Brazil v Germany (2014 FIFA World Cup)

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Brazil versus Germany on the 8th of July 2014 ended with a scoreline so lopsided that a number became the match's name: 7-1. At the Mineirão stadium in Belo Horizonte, with millions of Brazilians watching and the host nation desperate for a sixth world title, Germany put five goals past Brazil before the half-hour mark. Four of those goals came in a six-minute span. The crowd, which had arrived expecting a tight contest between two football giants, found itself watching something that had no precedent in World Cup history. What caused this collapse? How did a match that analysts predicted would be close become a national trauma? And what does it mean that a single scoreline can enter a country's language as a metaphor for catastrophe?

• 2. A Stage Built for Glory

  ›

  Brazil were hosting the FIFA World Cup for only the second time, the first having been 1950. That earlier tournament carried its own wound: the Maracanaço, when Uruguay beat Brazil in the de facto final on home soil, a defeat still vivid in national memory. By 2014, Brazil ranked 3rd in FIFA World Rankings and Germany ranked 2nd, and both had arrived as tournament favourites. Germany were in a record-breaking fourth consecutive semi-final, while Brazil had not reached that stage since 2002, a tournament they had won. The two sides had met in only one previous World Cup knockout match, the 2002 final, which Brazil won 2-0. Miroslav Klose was Germany's striker that day, and Luiz Felipe Scolari managed Brazil. Both men were still in those same roles in 2014, the only two figures carried over from that earlier meeting. Scolari's Brazil had won the 2013 FIFA Confederations Cup and the squad carried the confidence of a team that believed the trophy was theirs to claim.

• 3. Two Absences That Changed Everything

  ›

  Neymar's fractured vertebra, suffered in the quarter-final against Colombia, removed Brazil's most important player from the semi-final entirely. Scolari chose Bernard to replace him, preserving what analysts described as the "attacking tradition of Brazilian football" rather than bringing in an extra midfielder, which was called the logical tactical response to facing Germany. Thiago Silva, the team's captain and defensive leader, was suspended due to accumulated yellow cards; an appeal by the Brazilian Football Confederation failed. Dante came in for Silva, while Luiz Gustavo replaced Paulinho in defensive midfield. Germany, by contrast, were unchanged from their quarter-final. Goalkeeper Júlio César and stand-in captain David Luiz held Neymar's shirt during the national anthem ceremony, a tribute to the absent striker. Even analysts who noted these losses still expected a close match, reasoning that the home crowd would compensate. The crowd's roar, it turned out, would soon become tears.

• 4. Twenty-Nine Minutes

  ›

  Mexican referee Marco Antonio Rodríguez, officiating what would be the final match of his career, started the game in the 11th minute with Germany's first corner. Thomas Müller slipped his marker, David Luiz, in the penalty box; Toni Kroos's delivery found him open for a side-footed finish. In the 23rd minute, Kroos and Müller combined to set up Miroslav Klose, whose rebound goal was his 16th career World Cup goal, passing the record he had previously shared with Brazil's Ronaldo. Ronaldo was in the stadium that day, watching as a commentator for TV Globo. Then Kroos scored twice more. In the 24th minute, Lahm's deflected cross set him up for a left-footed strike. In the 26th minute, just seconds after Brazil kicked off, Kroos won the ball from Fernandinho and played a one-two with Khedira before finishing again. Those two Kroos goals came 69 seconds apart, the fastest brace by a single player in World Cup history. Sami Khedira added a fifth in the 29th minute after exchanging passes with Mesut Özil. Brazil had no shots on target in the entire first half. Many supporters left the stadium before the second half began. Military Police sent a special forces squad into the Mineirão stands as fights broke out.

• 5. The Records That Fell

  ›

  Germany's six-minute burst from the 23rd to the 29th minute was the fastest four-goal sequence in World Cup history; Austria in 1954 and Hungary in 1982 had each needed seven minutes to score four. The final 7-1 margin was the largest winning margin in any World Cup semi-final or final. Germany became the first team to score seven goals in a World Cup semi-final and the first squad to reach eight World Cup finals. Their goal tally at full time reached 223, overtaking Brazil's 221 to make Germany the all-time highest-scoring nation in World Cup history. For Brazil, the defeat broke a 62-match unbeaten streak in competitive home matches, a run stretching back to a 1-3 loss to Peru in the 1975 Copa América, a match that had also been played at the Mineirão. Their worst previous home result had been a 5-1 defeat by Argentina in Rio de Janeiro in 1939. Their worst previous World Cup loss had been the 3-0 defeat to France in the 1998 final in Saint-Denis. The 7-1 doubled that margin. Only two nations had ever trailed by five or more goals at half-time at a World Cup: Zaire against Yugoslavia in 1974, and Haiti against Poland in 1974. Brazil now joined that company.

• 6. What the Players Said

  ›

  Mats Hummels spoke for the German squad in the post-match. "We just made it clear that we had to stay focused and not try to humiliate them," he said. "You have to show the opponent respect and it was very important that we did this." The Germans removed jumping and shouting from their goal celebrations accordingly. Coach Joachim Löw said his team had "a clear, persistent game-plan" and that as Brazil were "cracking up", his players responded with calm. Toni Kroos, named Man of the Match after two goals, one assist, 93% pass accuracy, and two chances created, said the squad had studied Brazil carefully: "We took all the balls, and scored the goals." Thomas Müller said he was "shocked by just how open Brazil were", describing Luiz Gustavo, David Luiz, Dante, Fernandinho, and Marcelo as "shambolic in their positioning." On the Brazilian side, Scolari called it the "worst loss by a Brazilian national team ever" and accepted all responsibility. He described it as "the worst day of my life" and resigned after the tournament. Striker Fred, substituted in the 70th minute, had made not a single tackle, cross, run, or interception during the match according to Opta Sports; he later announced his retirement from international football.

• 7. A Nation's Wound

  ›

  The ZDF broadcast in Germany set a record with 32.57 million viewers, 87.8% of the available audience, beating the Germany-Spain match from the 2010 World Cup. Five days later that record fell again when Germany won the final. In Brazil, TV Globo's viewers dropped with each German goal. The match became the most discussed sports event in Twitter history at the time, with over 35.6 million tweets surpassing Super Bowl XLVIII's 24.9 million. Brazilian newspapers greeted the result with headlines including "The Biggest Shame in History" from Lance!, "Historical humiliation" from Folha de S.Paulo, and "Brazil is slain" from O Globo. In Germany, Bild ran the front page "Ohne Worte" (Without Words). L'Équipe in France carried a single headline: "Le Désastre." Pelé wrote on Twitter, "Nobody in this world expected this result." Carlos Alberto Torres, who captained Brazil's 1970 winning team, said the country lost due to a "feeling of 'we've already won'." Tereza Borba Barbosa, daughter of goalkeeper Moacir Barbosa who had been scapegoated for the 1950 Maracanaço defeat, said the 2014 loss was enough to redeem her father's legacy. The match was named the Mineiraço, after the stadium where it was played, deliberately evoking that 1950 ghost.

• 8. What Came After

  ›

  Brazil lost 3-0 to the Netherlands in the third-place match on the 12th of July, conceding two of those goals in the first 17 minutes. The total of 14 goals conceded across the tournament was the most Brazil had ever conceded in a single World Cup, the most by any host nation, and the most by any team since Belgium allowed 15 goals in 1986. Scolari resigned on the 15th of July; two weeks later, Dunga returned as head coach. Germany beat Argentina 1-0 in extra time in the final on the 13th of July at the Maracanã, winning the World Cup for the fourth time and the first as a unified nation. The Brazilian crowd supported Germany in that final, given Brazil's long rivalry with neighbouring Argentina. Brazil's senior team did not return to the Mineirão until a 3-0 win over Argentina in a World Cup qualifier in November 2016. Two years after the Mineiraço, Brazil and Germany's under-23 teams met in the gold medal match of the 2016 Summer Olympics at the Maracanã. Neymar scored the winning penalty as Brazil won 5-4 on penalties to claim their first Olympic football gold. In Brazil, the scoreline "7-1" entered the language as a phrase for any crushing, disproportionate defeat, while "gol da Alemanha" (goal for Germany) became a common exclamation after a mishap.