EC Comics

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  EC Comics began as Educational Comics, a modest publisher founded by Max Gaines with church bulletins and Bible stories in mind. Within a decade, it had become the most controversial comic book company in America, dragged before Congress and blamed for corrupting the nation's youth. How did a company that started by marketing scripture to schools end up publishing a story in which a man's wife stuffs his taxidermied body and mounts it on the wall?

  The answer runs through a boating accident in 1947, a son who never became a chemistry teacher, two editors of astonishing productivity, and a cadre of freelance artists whose names would become legends. It also runs through a censorship battle so heated that two grown men shouted an obscenity at a federal administrator in unison, over the telephone, and won.

  What made EC Comics different from every other publisher of the era? Why did its horror books trigger a national moral panic while its satire magazine, Mad, went on to become one of the longest-running humor publications in the country? And what does a robot planet divided by skin color have to do with the American civil rights struggle? Those are the questions this documentary will answer.

• 2. Max Gaines and the Origin

  ›

  Max Gaines had already helped invent the American comic book before he ever founded EC. His work with Eastern Color Printing produced a proto-comic called Funnies on Parade, and his involvement with Dell Publishing's Famous Funnies: A Carnival of Comics gave historians what they consider the first true American comic book.

  Gaines was the former editor of All-American Publications when he set up Educational Comics, initially as a shell company of All-American itself. His plan was practical and churchgoing: sell comics about science, history, and the Bible to schools and religious institutions. When All-American merged with DC Comics in June 1945, Gaines retained rights to one title, Picture Stories from the Bible, and used those rights and the EC name to keep his new venture alive.

  He expanded into children's humor quickly, but the educational mission remained the organizing principle. Then, in 1947, Max Gaines died in a boating accident, and the company passed to his son William. The initials EC would soon stand for something entirely different.

• 3. Bill Gaines and the New Trend

  ›

  William Gaines had spent four years in the Army Air Corps and had returned home intending to study at New York University and become a chemistry teacher. He never taught. Instead, he inherited his father's comic company and, starting in 1949 and 1950, began a line of titles that had nothing to do with education.

  He renamed the company Entertaining Comics and launched what the industry would call the New Trend: horror, suspense, science fiction, military fiction, and crime fiction. His two editors, Al Feldstein and Harvey Kurtzman, were not just editors. They drew covers and stories themselves, and they commissioned work from a roster of freelance artists whose names fill any serious history of the medium: Johnny Craig, Reed Crandall, Jack Davis, Will Elder, George Evans, Frank Frazetta, Graham Ingels, Jack Kamen, Bernard Krigstein, Joe Orlando, John Severin, Al Williamson, Basil Wolverton, and Wally Wood.

  EC did something unusual for the era: it promoted its artists publicly. Each artist signed his work. The company published one-page biographies of them inside the comics themselves. This stood in sharp contrast to the wider industry, where credits were routinely omitted. At EC's peak, Feldstein edited seven titles at once while Kurtzman handled three. Writers Carl Wessler, Jack Oleck, and Otto Binder were later brought in to help manage the volume.

  Gaines himself contributed to the creative process by staying up late reading large quantities of material, searching for what he called springboards for story concepts. Each morning he would pitch premises to Feldstein until one clicked. The result was a consistent output of stories with surprise endings, poetic justice, and an undercurrent of social conscience that distinguished them from anything else on the newsstand.

• 4. The Horror Titles and Their Themes

  ›

  Tales from the Crypt, The Vault of Horror, and The Haunt of Fear were EC's most notorious publications. Each had a horror host: the Crypt Keeper, the Vault-Keeper, and the Old Witch. These characters did not simply introduce stories. They squabbled with one another, made puns, and insulted the readers directly, addressing them as "boils and ghouls." That mocking, irreverent voice became a template. Stan Lee would later adopt a similar give-and-take with Marvel Comics readers.

  The stories themselves followed recognizable patterns. The most common was an ordinary situation given a gruesome ironic twist, often framed as poetic justice. In one story titled "Collection Completed", a man takes up taxidermy to irritate his wife; she kills him when he stuffs her cat, then mounts his body herself. In "Revulsion", a spaceship pilot repulsed by insects discovers, in the final reversal, that a giant alien insect is equally repulsed by finding the dead pilot in its salad. Siamese twins appeared in no fewer than nine stories across EC's horror and crime comics between 1950 and 1954; Feldstein later speculated that he and Gaines returned to the theme because it mirrored their own creative interdependence.

  There were also Grim Fairy Tales, offering gruesome retellings of Hansel and Gretel, Sleeping Beauty, and Little Red Riding Hood. Adaptations of Ray Bradbury's science-fiction stories appeared in roughly two dozen EC comics starting in 1952, after an incident that began as plagiarism: Feldstein and Gaines had combined two of Bradbury's stories into a single unauthorized tale. When Bradbury discovered it, he wrote a note praising the adaptation while remarking that he had "inadvertently" not yet received payment. EC sent a check, and a productive licensing arrangement followed.

  The war comics, Frontline Combat and Two-Fisted Tales, took a deliberately unheroic approach. Stories featured weary soldiers, not triumphant ones, which put EC at odds with the patriotic tone favored elsewhere. Shock SuspenStories addressed racism, drug use, and political corruption. Crime SuspenStories drew heavily on film noir; as historian Max Allan Collins observed in his annotations for Russ Cochran's 1983 hardcover reprint, Johnny Craig had developed a cinematic visual style, and EC's crime stories showed the influence of writers associated with film noir, particularly James M. Cain. David Hajdu wrote that to postwar young people, nothing in EC's comics was more subversive than Craig's domestic scheming stories set against the exits of the Long Island Expressway.

• 5. Mad and the Censorship Crisis

  ›

  Mad began as a side project for Harvey Kurtzman before it became the company's defining publication. When satire became popular in 1954 and other publishers started producing imitations, EC launched a companion title, Panic, edited by Feldstein and using the regular Mad artists alongside Joe Orlando.

  The censorship crisis that nearly destroyed EC had been building since the late 1940s. In 1948, psychiatrist Fredric Wertham published two articles linking comics to juvenile delinquency: "Horror in the Nursery" in Collier's and "The Psychopathology of Comic Books" in the American Journal of Psychotherapy. An industry trade group, the Association of Comics Magazine Publishers, formed that same year but proved toothless. EC left the association in 1950 after Gaines quarreled with its executive director, Henry Schultz. By 1954, only three publishers remained members, and Schultz himself admitted the ACMP seals were meaningless.

  In 1954, Wertham published Seduction of the Innocent. Congressional hearings on juvenile delinquency followed, with comic books cast as a primary cause. A federal investigation into distribution companies destabilized the entire industry, and sales collapsed. Gaines convened a meeting of his fellow publishers and proposed collective resistance to outside censorship. The result was the Comics Magazine Association of America and its Comics Code Authority. The code was far stricter than the old ACMP rules and was enforced rigorously, requiring code approval before publication. Among the new restrictions: no comic book title could use the words horror or terror on its cover.

  Gaines refused to join the association. When distributors declined to handle his horror and SuspenStory titles, he ended publication of all five of them on the 14th of September 1954. A brief attempt at a New Direction line of more realistic comics failed commercially after each title reached its fifth issue. A Picto-Fiction experiment, using typeset text with heavy illustration, lost money from the start and lasted only two issues per title. When EC's national distributor went bankrupt, Gaines dropped everything except Mad.

  Converting Mad from a comic book to a magazine format served a double purpose: it reconciled Kurtzman, who had received an outside offer from the magazine Pageant but wanted to stay, and it removed Mad from Comics Code jurisdiction. Kurtzman left anyway soon afterward, when Gaines refused to give him 51 percent control. Feldstein returned as his successor and steered the magazine through decades of commercial success.

• 6. Judgment Day

  ›

  "Judgment Day" was a story originally published in Weird Fantasy #18 in April 1953. Written by Al Feldstein and drawn by Joe Orlando, it depicted a human astronaut visiting the robot planet Cybrinia as a representative of the Galactic Republic. On Cybrinia, robots of identical function were divided into orange and blue races, with one group holding fewer rights than the other. The astronaut concludes that the planet is not ready for admission to the Galactic Republic because of this bigotry. In the final panel, he removes his helmet, and the reader sees that he is a Black man.

  When Gaines tried to reprint the story in Incredible Science Fiction #33 in February 1956, the Comics Code Administrator, Judge Charles Murphy, objected. His stated reason, as comics historian Digby Diehl recounted in Tales from the Crypt: The Official Archives, was simply that the central character was Black. Feldstein confronted Murphy directly. "I went in there with this story and Murphy says, 'It can't be a Black man'. But... but that's the whole point of the story!" Feldstein later told interviewers.

  When Murphy continued to insist, Feldstein delivered an ultimatum and reported back to Gaines. Gaines called Murphy himself. "This is ridiculous!" he said. "I'm going to call a press conference on this. You have no grounds, no basis, to do this. I'll sue you." Murphy, apparently attempting a compromise, said: "All right. Just take off the beads of sweat." He was referring to the glistening perspiration Feldstein had drawn on the astronaut's dark skin. Gaines and Feldstein responded simultaneously and identically, and Murphy hung up. The story ran without a single alteration.

  Incredible Science Fiction #33 turned out to be the last EC comic book ever published, making "Judgment Day" the final statement of EC's comic line: a defiant affirmation of racial equality, printed in its original form.

• 7. Afterlife in Reprints and Film

  ›

  Gaines sold the company in the 1960s as E.C. Publications, Inc. It was eventually absorbed into the same corporation that later acquired National Periodical Publications, the publisher then known as DC Comics. In June 1967, Kinney National Company, formed on the 12th of August 1966 from a merger of Kinney Parking and National Cleaning, purchased National Periodical and EC. Kinney then bought Warner Bros.-Seven Arts in early 1969, and after a financial scandal over price fixing in its parking operations, spun off its non-entertainment assets in September 1971. The renamed Warner Communications emerged on the 10th of February 1972.

  During the 1960s, Gaines gave permission to Bob Barrett, Roger Hill, and Jerry Norton Weist, co-founder of the comic shop Million Year Picnic, to produce an EC fanzine called Squa Tront. It ran from 1967 to 1983.

  Film adaptations came in waves. Tales from the Crypt became a movie in 1972, followed by The Vault of Horror in 1973. Creepshow in 1982 and Creepshow 2, while based on original scripts by Stephen King and George A. Romero, drew direct inspiration from EC's horror comics. In 1989, Tales from the Crypt began airing on HBO, running for seven seasons and 93 episodes through 1996. Two children's television series followed on broadcast TV, along with three branded films: Demon Knight, Bordello of Blood, and Ritual. In 1997, HBO added Perversions of Science, a 10-episode series drawing on Weird Science stories.

  Reprint collections kept the original comics accessible across generations. Ballantine Books published five black-and-white paperbacks between 1964 and 1966. The EC Horror Library from Nostalgia Press in 1971, selected by Bhob Stewart and Bill Gaines, was among the first books to reprint comic stories in color, following the original color guides by Marie Severin. Russ Cochran produced an extensive series of hardcovers and archives. IDW Publishing launched a series of Artist's Editions in February 2010, reproducing original inked pages in their 15-by-22-inch format, including scans of Wally Wood's work, stories from Mad, and collections devoted to Jack Davis and Graham Ingels. In February 2024, Oni Press announced a revival of the EC brand, beginning with the horror title Epitaphs from the Abyss and the science fiction title Cruel Universe, with the Gaines family continuing to license the titles.