Battle of Heilsberg

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Battle of Heilsberg was fought near a town on the Łyna River on the 10th of June 1807, and it cost the French army an estimated 12,000 men. Not a decisive victory. Not a celebrated triumph. A battle that, by most accounts, changed almost nothing. Yet understanding why it unfolded the way it did reveals something striking about the limits of Napoleon's war machine at its apparent height.

  How did a force of 190,000 French soldiers fail to dislodge roughly 115,000 Russo-Prussian troops dug into a riverside town? Why did Joachim Murat lead a charge before Napoleon even arrived on the field? And what happened just four days later that made Heilsberg seem like a footnote in history? These are the questions this documentary will answer.

• 2. Road to Heilsberg

  ›

  On the 24th of May 1807, Prussian General Friedrich Adolf, Count von Kalckreuth surrendered the city of Danzig to French Marshal François Joseph Lefebvre, ending a long siege. That capitulation freed Napoleon to concentrate his attention on Levin August von Bennigsen's Russian army in the region.

  Bennigsen moved first. On the 2nd of June, before Napoleon could act, Bennigsen ordered his columns to converge on Marshal Michel Ney's exposed VI Corps. Ney was outnumbered dramatically, facing 63,000 Russian troops with only 17,000 of his own men at the Battle of Guttstadt-Deppen on the 5th and the 6th of June. He lost his baggage train, two guns, and 2,042 men, but managed to escape southwest across the Pasłęka River with most of his force.

  Napoleon's response was swift. Within two days he had ordered his 190,000-man army to close in on the combined Russo-Prussian force of around 115,000. Bennigsen, aware of the French approach, pulled his troops back to the town of Lidzbark Warmiński, called Heilsberg by the Germans. The Russians set up strong defensive positions around the town, which stood on the banks of the Łyna River.

• 3. The Fortress on the Łyna

  ›

  The Teutonic Castle in Heilsberg was the focal point of the entire battle, and it was firmly in Russian hands. The castle's bridges and walls formed a natural perimeter, and the ground rising steeply from the base of the river to the castle's foundations made any French assault a punishing uphill fight.

  The Russians had not simply arrived and hoped for the best. Over the previous three to four months, Bennigsen's forces had compiled detailed tactics for defending castle grounds against a French invasion. The Prussian 21st Fusiliers, commanded by Ludwig August von Stutterheim, were garrisoned at the castle, adding another layer of defence to the position.

  The weather added its own complications for the attackers. During daylight, French soldiers carrying heavy supplies and equipment endured dangerously hot and humid conditions. At night, bitter cold and dampness gave the troops almost no chance to rest and recover. The terrain punished any attacker regardless of tactics; the weather punished them regardless of terrain.

• 4. Murat's Premature Charge

  ›

  Marshal Joachim Murat launched the French attack on the morning of the 10th of June, before Napoleon had arrived at the battlefield. This sequence mattered enormously. Murat attacked at what turned out to be the strongest point in the Russo-Prussian line, and he attacked without the reinforcements Napoleon had planned to bring.

  At first, Murat's cavalry forced a Russian commander named Borozdin to retreat. But Bennigsen responded by sending seven battalions of infantry, one regiment of cavalry, and two guns to shore up that flank. He also ordered Prince Bagration to cross to the left bank of the Alle River and hold the French until most of the army could shift from the right bank to the left. Bagration took up a position with his right flank on an area called Langwiese and his left on the river.

  When Soult's infantry arrived in the afternoon and attacked, Murat's cavalry moved toward the gap between Langwiese and Lawden. A mounted detachment of around 1,000 men under Major General Kozhin intervened at a critical moment, temporarily halting the French cavalry. Meanwhile, the Guard Battery, positioned on the right bank opposite the mouth of the Spuibach, stopped Soult's infantry in its tracks. Bagration's vanguard withdrew intact to the main Russian position, where it became a reserve. The initial French push had produced no breakthrough.

• 5. Napoleon Arrives Too Late

  ›

  At 6 pm Napoleon arrived on the battlefield, bringing part of Lannes' corps and the Fusilier guardsmen. Soult and Lannes led separate cavalry units forward on both sides of the River Łyna. Ney's infantry advanced with them. Divisional General Legrand was ordered to assault the central redoubt, and the French initially broke in.

  Lieutenant General Gorchakov, commanding a special corps of Bennigsen's army, then counter-attacked and seized the redoubt back. A regiment from Divisional General Saint-Hilaire, sent to help Legrand, was also repulsed. Napoleon shifted his focus to the Russian right flank, but even there, despite the arrival of the rest of Lannes' corps, every attack failed. The French were pushed back behind the Spuibach stream, holding only the grove of Lawden.

  When Prussian reinforcements arrived, sent by Anton Wilhelm von L'Estocq at Bennigsen's personal request, the French position grew even weaker. Artillery from both sides continued through the darkness. Then Lannes, leading Verdier's division, made a final attempt to take the central redoubt. He was forced back. That single repulse cost the French 3,000 casualties on its own. Napoleon had not intended for the day to end this way.

• 6. Command Under Fire

  ›

  Bennigsen was in serious trouble even as his forces were holding. A sudden fever had struck him during the battle, and he fell unconscious from his horse several times during the fighting. He remained mounted regardless, refusing to leave the field. By Grand Duke Constantine's orders, Lieutenant General Andrey Gorchakov eventually assumed general command for the remaining hours of the action, bringing the battle to a tactical draw.

  On the French side, the sequence of command had its own complications. Murat had initiated the assault without Napoleon's presence. When Napoleon did arrive, the opportunity for a coordinated assault had already been partly squandered. Marshal Mortier and Marshal Davout had advanced on the Königsberg side, but the uncoordinated nature of the day's fighting meant French numerical superiority never translated into a decisive blow.

  On the night of the 11th of June, Davout's corps finally arrived at the battlefield. But Napoleon abandoned the idea of renewing the attack the following morning, choosing to wait until all his forces were assembled. Bennigsen, expecting a renewed assault, had reinforced his lines. When it became clear the French were not coming, he moved Count Kamensky's detachment to join L'Estocq's corps, and on the night of the 12th of June, he withdrew his entire army to the right bank of the Alle and headed for Bartenstein.

• 7. Counting the Cost

  ›

  The casualty figures for Heilsberg remain disputed, as they do for most battles of this era. French losses were estimated at around 12,000 men overall. The French themselves claimed 1,398 killed, 10,059 wounded, and 864 captured, though the historian Digby Smith places the totals at 1,398 killed, 10,059 wounded, and 864 captured. The bulk of the French losses fell on Nicolas Jean-de-Dieu Soult's IV Corps, which suffered 8,286 casualties. Jean Lannes' corps lost 2,284 killed and wounded. General François Xavier Roussel, Chief of Staff of the Imperial Guard, was killed. Three French generals were wounded. Three French units lost their eagles.

  On the Russian side, Clodfelter estimates 6,000 killed and wounded. Digby Smith puts the figure at 2,000-3,000 dead and about 5,000-6,000 wounded, with two guns lost. Generals Koschin, Warneck, and Pahlen were killed. Generals Dmitry Dokhturov, Werdrevski, Fock, Zakhar Dmitrievich Olsufiev, Duka, Laptiev, Passeck, and Duke Charles of Mecklenburg were all wounded.

  The truce arranged on the 11th of June was an undocumented one, focused primarily on recovering the wounded. When Napoleon entered the Russian positions the following day, he found them deserted. All troops except the wounded had been evacuated overnight.

• 8. A Prelude to Friedland

  ›

  Analysts looking back at Heilsberg have settled on a consistent verdict: Murat and Soult attacked prematurely and at the strongest point in the Russo-Prussian line. The Russians had built extensive fortifications on the right bank of the Alle, but only minor redoubts on the left bank. The French advanced across the river anyway, giving up their positional advantages before the battle had properly begun.

  Napoleon also never realized he was facing Bennigsen's entire army. That misreading of the situation shaped his decisions throughout the day. What he believed was a defensive rearguard action was in fact a fully committed Russian defensive stand.

  The battle is recognized as strategically inconclusive: neither side gained significant ground, and the balance of strength between the two forces remained essentially unchanged. Yet the timing gives it a particular weight. Heilsberg was fought precisely four days before the Battle of Friedland, where Napoleon defeated Bennigsen decisively on the 14th of June 1807 and effectively ended the War of the Fourth Coalition. Colonel François-Joseph d'Offenstein, who fought on the French side at Heilsberg, was promoted to Brigadier General as a direct result of his performance there, one of the few individual careers the battle visibly altered.