X-Men

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The X-Men first appeared on newsstands in September 1963, and for the next seven years, almost nobody cared. Sales lagged behind every other Marvel franchise. The title was eventually cancelled in 1970, its stories quietly reprinted to fill the gaps. Then, in 1975, something changed. A new team assembled in a single issue called Giant-Size X-Men #1, and what followed became one of the most remarkable reversals in American comics history. By the early 1980s, publishers and retailers were measuring every other comic book by how many orders it received compared to that month's issue of X-Men.

  What made it work was not spectacle alone. The X-Men told stories about people who were feared and hated simply for being born different. Their powers emerged at puberty, in that period when anyone can feel like an outsider. The allegories ran deep: to racism, antisemitism, the AIDS epidemic, the closet, apartheid, and McCarthyism. A story about mutants hunting robots turned out to be a story about civil rights. A tale of a holocaust survivor and his old friend, now enemies, turned out to be a meditation on what justice actually requires. The question this documentary sets out to answer is how a struggling comic book about teenagers with superpowers became a mirror for some of the hardest questions in American life.

• 2. The Creation

  ›

  Stan Lee came up with the central concept partly out of exhaustion. He had already invented Spider-Man, giving him radioactive spider powers, and the Fantastic Four, altered by cosmic rays. Creating separate scientific origins for each new hero was wearing thin. His solution was to declare his new characters "mutants", born with their gifts rather than acquiring them by accident. Publisher Martin Goodman rejected the initial title, "The Mutants," convinced readers would not know what the word meant. The name "X-Men" followed from there, explained within the first issue's pages as standing for "extra power."

  Jack Kirby, who co-created the team and served as the visual architect of their world, described the founding logic simply in a 1987 interview: "What would you do with mutants who were just plain boys and girls and certainly not dangerous? You school them." Kirby's instinct was inclusion rather than alienation. Professor Charles Xavier became a teacher running a school in his Westchester, New York mansion. The original five students, Cyclops, Beast, Iceman, Angel, and Marvel Girl, were introduced in issue #1 as young people learning to use gifts that set them apart from the world around them. That central tension, between belonging and difference, was built into the premise from the first page.

• 3. The Near-Death and Revival

  ›

  By issue #20, published in May 1966, Lee and Kirby had moved on, replaced by writer Roy Thomas and artist Werner Roth. The stories tried new directions: Thomas and Neal Adams briefly gave the comic new life in 1969, introducing Alex Summers (Cyclops's brother, later Havok) and Lorna Dane (later Polaris), and debuting a Japanese mutant named Sunfire in issue #64. None of it was enough. Marvel stopped producing original stories with issue #66, published in March 1970, and spent years reprinting old material.

  The rescue came in 1975. Writer Len Wein and artist Dave Cockrum built an entirely new team in Giant-Size X-Men #1. This group, described as "an international cadre of mutants with diverse and often traumatic personal histories," replaced nearly all the original members. They were not teenagers. They came from the Soviet Union, Germany, Kenya, Ireland, Japan, Canada, and a Native American Apache background. Marvel's corporate owners had specifically pushed for foreign appeal, and Cockrum and Wein delivered. Chris Claremont then took over the ongoing series from issue #94 and would not leave for sixteen years. The long-dormant franchise became, under his pen, a sprawling ensemble drama with a genuine point of view.

• 4. Claremont's World

  ›

  Wolverine's real name was revealed as "Logan" in issue #103, published in February 1977. His healing factor first appeared in issue #116, and the suggestion of a reinforced skeleton followed in issue #124. These details accumulated across years because Claremont believed in slow revelation. He initially considered writing Wolverine out of the series entirely; artist John Byrne, who shared the character's Canadian nationality, argued to keep him. Wolverine became the breakout character of the entire franchise.

  Claremont introduced what scholars have called "Claremont Women": characters like Storm and Phoenix whose development he treated with unusual seriousness for superhero comics of the era. Scholar Ramzi Fawaz has described the 1977 "Phoenix Saga" as "arguably the most canonical story line in The X-Men's publishing history," notable for the alliance it forged between Storm and Phoenix, a pairing Fawaz reads as allegorical for the intersection of liberal feminism and emerging Black feminism. The story introduced the Shi'ar Empire and a broader cosmic scale.

  The 1980 "Dark Phoenix Saga" brought that arc to its conclusion, with Jean Grey destroyed by a corrupting hunger for power after being manipulated by the villain Mastermind. The same period introduced Kitty Pryde, thirteen years old and Marvel's first canonically Jewish superhero. Claremont and Byrne then immediately followed with "Days of Future Past," a story set in a dystopian future for mutants that would be adapted into film decades later. Comics scholar Douglas Wolk has described autumn 1985 as the "peak of X-Men's world-beating phase," when a single month produced the double-sized Uncanny X-Men #200, two miniseries, an annual, a special edition, and a fundraiser for relief of the 1983-1985 famine in Ethiopia.

• 5. Allegory as Architecture

  ›

  Professor Xavier has come to be compared to Martin Luther King Jr., while Magneto has been compared to Malcolm X. Magneto, a Holocaust survivor, quotes Malcolm X in the first film with the line "By any means necessary." The parallel was designed into the characters from early on: two old friends who share a diagnosis and disagree about what it demands of them.

  The fictional island nation of Genosha, introduced in Uncanny X-Men #235 in October 1988, depicted a state where mutants were segregated and enslaved under an apartheid system. The connection to South Africa, which was living under apartheid at that time, was explicit. The 1982 graphic novel God Loves, Man Kills introduced Reverend William Stryker and his Purifiers, an antimutant religious group who believe mutants are children of the devil; the book was later cited as partial inspiration for the 2003 film X2: X-Men United. The 2002 Chamber miniseries referenced Norman Rockwell's painting The Problem We All Live With directly, using the mutant context to address affirmative action and majority-supremacist terrorism.

  Editor Ann Nocenti identified something fundamental about the metaphor's reach: "Their powers arrive at puberty, making them analogous to the changes you go through at adolescence, whether they're special, or out of control, or setting you apart, the misfit identity theme." A longtime subplot about the Legacy Virus, a disease initially affecting only mutants, drew comparisons to the AIDS epidemic. The film X-Men: First Class made the subtext explicit when Hank McCoy responds to a question about concealing his mutant identity by saying, "You didn't ask, I didn't tell." Northstar's marriage was depicted in the comics in 2012; Iceman was revealed to be gay in 2015.

• 6. The Record-Breaking 1990s

  ›

  In October 1991, Marvel launched a new X-Men series, simply titled X-Men, written by Claremont and illustrated by Jim Lee. Retailers pre-ordered over 8.1 million copies of issue #1, generating nearly $7 million in orders. The Guinness Book of World Records certified it as the best-selling comic book of all time. Guinness presented honors to Claremont at the 2010 San Diego Comic-Con.

  The success came at a cost to the people who built it. X-Men editor Bob Harras sided with Jim Lee over Claremont in a dispute about plotting direction. Claremont left after writing only three of the new series' issues, ending a sixteen-year run that had made the franchise. Lee himself departed months later, joining Rob Liefeld, Whilce Portacio, and Marc Silvestri to found Image Comics. Lee's visual designs would form the basis for X-Men: The Animated Series, which reached a new generation of readers and viewers.

  The 1990s cycled through crossover after crossover: "X-Tinction Agenda," "Age of Apocalypse" in 1995, "Onslaught" in 1996, "Operation: Zero Tolerance" in 1997. Fans and creative staff alike criticized the crossovers as artificially regular and disruptive. They continued anyway, because they were financially successful. Cyclops and Jean Grey married in X-Men #30 in March 1994. Magneto ripped out Wolverine's adamantium skeleton during the "Fatal Attractions" crossover in late 1993. In November 1994, Jubilee and a group of teenage mutants formed a new team called Generation X, mentored by Banshee and Emma Frost at the Massachusetts Academy.

• 7. Reinvention and Krakoa

  ›

  In July 2001, Grant Morrison took over the newly renamed New X-Men and immediately destroyed Genosha, killing sixteen million mutants in the opening arc "E Is For Extinction." Morrison replaced the spandex costumes with black leather street clothes, brought Emma Frost into the main team, and had Xavier publicly reveal he was a mutant. Joss Whedon, creator of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, then launched Astonishing X-Men in July 2004, returning the characters to their traditional superhero costumes. The franchise had become something that could be remade wholesale by each new creative team and somehow remain recognizable.

  In 2006, the "House of M" storyline culminated in Scarlet Witch manipulating reality to depower ninety-eight percent of the mutant population. The school that had been Xavier's answer to bigotry became a safe haven for the shrinking number of powered survivors. Nightcrawler died in X-Force #26 in June 2010. Wolverine was killed in 2014's "Death of Wolverine" arc after losing his healing factor to an intelligent virus. Both would eventually return.

  On the 14th of May 2019, Marvel cancelled all X-Men titles and handed Jonathan Hickman full creative control to relaunch the line from scratch. The result was the Krakoan Age: a story about mutants founding their own island nation called Krakoa, achieving political sovereignty, and eventually facing an assault by a human supremacist organization called Orchis. The era introduced Synch, Ms. Marvel (Kamala Khan), and Rasputin IV to the roster, and produced major story arcs through 2023. A new era announced at SXSW 2024 called "From the Ashes" scattered the X-Men across the planet following the Krakoan collapse, with Scott Summers leading a team from Alaska and Rogue leading a group of outlaw heroes from a base in New Orleans.