Skip to content

Questions about Pre-sectarian Buddhism

Short answers, pulled from the story.

What was the historical context for the rise of pre-sectarian Buddhism?

Pre-sectarian Buddhism rose during the lifetime of Gautama Buddha on the fertile Indo-Gangetic plains. This era featured sixteen powerful kingdoms and republics known as Mahajanapadas that fostered intense urbanization in ancient India.

When did Samuel Beal publish comparative translations of early Buddhist texts?

Samuel Beal published comparative translations of the Pali Patimokkha and Chinese Dharmaguptaka Pratimoksa in 1859. He followed up with comparisons between Chinese sutras and Pali suttas in 1882 to show virtual identity between them.

Who argued that dhyana was a Buddhist invention versus Brahmanical practice?

Johannes Bronkhorst argued that dhyana was a Buddhist invention while Alexander Wynne claimed it incorporated Brahmanical practices from Nikayas. Louis de La Vallée-Poussin famously voiced the core problem regarding the relation between dhyana and insight in his text Musila et Narada Le Chemin de Nirvana published 1936.

What is the scholarly consensus on when pre-sectarian Buddhism ended?

Pre-sectarian Buddhism existed before various Early Buddhist schools developed around 250 BCE. Scholars debate whether the first documented split occurred during the reign of Ashoka from 268 to 232 BCE or after his death.

How did modern scholars define the goal of early Buddhism compared to later traditions?

Modern scholars like Rupert Gethin Richard Gombrich and Paul Williams hold that the goal of early Buddhism meant nirvana as blowing out the flame of greed aversion and delusion. This view signifies permanent cessation of samsara rebirth rather than a journey to a separate reality.