Free to follow every thread. No paywall, no dead ends.
The Motley Fool: the story on HearLore | HearLore
Common questions
Who founded The Motley Fool and when was it launched?
David and Tom Gardner, along with partners Todd Etter and Erik Rydholm, launched The Motley Fool in July 1993 in Alexandria, Virginia. The company eventually grew to employ over 300 people worldwide.
What was the April Fool's joke The Motley Fool played in 1994?
In 1994, The Motley Fool published a series of online statements promoting a nonexistent sewage-disposal company as an April Fool's joke. This prank garnered widespread attention and demonstrated the power of the company's early online presence.
Why did The Motley Fool remove 80% of its staff in 2001?
The Motley Fool removed 80% of its staff in three rounds of layoffs following the failure of the Foolish Four method during the dot-com bubble and market collapse of 2001. This event served as a stark reminder of the risks of overconfidence in financial strategies.
When did The Motley Fool launch its Stock Advisor subscription program?
The Motley Fool shifted to a subscription-based business model and launched its Stock Advisor program in February 2002. This program offered subscribers monthly stock picks and premium investment education.
What sub-brands did The Motley Fool launch in 2019?
In September 2019, The Motley Fool launched two sub-brands called Millionacres and Investor Island. Millionacres provides subscription-based real estate investing advice, while Investor Island is a mobile game launched on the 17th of September 2019.
How did The Motley Fool influence the passage of Regulation Fair Disclosure?
The Motley Fool
In July 1993, two brothers named David and Tom Gardner, along with partners Todd Etter and Erik Rydholm, launched a financial advice company in Alexandria, Virginia, that would eventually employ over 300 people worldwide. They chose a name that seemed absurd for a business dealing with serious money, borrowing the term Motley Fool from William Shakespeare's comedy As You Like It. The name referenced the court jester, a character who alone among the court could speak the truth to the Duke without fear of losing his head. This bold choice signaled a willingness to challenge conventional wisdom and speak plainly about investing, setting the stage for a company that would grow from a small newsletter into a global financial media empire. The founders believed that the financial industry was full of jargon and deception, and they wanted to create a space where ordinary people could learn to invest without being intimidated by experts.
The Sewage Scam
In 1994, The Motley Fool published a series of online statements promoting a nonexistent sewage-disposal company as part of an April Fool's joke designed to teach a lesson about penny stock investing. The prank garnered widespread attention, including an article in The Wall Street Journal, and demonstrated the power of the company's early online presence. By August of that year, the Gardners had parlayed their one-year-old investment newsletter into a content partnership with America Online, one of the most popular internet service providers of the time. In December, they were profiled in the Talk of the Town section of the New Yorker, marking their entry into mainstream cultural consciousness. The joke was not just a gimmick; it was a strategic move to highlight the dangers of speculative investing and to build a reputation for transparency and humor in a field often dominated by seriousness and secrecy.
The Fanatical Following
In 1996, David and Tom Gardner published The Motley Fool Investment Guide, which ranked on bestseller lists for The New York Times and Bloomberg Businessweek. The book was controversial, with Bloomberg writing about the company's Fanatical following, while a PBS Frontline episode described the company as made up of 20-somethings giving so-called advice. In 1997, the Motley Fool's online presence moved from AOL to its own domain, Fool.com, where it continued to provide investment advice under an advertising-based revenue model. The company's approach was to demystify investing for the average person, using clear language and a friendly tone. This strategy resonated with a generation of investors who felt alienated by the traditional financial establishment, and it helped The Motley Fool build a loyal readership that would grow over the next decade.
In December 1999, Motley Fool author Bill Barker encouraged readers to post comments on the SEC website regarding Regulation Fair Disclosure. Former SEC chairman Arthur Levitt stated in the 2nd of July 2001 edition of The Wall Street Journal that two-thirds of the letters came from Fools and the regulation would not have happened without them.
In the late 1990s, The Motley Fool publicized their Foolish Four method of systematic trading, adapted from the Dogs of the Dow method for selecting stocks from the Dow Jones Industrial Average based on high dividend yield. They published a book on the topic in 1999, titled The Foolish Four: How to Crush Your Mutual Funds in 15 Minutes a Year. Journalist Jason Zweig criticized the Foolish Four method in 1999, describing selecting high-dividend yield stocks as a sensible strategy at least on a preliminary level, but questioning the Motley Fool staff's outlandish claims such as the ability to crush mutual funds in only 15 minutes a year. In 2000, Motley Fool writer Ann Coleman admitted that the Foolish Four method turned out to be not nearly as wonderful a strategy as they thought. The method's failure during the dot-com bubble and market collapse of 2001 led to the company removing 80% of its staff in three rounds of layoffs, a stark reminder of the risks of overconfidence in financial strategies.
The Subscription Shift
In February 2002, The Motley Fool shifted to a subscription-based business model, launching its Stock Advisor program, which offered subscribers monthly stock picks and premium investment education. The company also established free and subscription-based businesses in several countries, including the United Kingdom, Australia, and Canada. In October 2019, the company announced that it was shutting down operations in Singapore, and a year later, in October 2020, it announced that it was also shutting down operations in Hong Kong. The shift to a subscription model allowed The Motley Fool to provide more in-depth analysis and personalized advice to its readers, while also generating a more stable revenue stream. The company's expansion into international markets demonstrated its growing influence, but the decision to close operations in certain regions highlighted the challenges of maintaining a global presence in a rapidly changing financial landscape.
The Ascent and Beyond
In August 2018, the company launched a personal-finance sub-brand called The Ascent to provide personal finance product reviews and free educational resources. In September 2019, The Motley Fool launched two more sub-brands: Millionacres, which provides subscription-based real estate investing advice and real estate resources, and Investor Island, a mobile game launched on the 17th of September 2019. These new ventures reflected the company's commitment to expanding its reach beyond traditional stock picking and into other areas of personal finance. The Ascent focused on helping consumers make better financial decisions, while Millionacres targeted the growing interest in real estate investing. Investor Island, a mobile game, was an innovative attempt to engage younger audiences and teach them about investing in a fun and interactive way. The company's diversification strategy demonstrated its ability to adapt to changing market conditions and consumer preferences.
The Voice of the People
Representatives of The Motley Fool have testified before Congress against mutual fund fees, in support of fair financial disclosure, on the Enron scandal, and the IPO process. In 1999, the Securities and Exchange Commission proposed Regulation Fair Disclosure, which would require companies to simultaneously give vital information to Wall Street analysts and the public. In December 1999, Motley Fool author Bill Barker wrote an article telling readers to post comments on the SEC's website. The regulation passed, and in the 2nd of July 2001, edition of The Wall Street Journal, former SEC chairman Arthur Levitt is quoted saying, Two-thirds of our letters came from Fools. Without them, Reg FD would not have happened. This legislative effort highlighted the company's role as a voice for the average investor, advocating for transparency and fairness in the financial industry. The Motley Fool's influence extended beyond its own subscribers, shaping public policy and regulatory frameworks that would benefit millions of investors.