The Allegory of Good and Bad Government
Ambrogio Lorenzetti began painting The Allegory of Good and Bad Government in February 1338. He finished the work by May 1339 inside Siena's Palazzo Pubblico. This room was known as the Sala dei Nove, or Salon of Nine. It served as the meeting hall for the nine executive magistrates who governed the Republic of Siena. The Council of Nine commissioned this series of three fresco panels to remind these leaders of the consequences of their decisions. Unlike most art from that era, the subject matter focused on civic life rather than religious themes. Fourteenth-century Italy faced constant violent party struggles and frequent government overthrows. The Black Death would later strike the region, adding to the turbulent political climate. Siena stood as one of the most powerful Italian city-states during this time. Its population included many bankers and merchants who shaped its economic power.
The murals cover three walls within the Council Room while leaving the southern wall empty. That southern wall contains the room's sole window which blocks any mural placement there. A door used by the council for entry sits on the opposite northern wall. On the eastern wall Lorenzetti depicted scenes showing the Effects of Good Government. The opposing western wall features The Allegory and Effects of Bad Government. Overlooking both of these murals on the northern wall are personifications representing allegorical virtues of good government. This arrangement maximizes visibility for magistrates sitting in the Sala dei Nove. The layout forces viewers to look across the room when examining specific details. The perspective shifts depending on where a viewer stands relative to Justice's gaze line. This spatial design ensures every magistrate sees the warnings and promises painted before them daily.
Six crowned female figures represent the virtues of Good Government in the fresco. Peace Fortitude and Prudence stand on the left side of the composition. Magnanimity Temperance and Justice occupy the right side. Justice balances scales held by Wisdom while floating bodiless ghosts appear above as heavenly spheres. Two children play at the feet of the ruler possibly representing Romulus and Remus or sons of Remus Ascius and Senius. Text within the lower border reads that this holy virtue induces unity among many souls. Below the fresco appears Ambrosius Laurentii De Senis Hic Pinxit Utrinque which serves as Lorenzetti's signature. On the opposite wall a devious figure adorned with horns and fangs sits enthroned. This figure identified as Tyrammides rests his feet upon a goat while holding a dagger. Captive Justice lies bound below him flanked by Cruelty Deceit Fraud Fury Division and War. Above float Avarice Pride and Vainglory considered leading enemies of human life by advice books for city magistrates.
The Effects of Good Government in the City presents a panoramic view of fourteenth-century Siena. Viewers can identify specific buildings like clustered palaces markets towers churches streets and walls. The painting offers the first accurate panoramic view of city and country since antiquity. Shops indicate good commerce and economic conditions thriving under virtuous rule. Traffic moves peacefully through streets where guild members work at their trades. A wedding procession takes place while maidens dance gracefully near the center of the scene. Dancers common for springtime rituals act as metaphors for peaceful commonwealth in this painting. The young women could represent the Nine Muses from Greek mythology. The fresco then blends into Peaceful Country showing a bird's-eye view of the Tuscan countryside. Villas castles plowed farmlands and peasants leisurely go about responsibilities appear beyond city walls. Security hovers above the landscape holding an unfurled scroll promising safety to all who live under law.
Lorenzetti integrated planetary medallions and monthly agricultural tasks along the border of three frescos. Citizens complete different labors for each month shown within the natural order of seasons. Fishing and tending vines occur in March while cultivation and planting happen in April. Riding appears in May followed by ploughing and stock rising in June. Cereal harvesting happens in July with threshing in August and hunting in September. Winter and fall labors do not follow normal conventions of the time but still appear clearly. Saturn's children represented by ploughmen diggers and threshers ensure peace through labor. Jupiter's children are hunters while Mars' children depend on weapons and appear as knights. Venus's children gain representation as chastity matrimonial love friendship and sociability through dancing. Half the seasons and plants depicted over the scene of war remind viewers of faulty errors. Following activities in accordance to nature ensures peace rather than disruption of civic order.
The cityscape and scale of figures do not follow a rational scheme in The Effects of Good Government. One hypothesis suggests perspective derives from a center directly in front of Tyranny on the opposite wall. Another popular hypothesis claims perspective comes from Justice's line of gaze directed across to the corner of the room. Photographs taken following her sight show buildings and figures falling into correct alignment. Science of optics during that time in Siena believed sight meant both seeing and understanding. Light had dual meaning describing physical and spiritual illumination for Sienese citizens. When placed into the mindset of a citizen of the day this strengthens arguments about Justice creating the peaceful scene. The skewed perspective radiates from this specific point of view making use of radial design. Viewers must read the bad government scene right to left automatically creating discomfort. This departure from traditional perspective forces engagement with the moral message painted before them.
Lorenzetti's The Effects of Bad Government fresco has suffered much moisture damage over centuries. The wall used to be an exterior wall exposing it to weather elements inside the Palazzo Pubblico. This deterioration means the mural is not written on as extensively as The Effects of Good Government. Windows appear wide open while houses are being demolished in the ruined city scene. Businesses exist only as an armourer shop amidst general destruction. Streets remain deserted while countryside shows two armies advancing toward each other in conflict. The whole scene creates diametrical opposite imagery compared to the good government side. Current state of preservation reflects decades of environmental exposure and lack of early conservation efforts. Scholars debate whether the depicted city represents actual Siena or serves as metaphorical ideal. Evidence includes bell towers cathedral domes and small port scenes labeled Telamon yet differences persist between reality and fresco.
Continue Browsing
Common questions
When did Ambrogio Lorenzetti begin painting The Allegory of Good and Bad Government?
Ambrogio Lorenzetti began painting The Allegory of Good and Bad Government in February 1338. He finished the work by May 1339 inside Siena's Palazzo Pubblico.
Where is The Allegory of Good and Bad Government located within the Palazzo Pubblico?
The murals cover three walls within the Council Room known as the Sala dei Nove or Salon of Nine. They occupy the eastern wall with Effects of Good Government, the western wall with The Allegory and Effects of Bad Government, and the northern wall featuring allegorical virtues.
What specific figures represent the virtues of Good Government in the fresco?
Six crowned female figures represent the virtues including Peace Fortitude Prudence Magnanimity Temperance and Justice. Justice balances scales held by Wisdom while floating bodiless ghosts appear above as heavenly spheres.
How does The Allegory of Good and Bad Government depict civic life compared to other art from that era?
Unlike most art from that era the subject matter focused on civic life rather than religious themes. The painting offers the first accurate panoramic view of city and country since antiquity showing clustered palaces markets towers churches streets and walls.
Why did Ambrogio Lorenzetti use a skewed perspective in The Allegory of Good and Bad Government?
The skewed perspective radiates from a specific point of view making use of radial design to force engagement with the moral message painted before them. Viewers must read the bad government scene right to left automatically creating discomfort which aligns with the science of optics during that time in Siena.