The Other Boleyn Girl (2003 film)

• 1. Adaptation Origins

  ›

  Philippa Gregory published her novel The Other Boleyn Girl in 2001. Two years later, the BBC commissioned a television adaptation of that book. Philippa Lowthorpe directed and wrote the script for this project. She chose to focus on Mary Boleyn rather than Anne, who is usually the central figure in stories about the family. This decision shifted the perspective away from the more famous sister. The film was released as part of the BBC's historical drama lineup. It arrived before the major theatrical version starring Natalie Portman hit cinemas in 2008.

• 2. Narrative Structure

  ›

  Mary Boleyn narrates her life story while competing with sister Anne for King Henry VIII's affections. The camera often turns directly toward Mary as she speaks to the audience. She describes how her husband William Carey consented to her becoming the King's mistress despite his own despair. Anne falls in love with Henry Percy and consummates the relationship against Mary's warnings. The family tells Anne she has made a grave mistake because Percy is already betrothed with royal consent. Anne declares she will never fall in love again after being exiled to Hever Castle. She plots revenge and her return to court while Mary begins to enjoy time with the King. Mary becomes pregnant by the King but soon finds him caring only for Anne. Anne returns to court announcing gratitude while Mary remains sceptical of her sincerity. The family plans for Anne to distract the King as Mary enters confinement. The King finds Anne more attractive than Mary and learns from her sister's example. Anne cautiously turns down seduction attempts hoping to strengthen his desire. Mary gives birth to a son but leaves court when the King cares only for Anne. She reconciles with husband William and they have a daughter before he dies from sweating sickness two years later. Anne needs Mary by her side to protect her from scandal. The true extent of Anne's ambition emerges as the King seeks an heir. Anne pressures Mary to testify that no betrothal existed between her and Percy. The King makes Anne swear she has never loved any other man. Anne finally sleeps with him to demonstrate devotion and triumphs as he marries her. Anne banishes Mary from court after Mary accepts William Stafford's marriage proposal. The King grows disappointed when Anne gives birth to Elizabeth, a daughter. Her hold on him weakens as she makes jealous scenes. Anne reveals her pregnancy to a delighted King but miscarries again. George and other men are taken to the Tower on charges of treason and adultery. Anne reminds the King that he once loved her. Proclaiming innocence, she asks God to have mercy on his soul. She sings a song to Elizabeth as she is led away. Mary narrates that George, Anne and others were beheaded.

  1

• 3. Visual Techniques

  ›

  Director Philippa Lowthorpe employed handheld cameras and confessional video diary styles to create a unique historical drama aesthetic. Some scenes are shot in a straight-to-camera style where characters speak directly to the audience. This approach mimics modern reality television formats within a sixteenth-century setting. Critics described the result as having the feel of Peter Greenaway-lite. One reviewer likened the visual style to NYPD Blue visiting Hampton Court. The use of hand-held cameras created an intimate yet unstable atmosphere for the court scenes. These techniques were unusual for an historical drama produced by the BBC at that time.

  2

• 4. Production Challenges

  ›

  A low budget of £750,000 required four weeks of improvisational workshops before principal photography began at Berkeley Castle. The cast spent those four weeks working with the director to improvise the script. They developed their characters through these sessions rather than relying solely on written dialogue. Filming took place at Berkeley Castle in Gloucestershire. The production team had to work within tight financial constraints while maintaining period accuracy. The improvisation process helped actors like Natascha McElhone and Jodhi May find natural chemistry. Jared Harris played Henry VIII under these same conditions. Steven Mackintosh portrayed George Boleyn during the workshop phase. Philip Glenister appeared as William Stafford after the rehearsal period concluded. Jack Shepherd played Thomas Boleyn and John Woodvine played Uncle Norfolk throughout the shoot. Ron Cook portrayed Thomas Cromwell, 1st Earl of Essex. Anthony Howell played William Carey and Jane Gurnett played Elizabeth Boleyn. Yolanda Vazquez appeared as Catherine of Aragon. Geoffrey Streatfeild played Francis Weston. The film was released on DVD on the 6th of October 2008 following the theatrical version's release.

• 5. Critical Reception

  ›

  Critics divided on the camera work described it as either innovative or an interference with the gripping narrative. Stuart Jeffries wrote for The Guardian that some previewers thought it had the feel of Peter Greenaway-lite. He found the style interfered with what he called a gripping well-written narrative. Other reviewers felt the visual approach added necessary intimacy to the historical drama. The debate centered on whether the modern filming techniques distracted from the story. Some praised the bold choice while others felt it undermined traditional expectations. The film received attention for its unique approach compared to other BBC productions of the era.