White Terror (Russia)
Individual acts of violence against Bolshevik rule began by the end of 1917, but large-scale White Terror violence arguably started in early 1918. This period of mass killings continued until the defeat of the Whites at the hands of the Red Army from 1920 to 1922. Unlike the Red Terror which officially began on the 5th of September 1918 following planned assassinations of leaders, there was no formal decree that kicked off the White Terror. The violence evolved from spontaneous disorganization into a system of political repression sanctioned by military dictatorships. It targeted not only Bolsheviks but also members of other parties and ordinary people caught in the crossfire. The most acute phase occurred in the Far East under warlords like Grigory Semyonov and Baron Roman von Ungern-Sternberg.
Russian historians hold conflicting views on whether the White Terror was premeditated state policy or spontaneous chaos. Some argue it was a series of actions directed by leaders while others see it as unorganized and disordered. Western historians like Richard Pipes and Nicolas Werth contrasted the two terrors, claiming the White version was restorative and arbitrary rather than ideological. They viewed it as mere repressive violence intended to restore a previous status quo instead of reconstructing society. Peter Holquist and Joshua Sanborn refute this view, arguing that White violence had its own ideological underpinnings similar to German Freikorps ethos. They suggest that massacres of tens of thousands of Jews could not have happened without some form of ideology linking Jews to Communists. Ronald Hingley believes Red Terror casualty figures were exaggerated due to White Army propaganda, suggesting lower estimates closer to 50,000 deaths.
Dietrich Beyrau estimates victims of the White Terror between 20,000 and 100,000 people excluding pogrom victims compared to up to 1.3 million for the Red Terror. Jonathan Smele cites Russian historian V. Erlikhman's figure of 300,000 victims against 1,200,000 for the Reds. Nikita Ratkovsky believes victim numbers may exceed 500,000 excluding pogroms. The Cheka presented evidence during Kolchak's ministers trial in 1920 showing at least 25,000 executions occurred in Yekaterinburg Governorate alone between 1918 and 1919. Ronald Suny states casualties likely fall between 50,000 and 140,000 if restricted to White movement atrocities but would exceed that when including anti-Soviet popular violence and Jewish pogroms. The 1985 Whitaker Report of the United Nations cited 100,000 to 250,000 Jews killed in more than 2,000 pogroms by Whites, Cossacks, and Ukrainian nationalists.
Tens of thousands of Jews were left homeless and became victims of serious illness following numerous pogroms committed during the Civil War. Modern estimates place Jewish deaths between 1918 and 1921 with a total of 1,236 pogroms occurring against Jews in 524 towns across Ukraine. Of these recorded events, 493 were carried out by Symon Petliura's soldiers while 307 came from independent warlords. Denikin's army conducted 213 pogroms and the Red Army executed 106 of them. In Fastov alone, Denikin's Volunteer Army murdered over 1,500 Jews who were mostly elderly women and children. A proclamation by one of Denikin's generals urged people to arm themselves to extirpate the evil force living in Jewish hearts. The Don Province saw approximately 25,000 to 40,000 people executed by Pyotr Krasnov's White Cossacks before the region fell to the Red Army after their victory at Tsaritsyn.
Admiral Alexander Kolchak pursued persecution policies after seizing power in Siberia in November 1918. His government issued a decree on the 3rd of December 1918 revising criminal code articles to preserve the Supreme Ruler system. Article 103 made insults punishable by imprisonment while bureaucratic sabotage under Article 329 carried hard labor sentences of 15 to 20 years. Regulation 428 adopted the 11th of April 1919 provided five-year prison terms for individuals considered threats due to Bolshevik ties. General Sergey Rozanov ordered villages meeting troops with arms to be burned down with adult males shot without exception. Omsk froze in horror as entire carts of bodies arrived like winter lamb carcasses with at least 2,500 people killed. Czech-Slovak forces delivered a memorandum to Allied representatives in Vladivostok on the 15th of November 1919 condemning daily burning of villages and murder of peaceful inhabitants. Major General William S. Graves testified that anti-Bolsheviks killed one hundred people in Eastern Siberia for every one killed by Bolsheviks.
Soviet authors wrote extensively about heroism in combating White Terror through novels including Furmanov's Chapaev and Serafimovich's The Iron Flood. Early short stories and novels by Sholokhov, Leonov, and Fedin devoted themselves to documenting these themes. Nikolai Ostrovsky's autobiographical novel How the Steel was Tempered recorded episodes of White Terror in western Ukraine. Trotsky argued in Terrorism and Communism: A Reply to Karl Kautsky that terror began with White Guard forces before Bolshevik response. During the Soviet period significant monuments dedicated to victims appeared mainly in Russia within visible town and city locations. Since 1920 the central square in Tsaritsyn has been called Square of Fallen Fighters where remains of 55 victims are buried under a monument established in 1957. Memorials stand in Vyborg near Leningrad Highway commemorating 600 people shot by machine gun while Voronezh hosts an In Memory of Victims monument unveiled in 1920 on execution sites from 1919.
Continue Browsing
Common questions
When did the White Terror in Russia begin and end?
Large-scale White Terror violence started in early 1918 and continued until the defeat of the Whites from 1920 to 1922. Individual acts of violence against Bolshevik rule began by the end of 1917 before evolving into mass killings.
Who were the main perpetrators of the White Terror during the Russian Civil War?
Warlords like Grigory Semyonov and Baron Roman von Ungern-Sternberg led the most acute phase of violence in the Far East. Admiral Alexander Kolchak pursued persecution policies after seizing power in Siberia in November 1918 while Denikin's army conducted numerous pogroms.
How many people died during the White Terror according to historical estimates?
Dietrich Beyrau estimates victims between 20,000 and 100,000 excluding pogrom victims compared to up to 1.3 million for the Red Terror. Nikita Ratkovsky believes victim numbers may exceed 500,000 excluding pogroms while Ronald Suny states casualties likely fall between 50,000 and 140,000 if restricted to White movement atrocities.
What specific laws did Admiral Kolchak issue regarding political repression?
His government issued a decree on the 3rd of December 1918 revising criminal code articles to preserve the Supreme Ruler system. Regulation 428 adopted the 11th of April 1919 provided five-year prison terms for individuals considered threats due to Bolshevik ties.
Why do historians disagree about whether the White Terror was premeditated policy or spontaneous chaos?
Russian historians hold conflicting views on whether the White Terror was premeditated state policy or spontaneous chaos. Western historians like Richard Pipes and Nicolas Werth contrasted the two terrors claiming the White version was restorative and arbitrary rather than ideological while Peter Holquist and Joshua Sanborn argue it had its own ideological underpinnings similar to German Freikorps ethos.