till later observed that a functioning copyright law might have transformed the career of Mozart, who depended on commissions and patronage rather than on steady royalties.

  The political tide turned in 1787, when Joseph launched what one account described as a "disastrous, futile, and costly" war against the Turks. The conflict destabilized Austrian society and undermined the reform program. Joseph, by then terminally ill, turned on van Swieten. He blamed him for permitting too much press freedom and for pursuing an educational program that stripped religious instruction from schools. In 1790, Joseph wrote to Chancellor Kolowrat that "since an essential aspect of the education of young people, namely religion and morality, is treated far too lightly... the state is deprived of the essential advantages of having raised right-thinking and well-behaved citizens." Joseph died later that year. His more conservative brother Leopold took the throne, further weakening van Swieten's position. A bitter power struggle followed. Van Swieten was stripped of his commission post on the 5th of December 1791. That same night, his protégé Mozart died.

  5201926

• 5. Mozart and the Old Masters

  ›

  Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was eleven years old when he first met van Swieten in 1768, during the Mozart family's visit to Vienna. According to Mozart's father Leopold, van Swieten was involved in the early planning of the opera La finta semplice, though the work was later blocked by intrigues and could only be performed in Salzburg.

  Thirteen years passed before their paths crossed again with lasting consequence. In 1781, shortly after Mozart settled in Vienna, he played extracts from Idomeneo at the salon of Countess Thun. Van Swieten was in the audience. That event helped trigger the commission for Die Entführung aus dem Serail, Mozart's first major success in the city.

  By 1782, van Swieten was inviting Mozart to his home every Sunday. Mozart described the gatherings in a letter to his father Leopold dated the 10th of April 1782: "I go every Sunday at twelve o'clock to the Baron van Swieten, where nothing is played but Handel and Bach. I am collecting at the moment the fugues of Bach - not only of Sebastian, but also of Emanuel and Friedemann." Van Swieten gave Mozart the task of transcribing fugues for small instrumental ensembles. At the keyboard, Mozart also rendered the orchestral scores of Handel's oratorios in spontaneous reduction. According to Joseph Weigl, he sang one of the choral parts himself while correcting errors of the other singers.

  Scholar Olleson describes the effect on Mozart as unfolding in two stages. At first, Mozart responded with direct imitations, writing fugues and suites in the style of his models. These works have, in Olleson's phrase, "a dryness which is absent from most of Mozart's music," and many were left unfinished. In a second stage, Mozart absorbed the influence more fully into his own voice. Olleson points to two moments that show this deeper integration. The first is the C minor Mass of 1783. The other is the chorale prelude sung by the two armored men in The Magic Flute of 1791. In 1786, van Swieten formalized the Sunday gatherings into something larger, founding an organization of music-loving nobles whose resources would reshape Mozart's final years.

  192092527

• 6. The Gesellschaft and Haydn

  ›

  In 1786, van Swieten founded the Gesellschaft der Associierten, known in English as the Society of Associated Cavaliers. It was a private body of music-loving nobles assembled to fund full-scale performances of the works van Swieten had long championed. Concerts typically began in van Swieten's private rooms in the Vienna Hofburg, then moved to a public performance in the Burgtheater or Jahn's Hall.

  Mozart took on the task of conducting these concerts in 1788. He had previously been occupied with other commitments, but a decline in his career prospects elsewhere made the post welcome. Four works were prepared for contemporary audiences. Acis and Galatea was performed at Jahn's Hall in approximately November 1788. For Der Messias, an adaptation of Handel's Messiah, Mozart wrote entirely new parts for flutes, clarinets, bassoons, horns, and trombones, as well as additional notes for the timpani. The Ode for St Cecilia's Day and Alexander's Feast followed in 1790. Van Swieten translated the English libretti into German for all four.

  Mozart's financial situation during this period was precarious. A letter of 1789 shows van Swieten's loyalty: after two weeks soliciting subscriptions to a projected concert series, the Baron remained the only subscriber. When Mozart died at 1:00 am on the 5th of December 1791, van Swieten came to his home and made the funeral arrangements. On the 2nd of January 1793, he organized a performance of Mozart's Requiem for Constanze's benefit. It yielded a profit of 300 ducats. He also reportedly helped arrange the education of Mozart's son Karl in Prague.

  Joseph Haydn had been part of van Swieten's orbit since 1776. That year, van Swieten visited Vienna from Berlin and offered encouragement to the 43-year-old composer, who was frustrated by hostile reviews his work was receiving from certain Berlin critics. Van Swieten told him his works were in high demand there. Haydn noted the gesture appreciatively in his autobiographical sketch of that year.

  In 1794, van Swieten provided Haydn with a carriage for the second of his London journeys. On Haydn's return the following year, their relationship deepened into a close creative collaboration, with van Swieten serving as librettist and artistic adviser. Their first joint project was a choral version of The Seven Last Words of Christ. Haydn had originally composed the piece as an orchestral work in 1785. During his second London journey, he had heard a choral version prepared by the Passau Kapellmeister Joseph Friebert. Liking the idea, he prepared his own choral version, with van Swieten revising Friebert's lyrics.

  The collaboration then moved to two larger works: The Creation, premiered in 1798, and The Seasons, premiered in 1801. Van Swieten adapted the source texts, drawing on John Milton's Paradise Lost and James Thomson's poem The Seasons. He also translated the German back into English. This allowed the first published editions to serve both German- and English-speaking audiences, though Olleson notes the reverse translation was often awkward. In the margins of his libretti, van Swieten made specific suggestions about musical setting, which Haydn "observed closely." In The Creation, God commands the newly created animals to multiply. For this episode, van Swieten proposed a specific texture: the bass soloist singing over an unadorned bass line. Haydn partly followed, but then added a rich four-part harmony for divided cellos and violas. That addition proved crucial to the passage's final character.

  1920291722

• 7. Beethoven and Other Composers

  ›

  Ludwig van Beethoven arrived in Vienna in the early 1790s and found his way to van Swieten's home. The evening gatherings there centered on Bach and Handel. Anton Schindler, one of Beethoven's early biographers, described van Swieten as "musically insatiable." He wrote that the host would not let the young pianist leave until he had "blessed the evening" with several Bach fugues.

  Modern musicologists do not fully trust Schindler's account. Beethoven had encountered Bach's fugues before knowing van Swieten. His teacher Christian Gottlob Neefe, in a letter promoting Beethoven's abilities, noted that the young musician was already playing The Well-Tempered Clavier of Sebastian Bach. But a concrete document confirms that the evenings took place. A letter from van Swieten to Beethoven, dated Monday the 15th of December 1794, reads: "If you are not hindered this coming Wednesday, I wish to see you at my home at 8:30 in the evening with your nightcap in your bag." Scholar Albrecht explains the nightcap: Vienna enforced a citywide 9 pm curfew. If Beethoven stayed past it at van Swieten's, he would have to pay Prince Lichnowsky's turnkey a fee to be let back through the locked house doors.

  Ferdinand Ries later reported: "Of all composers, Beethoven valued Mozart and Handel most highly, then J. S. Bach." In 1801, Beethoven dedicated his First Symphony to van Swieten.

  Earlier in his career, during his Berlin posting, van Swieten had also supported Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach. He commissioned six Symphonies for String Orchestra from Bach in 1773. The commission specified that "the composer's creative imagination might have free rein, unfettered by any regard for technical difficulties." The third set of Bach's Sonaten für Kenner und Liebhaber, published in 1781, was dedicated to van Swieten. Johann Nikolaus Forkel, who wrote the first biography of Johann Sebastian Bach, also dedicated his book to van Swieten. Forkel's dedication acknowledged van Swieten as central to the preservation of Bach's legacy, a role he had pursued long before most of his contemporaries thought it mattered.

  23319277

• 8. Patriarch of Music

  ›

  Haydn told his biographer Georg August Griesinger that van Swieten's symphonies were "as stiff as the man himself." The Grove Dictionary was equally blunt. It described his conservative, three-movement symphonies as characterized by "tautology and paucity of invention" and concluded that "as a composer van Swieten is insignificant." He had written three comic operas, including Les talents à la mode and Colas, toujours Colas, as well as ten symphonies, of which seven survive. One opera, La chercheuse d'esprit, is lost.

  Haydn's friend and pupil Sigismund Neukomm described van Swieten as "not so much a friend as a very self-opinionated patron of Haydn and Mozart." Olleson found that "in his own time van Swieten won little affection" but that he received "almost universal respect." He maintained a formal social distance from the composers he patronized, rooted in the system of aristocracy still in force in Austria. An 1801 letter from Haydn to van Swieten, written after years of close collaboration, closes: "I remain, with profound respect, / Your Excellency's / most humble and obedient servant, / Joseph Haydn."

  Olleson noted that van Swieten had singled out, from a field crowded with now-forgotten contemporaries, the composers that posterity has ranked most highly. Those names were Sebastian Bach, Handel, Gluck, Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach, Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven. Olleson's verdict: "One could scarcely quarrel with his choice."

  William Weber, writing on the history of concert life, notes that in van Swieten's time performers typically played only newly composed music, often their own. The practice of reviving the works of earlier generations was rare and considered by some a fringe inclination. Van Swieten championed it by programming older music and by encouraging living composers to learn from masters who preceded them. The music publisher Johann Ferdinand von Schönfeld wrote in 1796 that van Swieten was "looked upon as a patriarch of music." Schönfeld added that "semi-connoisseurs never take their eyes off him, seeking to read in his features, not always intelligible to everyone, what ought to be their opinion of the music."

  Otto Jahn, in his 1856 Mozart biography, recorded an anecdote from Sigismund Neukomm about the silence van Swieten demanded at concerts. Whenever conversation arose during a performance, van Swieten would rise from his seat in the front row. He drew himself up to his full height and fixed the offenders with a long, serious look. He would then very slowly resume his seat. It never failed of its effect.

  Van Swieten died in Vienna on the 29th of March 1803. Among the paintings he left was one now considered extraordinary: the Art of Painting by Vermeer, which he had inherited from his father. At the time of his death, it was not yet known that the work was by Vermeer.

  192011130