Swing music

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Swing music seized America by the collar on the 21st of August 1935, when Benny Goodman's orchestra took the stage at the Palomar Ballroom and young white dancers rushed the floor, electrified by rhythms they had never heard in quite that form before. The music was bold, daring, and built for bodies in motion. It would become the dominant sound of American popular life for more than a decade, crowding out everything else on the airwaves and in the ballrooms. How did a style rooted in Black dance halls of the 1920s become the national soundtrack of a generation? Who were the architects of that sound, and what forces eventually dismantled the empire they built? And what happens to a musical form when the dancers stop dancing?

• 2. Roots in the 1920s

  ›

  In 1923 the Fletcher Henderson Orchestra began reshaping what a large dance band could sound like. Arranger Don Redman introduced call-response exchanges between the brass and reed sections, and the rhythm felt smoother than the ragtime-inflected "hot" dance music that filled most ballrooms at the time. When Louis Armstrong joined Henderson in 1924, the emphasis on individual soloists sharpened further. Coleman Hawkins, Benny Carter, and Buster Bailey were also in the band, each shaping the instrumental styles that the swing era would later inherit wholesale. Henderson's residency at the Roseland Ballroom in New York made his orchestra a direct influence on every large band that passed through the city. Duke Ellington himself credited Henderson as an early model when he was assembling his own sound.

  Armstrong left Henderson in 1925 and carried his innovations into Chicago-style jazz, a format that freed soloists from the tight contrapuntal weave of the older New Orleans tradition. The New Orleans style had relied on a two-beat meter with trumpet, clarinet, and trombone trading in close counterpoint over sousaphone and drums. Chicago jazz loosened all that, giving Armstrong room to accent the second and fourth beats, to slip lead-in notes ahead of the main beats, and to build a rhythmic pulse that lived between the downbeats as well as on them. That gap between the beats is, in a precise sense, what "swing" means.

  By 1927 Armstrong was working alongside pianist Earl Hines, whose approach to the keyboard was equally subversive. Where most jazz pianists of the period built rhythmic patterns around fixed "pivot notes", Hines played melodically, horn-like, accenting lead-in figures rather than main beats, dropping silences into his phrases to build tension, and mixing meters to generate anticipation. His influence on what followed was enormous: Teddy Wilson, Art Tatum, Jess Stacy, Nat King Cole, Erroll Garner, Mary Lou Williams, and Jay McShann all carried traces of Hines in their swing-era playing.

  Meanwhile, territory dance bands across the southwestern United States were working in a different but parallel direction. These ensembles, most of them Black, favored blues-based simplicity, building riff patterns in call-response form that produced a heavy, danceable pulse. The rhythm-heavy pieces were called "stomps". Walter Page, among others, was refining the string bass technique that would eventually allow a single bassist to anchor a full-sized dance orchestra without the sousaphone, opening further rhythmic possibilities.

• 3. Early Swing Takes Shape

  ›

  Starting in 1928 the Earl Hines Orchestra broadcast regularly from the Grand Terrace Cafe in Chicago, sending Hines' rhythmic ideas across the Midwest. His arranger Jimmy Mundy would later bring those ideas directly to Benny Goodman's book. The Duke Ellington Orchestra beamed its new sound from New York's Cotton Club, and the Cab Calloway and Jimmie Lunceford orchestras followed from the same stage. The Chick Webb Orchestra settled into the Savoy Ballroom in 1931 and would not leave easily. Bennie Moten's Kansas City orchestra was building its own riff-driven, soloist-centered approach, and by late 1932 it had become something audiences were desperate to hear. At the Pearl Theatre in Philadelphia in December 1932, the doors were thrown open and people crowded inside, demanding seven encores from Moten's band.

  The Great Depression hit the swing scene hard in the early 1930s. Recording dried up. The Fletcher Henderson Orchestra folded in 1934, as did McKinney's Cotton Pickers. Henderson's next step was practical: he began selling arrangements to Benny Goodman, whose own orchestra was still searching for its identity.

  At this same moment, "sweet" dance music held the loyalty of most white American audiences. Guy Lombardo and Shep Fields were its reliable champions. Goodman, by contrast, was deliberately targeting younger listeners with something rawer. He even dismissed sweet music as a "weak sister" compared to what he called the "real music" of America. Louis Armstrong, for his part, named Lombardo's band one of his favorites, a reminder that the boundaries between commercial and artistic in popular music were never as clean as the polemicists preferred.

• 4. The Swing Era Arrives

  ›

  The Goodman orchestra had landed a slot on the radio program Let's Dance, but broadcast timing complicated its reach. The show aired after midnight on the East Coast, where few listeners were awake. On the West Coast it ran earlier, and an audience had formed there before Goodman ever arrived in California. The Palomar Ballroom triumph of the 21st of August 1935 was the result. Young dancers filled the floor, and the success rewired the landscape of American popular music overnight. Within the year, swing had launched imitators and enthusiasts across the entire world of dance bands, and the era that would last until 1946 was underway.

  A typical swing arrangement followed a recognizable architecture. An introductory chorus stated the theme. Arranged choruses showcased soloists or vocalists. Out-choruses brought the piece to a climax. Repertoire drew from the Great American Songbook of Tin Pan Alley standards, original band compositions, traditional jazz tunes including "King Porter Stomp" (a hit for Goodman), and blues.

  The dancing that went with the music was the Lindy Hop, which had originated in the late 1920s and evolved to absorb other styles including the Suzie Q, Truckin', Peckin' Jive, the Big Apple, and the Shag. Competitive subcultures of jitterbuggers congregated at hot-swing ballrooms, and their athleticism had enough cinematic appeal to land them in newsreels and films. The professional troupe Whitey's Lindy Hoppers appeared in Everybody Dance in 1936, A Day at the Races in 1937, and Hellzapoppin' in 1941.

  Not everyone welcomed the new sound. Jazz critic Hugues Panassié argued that polyphonic New Orleans improvisation was the pure form of jazz and that swing was a commercialized corruption of it. In his 1941 autobiography W. C. Handy wrote that white orchestra leaders were making commercial use of Black music and that swing was not a musical form at all, a charge notable for making no mention of Fletcher Henderson, Earl Hines, Duke Ellington, or Count Basie. The Dixieland revival, beginning in the late 1930s, positioned itself as a deliberate counter-movement, though some swing bandleaders found the revival commercially useful: Tommy Dorsey's Clambake Seven and Bob Crosby's Bobcats were Dixieland ensembles operating inside larger swing organizations.

  Between the poles of hot and sweet, Glenn Miller's clarinet-led reed sound tilted toward sweetness while still carrying bouncy medium-tempo material and pieces like the Lionel Hampton composition "Flying Home". Tommy Dorsey hired jazz trumpeter Bunny Berigan and then brought in Jimmie Lunceford's arranger Sy Oliver in 1939 to sharpen the band's edge. The Count Basie Orchestra arrived at the Savoy in 1937 carrying the riff-and-solo Kansas City style to national attention. At Goodman's 1938 Carnegie Hall concert, guests from the Basie and Ellington bands joined for a jam session that served as a kind of summit for the entire movement. Coleman Hawkins returned from Europe to New York in 1939 and recorded his celebrated version of "Body and Soul". By 1940 a cluster of younger musicians including Charlie Parker, Dizzy Gillespie, and Charlie Christian, all of whose careers had brought them to New York through swing, were beginning to develop the ideas that would become bebop.

• 5. The Collapse of an Empire

  ›

  Vocalists gradually displaced bandleaders as the main attraction. Ella Fitzgerald had joined the Chick Webb Orchestra in 1936, propelling it to popularity; when Webb died in 1939 the band continued under her name. Frank Sinatra became the star of the Tommy Dorsey Orchestra in 1940, drawing mass hysteria from bobby-soxers. Peggy Lee joined the Goodman orchestra in 1941 for two years and became its most prominent draw on its biggest hits. In a 1939 DownBeat article, Duke Ellington had already expressed dissatisfaction with the creative state of swing music, and within a few years he and other bandleaders were pursuing more ambitious and less danceable forms of orchestral jazz.

  Institutional blows arrived in rapid succession. In 1941 the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers demanded larger royalties from radio broadcasters, the broadcasters refused, and ASCAP banned its entire repertoire from airplay for the duration of the standoff. Broadcasters could not even carry a quoted fragment of ASCAP material in live performances without pre-approval. In July 1942 the American Federation of Musicians called a recording ban until labels agreed to pay royalties to musicians. Instrumental recording for major labels stopped for over a year. The last labels agreed to new terms in November 1944. During that silence, vocalists recorded with vocal group backings and the industry leaned on catalog material. Columbia re-released the 1939 Harry James recording of "All or Nothing at All" with Frank Sinatra in 1943, this time crediting Sinatra above the band. The recording found the success that had escaped it four years earlier.

  Wartime restrictions made road touring expensive and logistically strained. Military conscription thinned the labor pool for big bands. Then in 1944 the federal government imposed a 30% excise tax on dancing nightclubs, directly cutting into the market for dance-oriented music in smaller venues. The cumulative effect was devastating. Swing bands and sales declined from 1953 to 1954, and a list of top recording artists released in 1955 confirmed that big band sales had been falling since the early 1950s. The Earl Hines Orchestra of 1943, meanwhile, had featured the core musicians who would form the bebop vanguard; the following year they moved into the Billy Eckstine Orchestra, the first big band organized around bebop rather than swing.

• 6. Revival and Reinvention

  ›

  Frank Sinatra's commercial comeback in the mid-1950s, backed by a mildly swinging studio orchestra, demonstrated that swing-inflected music still had an audience. Nelson Riddle's orchestra became especially associated with the Sinatra resurgence and with Nat King Cole's pop success. The sound fed a broader category of swingin' pop that remained commercially viable into the mid-1960s and eventually settled into the easy listening genre. Bobby Darin, Dean Martin, Judy Garland, and Keely Smith all worked within this lineage.

  Count Basie and Duke Ellington had each downsized their big bands during the first half of the 1950s, then reconstituted them by 1956. Ellington's return to full big-band format was encouraged by the reception his orchestra received at the 1956 Newport Jazz Festival. Both leaders worked and received critical acclaim through the 1960s and beyond, performing until they were physically unable. Drummer Buddy Rich formed his definitive big band in 1966 and his name became synonymous with a dynamic, exuberant ensemble style. Big band jazz also sustained itself through college jazz curricula, which incorporated it as a central part of instruction.

  Outside the concert hall, cross-genre absorption kept swing alive in unexpected forms. In country music, Bob Wills and others had already fused swing with blues to produce Western swing; Asleep at the Wheel carried that tradition forward and recorded Count Basie tunes including "One O'Clock Jump" and "Jumpin' at the Woodside" with a steel guitar standing in for a horn section. In Europe, guitarist Django Reinhardt and violinist Stephane Grappelli had developed gypsy swing, a format built on guitars, bass, and lead melody instruments with no brass or percussion, drawing on French popular music, gypsy songs, and Reinhardt's own compositions. Gypsy swing groups generally kept to five players or fewer.

  A 1990s revival brought groups including Royal Crown Revue, Big Bad Voodoo Daddy, the Cherry Poppin' Daddies, Squirrel Nut Zippers, and Brian Setzer to mainstream attention, many of them playing neo-swing that blended the original style with rockabilly, ska, and rock. The revival reignited interest in swing dancing. In 2001 Robbie Williams released Swing When You're Winning, a collection of swing covers that sold more than 7 million copies worldwide, followed in November 2013 by Swings Both Ways. Electro swing, popular primarily in Europe and led by artists including Caravan Palace and Parov Stelar, fused swing repertoire and aesthetics with electronic production techniques, becoming prominent in the late 2010s. Its practitioners often draw on the Charleston era of the 1920s rather than the swing era proper, a point that makes the genre's name something of a misnomer by the standards of the original style.