Decian persecution

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Decian persecution began with a piece of paper. In 250 AD, every resident of the Roman Empire was ordered to sacrifice to the gods, then obtain a signed certificate from a magistrate proving they had done so. No exceptions, no delays. For most people, compliance was a minor inconvenience. For Christians, it was a moment of existential reckoning.

  The man behind the order was Decius, who had come to power in 249 through military victories. He admired Rome's past so deeply that he added the name of the revered emperor Trajan to his own. He restored the ancient office of censor. He repaired the Colosseum. And on the 3rd of January 250, after performing the annual sacrifice to Jupiter himself, he issued an edict that would send tremors through the Christian communities scattered across his empire.

  What exactly did the edict require? Who was exempt, and why? And what happened to the hundreds of thousands of people caught between a government decree and their deepest convictions?

• 2. The Loyalty Test

  ›

  Decius issued his edict as an empire-wide loyalty oath, sanctified through Roman religion. The text itself has not survived, but its requirements are known because the certificates it demanded survived in large numbers, particularly from Egypt. These documents were called libelli.

  A surviving example from Egypt shows the level of formal detail involved. A woman named Aurelia Ammonous, daughter of Mystus, identified herself as a priestess from the Moeris quarter. She stated that she had sacrificed to the gods all her life, and that she had now sacrificed again in accordance with the decree, poured a libation, and partaken of the sacred victims. She requested the commission certify this below her statement.

  Every person in the empire was expected to produce paperwork of this kind. The sacrifice had to be performed before a Roman magistrate in person. A signed and witnessed certificate then confirmed that the act had taken place. The edict was not framed as a weapon against Christians specifically. It was framed as a demonstration of collective piety and devotion to the emperor's well-being.

• 3. Why Jews Were Spared

  ›

  Jews were specifically exempted from the requirement to sacrifice, and this exemption had a long legal history behind it. Julius Caesar had formulated a policy permitting Jews to observe their traditional religious practices. Augustus followed and extended that policy. The result was that Judaism held the official status of religio licita, a permitted religion, throughout the empire.

  Roman authorities placed great weight on ancestral tradition in religion. Jews worshipped as their ancestors had always worshipped. It was widely understood by Roman officials that Jews would not sacrifice to Roman gods or burn incense before an emperor's image, and this had been tolerated for generations.

  Christianity had no such standing. Pliny the Younger and Tacitus, writing around 116 AD, both used the same word for it: superstitio. This Latin term described excessive, non-traditional religiosity judged to be socially disruptive. Christians had abandoned the religion of their ancestors, unlike the Jews, and they were actively seeking converts. That combination, departure from tradition plus proselytism, struck Roman authorities as dangerous. Refusing to sacrifice for the emperor's well-being looked, to Roman eyes, like sedition.

• 4. Faith Under Pressure

  ›

  Pope Fabian died as a direct result of refusing to comply. So did Babylas of Antioch and Alexander of Jerusalem. The number of ordinary Christians put to death for refusing to obtain a certificate is not recorded.

  Many Christians, however, did comply. At Carthage, so many people came forward to perform the required sacrifice that the authorities were overwhelmed. They were forced to issue a notice asking the crowds to return the next day because the volume was too great to process. This was not a case of a defiant community standing firm; it was a stampede toward compliance.

  Others chose a third path. Dionisius of Alexandria and Cyprianus of Carthage both went into hiding rather than sacrifice or face death. Large numbers of Christians throughout Egypt, Africa, and Anatolia followed the same course, disappearing from their communities until the danger passed.

• 5. Aftermath and Memory

  ›

  Decius died in June 251, and with him died the enforcement of his edict. By that point it had been in force for approximately eighteen months. The effects on Christian communities, many of which had until then lived undisturbed, were lasting.

  The question of what to do with those who had lapsed in their faith became a source of serious internal conflict. Novatian, whose position was schismatic, opposed readmitting those who had sacrificed or obtained certificates under pressure. His refusal to accept the lapsed back into the community split congregations.

  In collective Christian memory, the Decian persecution became a byword for monstrous tyranny, an episode that loomed far larger than its eighteen months might suggest. Deliberate persecution resumed under emperor Valerian in 257 AD, followed by a period of relative tolerance under Gallienus. Then, in 303 AD, the Diocletianic Persecution began, and the scale of what Christians had faced under Decius would be surpassed.