Tolkien's maps

• 1. The Hobbit Maps

  ›

  A 1937 edition of The Hobbit opens with a hand-drawn map of Wilderland. This drawing stretches from Rivendell in the west to the Lonely Mountain and Smaug the dragon in the east. The Misty Mountains appear in three dimensions, while Mirkwood shows closely packed tree symbols mixed with spiders and their webs. A heavy vertical line runs near the left-hand side, marked "Edge of the Wild". This line represented the printed margin of school paper that came with instructions not to write there. The first map inside the book is Thror's map, handed down to Thorin. It shows little but the Lonely Mountain drawn in outline with ridgelines and entrances. Two rivers flow through the landscape, decorated with a spider and its web. English labels and arrows point to key locations, alongside two texts written in runes. The second map displays over fifty placenames in red ink. Publishers Allen & Unwin asked Tolkien to redraw these maps for better line-block printing. They requested sharper lettering and fewer colors to suit commercial production standards.

  12

• 2. Lord Of The Rings Cartography

  ›

  Tolkien worked for many years on The Lord of the Rings using squared paper where each square measured 2cm by 2cm. Each square represented 100 miles across the north-west part of Middle-earth. His hand-drawn map accumulated annotations in pencil and various inks added over decades. Older markings faded until they became almost illegible. The paper grew soft, torn, and yellowed from intensive use. A fold down the center required mending with parcel tape. He created a detailed design on graph paper that he enlarged five times in length from his main map. His son Christopher drew the final contour map from this design. The finished map faithfully reproduced contours, features, and labels but omitted the route taken by Frodo and Sam. Father and son worked desperately to finish the map before publication. The book contains three maps and over six hundred placenames. One map shows mountains as if seen in three dimensions with multiple waterlines along coasts. Another provides a detailed drawing of "A Part of the Shire" including political boundaries between administrative districts called Farthings. Many places mapped never appear in the text itself.

  345

• 3. Silmarillion And Arda Sketches

  ›

  The first edition of The Silmarillion contains two maps featuring a large fold-out drawing of Beleriand. The Ered Luin mountain range on its right-hand edge matches the same name on the left-hand edge of the main map in The Lord of the Rings. A smaller-scale drawing covers the central region showing coasts, mountains, and rivers without forests. Red ink overlays names of Elven leaders across each part of Beleriand. Tolkien drew sketches of Valinor (Aman) and Numenor for later publications like Unfinished Tales. These maps show little detail beyond coastlines marked with waterlining and mountain ranges. Christopher Tolkien noted that the frequently mentioned Dwarf-road bordering Beleriand does not appear because Noldorin Elves never crossed those mountains. Other continents described in The Silmarillion remain unmapped within the book itself. Absences in mapping may carry significant meaning regarding the history of the legendarium. The star-shaped island of Numenor appears only as an outline with minimal topographical features.

  67

• 4. Aesthetic And Narrative Functions

  ›

  Tolkien wrote in 1954 to novelist Naomi Mitchison about his approach to world-building through cartography. He developed names and languages before arriving at a plot structure. Old Norse appeared for Dwarves of Dale while modern English served Hobbits of the Shire. Old English defined riders of Rohan creating a linguistic map of Middle-earth. Alice Campbell notes their style mixes illustrative principles with purpose alongside cartographical practice. They possess what Tolkien called an "archaic air" yet lack authentic medieval styling. Blank spaces between features reflect an eighteenth-century innovation making drawn features reliable. His mapping echoes William Morris's Arts and Crafts movement where grace meets function. Maps serve three functions: constructing consistent plots, guiding readers, and providing aesthetic experience. These picturesque maps lead readers into an imagined secondary world beyond mere text indices. Karen Wynn Fonstad found herself unable to proceed with her atlas until mastering all details. Distances traveled, chronology of quests, geology, and terrain required understanding to create accurate work. Names and maps give Middle-earth that air of solidity and extent both in space and time.

  91011

• 5. Geomorphological Inconsistencies

  ›

  Geologists Robert C. Reynolds examined Tolkien's illustrations in 1974 followed by William Sarjeant in 1992. Alex Acks wrote on Tor.com in 2017 outlining mismatches between Tolkien's maps and plate tectonics processes. Mountains form mainly next to subduction zones or where continents collide and crumple together. Stretching continental crust creates broken horst and graben landforms through magma upwelling. None of these geological processes create right-angle junctions seen around Mordor or Misty Mountain ends. Isolated volcanoes far inland like Mount Doom are possible but unlikely since most occur as islands. Rivers drain raised areas forming drainage basins that branch regularly into smaller streams leading uphill. The Anduin runs more or less as a single large stream for hundreds of miles parallel to the Misty Mountains. One tributary called Entwash branches out into a river delta yet the main river continues flowing downhill past it. Hazel Gibson writes that several mountain ranges make absolutely no sense under real-world geology. Mordor stands as the most egregious instance with its square plain fenced by mountains at right angles. The Harvard Lampoon's 1969 book Bored of the Rings parodies this geomorphology with "The Square Valley Between the Mounts".

• 6. Fantasy Map Antecedents

  ›

  William Morris published The Sundering Flood in 1897 featuring a frontispiece map showing a city on a great river. This map defined a wholly invented world containing "The Wood Masterless" and a "Desert Waste". Towns bore English names like Westcheaping and Eastcheaping appearing as the first fantasy map in modern sense. Tolkien stated he wished to imitate style and content from Morris's romances while making use of elements from them. Jonathan Swift included maps in his 1726 Gulliver's Travels offering another published example Tolkien may have considered. Robert Louis Stevenson provided adventure story maps in his 1883 Treasure Island for further inspiration. Tolkien's maps set a completely new standard so their use became expected in the genre he largely created. Peter Jackson chose to use Tolkien's Middle-earth map in his Lord of the Rings film trilogy. George R. R. Martin used maps in all his A Song of Ice and Fire books starting with A Game of Thrones. These influences shaped how fantasy novels presented imaginary worlds through visual documentation and spatial logic.

  8

• 7. Pauline Baynes Iconic Poster

  ›

  Allen & Unwin commissioned illustrator Pauline Baynes to paint a map of Middle-earth in 1969. Tolkien supplied her copies of draft maps for The Lord of the Rings plus annotations on Christopher's 1954 map. Allen & Unwin published Baynes's map as a poster in 1970 decorated with header and footer paintings showing characters. Vignettes depicted locations from stories within the map design itself. This poster map became iconic of Middle-earth among generations of readers. She was one of few illustrators whom Tolkien approved for such work. The poster added far beyond Tolkien's original cartography through these decorative additions. Later redrafting by HarperCollins made cartography bland, modern, professional illustration according to Alice Campbell. This unintentional reversion lost what she calls "the illusion of Bilbo's own fair copies" suggesting culture without printing presses. Tolkien desired accuracy more than decoration yet later editions prioritized technical precision over hand-drawn charm.

  6

• 8. Modern Redraftings And Fan Efforts

  ›

  Karen Wynn Fonstad published The Atlas of Middle-earth as part of significant fan cartographic efforts. These works appeared in print form alongside other fan-created atlases exploring the Tolkien universe. HarperCollins redrafted maps for later editions making them look bland and modern compared to originals. Campbell argues this choice loses the charming hand lettering found in Tolkien's own drafts. The new style suggests a culture without printing presses or engraving which contradicts Tolkien's intent. Fans have published their works in print including detailed reconstructions of routes and geography. Fonstad drew her map of Dwarves' route from Anduin to Forest River completely flat with only small local topographic features. Real mountain chains can meet almost at right angle but finding them requires working really hard. Several mountain ranges make absolutely no sense under geological scrutiny yet remain central to fantasy tradition. The loss of hand-drawn feeling marks a shift away from original aesthetic values toward standardized production methods.

  12