Export Control Act

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Export Control Act of 1940 began not as a law passed by Congress but as a presidential proclamation. Franklin D. Roosevelt issued it to block the sale of aircraft parts, chemicals, and minerals to foreign buyers without a government license. The immediate target was Imperial Japan, and the immediate goal was to pressure Tokyo into pulling back from its occupation of the coast of Indochina. What started as a targeted diplomatic signal would expand, layer by layer, across decades, until it became one of the most sweeping instruments of American foreign policy in the twentieth century. How did a wartime emergency measure outlast the war it was built to fight? And how did a law aimed at Japan end up shaping trade with the Soviet Union, China, and dozens of other countries for generations? Those are the questions this documentary will answer.

• 2. Moral Embargo

  ›

  In June 1938, Secretary of State Cordell Hull publicly condemned Japan's bombing of civilians in mainland China, calling out the "material encouragement" that American exports were providing to those attacks. A month after Hull's condemnation, the State Department sent a direct warning to American aircraft manufacturers and exporters. The government was, in its own words, "strongly opposed" to selling airplanes and related equipment to any nation using aircraft to kill civilian populations. This was the so-called "moral embargo": not a law, not a trade sanction, but a statement of collective disgust backed by bureaucratic pressure. It was a codified expression of moral outrage, and it set the political tone for everything that followed.

• 3. Breaking the Treaty

  ›

  Japan had long held the status of a most favoured nation under a commercial treaty signed between the two countries in 1911. That status was a genuine legal obstacle. As long as the treaty held, the United States could not legally single out Japanese commerce for retaliation without violating its own treaty obligations. Diplomatic efforts to protect American lives, rights, and economic interests in China had failed, and the American government concluded that the treaty was not providing adequate protection for US commerce in Japanese-occupied territory. In July 1939, Washington gave the required six months' notice of withdrawal from the 1911 treaty, clearing the legal path for an embargo. The primary legal obstacle was gone before the Export Control Act itself was even signed.

• 4. The Embargo's Edges

  ›

  The embargo that took shape was deliberately calibrated. Halting shipments of airplanes, machine tools, and aviation gasoline was designed to be an unfriendly act, and American officials knew it. But extending that ban to oil was a different calculation entirely. Japan was heavily dependent on American oil, and planners in Washington believed that cutting off oil would cross from pressure into provocation. Iron and steel scrap were added to the list in September 1940, a move that Japanese Ambassador Kensuke Horinouchi personally warned Secretary Hull on the 8th of October 1940 could be seen as an "unfriendly act." The oil and steel export bans finally took effect between June and August of 1941, months before the United States entered the war.

• 5. From War to Cold War

  ›

  The original 1940 act was always intended to be temporary. It was extended in 1944, 1945, 1946, and 1947, each time as a provisional measure. When the United States entered World War II after December 1941, the act's coverage was broadened to all commodities and extended to a wider geographic range. By 1949, officials assumed the remaining controls would soon disappear. That assumption did not survive the Korean War. The outbreak of fighting on the Korean peninsula gave national security and foreign policy a new urgency, and the Export Control Act of 1949 was renewed in 1951, 1953-1956, and again in 1958. The postwar version of the law was explicitly aimed at preventing advanced technology from reaching the Soviet bloc and China.

• 6. Controlling Knowledge

  ›

  What made the Cold War iteration of export control distinctive was that the technology being restricted did not have to be military in any conventional sense. In 1982, Bell Labs's chess-playing computer, known as Belle, was impounded by US authorities before it could travel to Moscow for an exhibition. A chess computer, built to play a game, was treated as a strategic asset that could not be allowed to cross the Iron Curtain. The law also reached beyond American borders. Under the 1949 act, controls applied to all persons wherever situated, meaning that the reach of American export regulation extended to foreign nationals and foreign entities operating outside the United States. The United States even pushed its allies to adopt parallel controls, threatening to withhold benefits from economic and military aid programs if they refused to cooperate, as formalized in the Mutual Defense Assistance Control Act of 1951.