Decree of the President of Russia
A Decree of the President of the Russian Federation sits at a peculiar crossroads of law and power. It carries the formal title Указ Президента Российской Федерации in Russian, and its reach is absolute: every decree is binding on the entire territory of Russia the moment it takes effect. But the story of what that instrument can and cannot do is more complicated than it first appears. What limits does the Russian Constitution place on presidential decrees? How did one president use them during a constitutional crisis? And how did the legal landscape shift after a referendum in 2020 changed the relationship between Russian law and international agreements? Those questions thread through the history of this document.
Presidential decrees occupy a defined rung in Russia's hierarchy of legal acts, sitting alongside decrees of the Government of the Russian Federation and the instructions of other officials. They carry the highest legal force after the Constitution of the Russian Federation and federal laws, but they cannot alter or override those superior instruments. Federal Constitutional Laws, Federal Laws, and even laws of Russian regions all outrank a presidential decree.
Decrees must not contradict the Constitution of the Russian Federation or federal constitutional laws. If a decree conflicts with existing law of higher precedence, the law prevails and the decree can be superseded. This structure means presidential decrees are subordinate legal acts, not supreme commands. They fill space that existing legislation has not already occupied.
Every act of the President of the Russian Federation must be officially published within ten days after the date of its signing. That publication requirement is not optional; it governs the entire class of presidential acts. From that point, the clock on enforceability begins.
Normative decrees, those with a general regulatory character, enter into force simultaneously across the entire territory of Russia seven days after their first official publication. Non-normative orders and acts containing information classified as state secrets or confidential information follow a different rule: they come into force from the date of signing itself. The decree itself may also establish its own procedure for entry into force, allowing the president to set a custom timeline when circumstances call for it. When a decree carries classified information, the letter "c" or the letters "cc" are added to its number, depending on the level of secrecy involved.
Beyond issuing its own decrees, the Russian presidency holds a specific authority over the acts of executive bodies within Russia's regions. By decree, the President of Russia has the right to suspend the operation of regional executive acts when those acts contradict the Constitution, federal constitutional laws and federal laws, or Russia's international obligations. Violations of human and civil rights and freedoms also trigger this suspending authority.
This power places the president as a constitutional backstop for the entire executive branch, extending control downward through the federation. Regional executive authorities cannot shelter behind local acts if those acts run counter to federal norms. In the Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation, presidential acts are published in the third section, with regulatory decrees appearing first and non-normative orders following.
In 1992 and 1993, a sustained conflict between President Boris Yeltsin and the Russian parliament became known as the "war of laws." Presidential decrees issued by Yeltsin were overturned by separate legislation adopted by the parliament, creating a state of legal paralysis. Each side wielded the instruments available to it; Yeltsin signed decrees, parliament passed laws to annul them.
The conflict reached its peak in October 1993 when Yeltsin ordered the parliament building to be shot. That act broke the impasse by force rather than by law. The referendum that followed in 1993 resulted in a new constitution, and the dynamic shifted. Many decrees that Yeltsin had issued became part of a process that gradually shrank as the legislative vacuum filled in. As parliament enacted various laws, the range of presidential discretion available through decree narrowed correspondingly.
Until the 2020 Russian constitutional referendum, Russia's international agreements occupied a position of precedence above presidential decrees. That referendum changed the hierarchy. After the vote, international agreements dropped below presidential decrees and all other Russian state law or obligations in terms of legal precedence.
The practical meaning of that shift is significant. A presidential decree now outranks an international agreement, reversing the prior order. This places Russia's internal executive instruments in a position of formal supremacy over its treaty commitments, a reorientation that touched one of the foundational rules governing how Russian law interacts with the outside world.
Common questions
What is a Decree of the President of Russia?
A Decree of the President of the Russian Federation is a legal act with the status of a by-law made by the President of Russia. It is binding on the entire territory of Russia and carries the highest legal force after the Constitution of the Russian Federation and federal laws.
How does a Russian presidential decree enter into force?
Normative presidential decrees must be officially published within ten days of signing and enter into force seven days after first official publication, simultaneously across all of Russia. Acts containing state secrets or confidential information come into force from the date of signing.
Can a Decree of the President of Russia override federal law?
No. Presidential decrees may not alter the Constitution of the Russian Federation, Federal Constitutional Laws, Federal Laws, or laws of Russian regions. Any of those instruments can supersede a presidential decree.
What was the "war of laws" between Yeltsin and the Russian parliament?
In 1992 and 1993, a conflict arose in which presidential decrees issued by Boris Yeltsin were overturned by legislation adopted by the parliament. The standoff peaked in October 1993 when Yeltsin ordered the parliament building to be shot, ending with a new constitution enacted after the 1993 referendum.
How did the 2020 Russian constitutional referendum affect presidential decrees?
Before the 2020 referendum, Russia's international agreements outranked presidential decrees in the legal hierarchy. After the referendum, international agreements dropped below presidential decrees and all other Russian state law, reversing the prior precedence order.
Can the President of Russia suspend regional executive acts?
Yes. By decree, the President of Russia has the right to suspend the operation of acts of regional executive authorities when those acts contradict the Constitution, federal laws, Russia's international obligations, or violate human and civil rights and freedoms.
All sources
6 references cited across the entry
- 6BookHandbook of New Institutional EconomicsC. Menard et al. — Springer — 2005