Skip to content
— CH. 1 · ROMAN HISTORY AND ANCIENT SOURCES —

Sharpening stone

~4 min read · Ch. 1 of 6
6 sections
  • The Roman historian Pliny described the use of several naturally occurring stones for sharpening in his Natural History. He recorded locations of ancient sources for both oil and water stones used by craftsmen across the empire. Archaeological evidence shows that the Dyakovo culture utilized natural whetstones to maintain tools during prehistoric times. These early users relied on quartz formations found near their settlements to keep blades functional. The Ouachita Mountains in Arkansas later became a noted source for novaculite stones known as Arkansas stones. Novaculite crystals measure between 3 and 5 microns making them suitable for fine stages of knife sharpening. Eastern Crete produces a stone called the Turkish Stone mined from the Elounda mountain since antiquity. This material travels throughout the Levant region where it has been sold for centuries.

  • Natural whetstones typically form from quartz or other sedimentary rock deposits found globally. The yellow-gray Belgian Coticule has been legendary for blade edges since Roman times. Miners have quarried this stone from the Ardennes region for many centuries. A slightly coarser variant known as Belgian Blue Whetstone appears in adjacent strata alongside the yellow layer. Two-sided whetstones exist with a natural seam separating these distinct color layers. The hard stone of Charnwood Forest in northwest Leicestershire England was quarried for centuries. It served as a source for both whetstones and quern-stones used by local populations. Water of Ayr stone and speckled Tam'o Shanter stone are common slate forms used as razor oilstones in the UK. Each natural stone differs in composition adding value to collectors who seek rare specimens.

  • Artificial stones usually come in bonded abrasive forms composed of ceramic materials like silicon carbide. Aluminum oxide also known as corundum functions as an India stone or water stone alternative. Cubic boron nitride provides another option for modern sharpening applications. These synthetic options offer more aggressive cutting action than natural stones during middle stages. Modern synthetic stones generally equal natural stones in quality while providing consistency in particle size. Proportional content of abrasive particles versus base binder materials can be controlled to adjust cutting speed. The widespread availability of high-quality artificial stones has diminished the use of natural stone for sharpening. The legendary Honyama mines in Kyoto Japan closed their operations since 1967 due to this shift. Belgium currently maintains only a single mine that still quarries Coticules and Belgian Blue Whetstone counterparts. Some shapes designed for specific purposes include tools for sharpening scythes drills or serrations.

  • The Japanese traditionally use natural sharpening stones wetted with water rather than oil. Using oil on such a stone reduces its effectiveness significantly compared to water usage. Geology of Japan provided fine silicate particles embedded in a clay matrix softer than novaculite. Most famous stones are mined in the Narutaki District just north of Kyoto along the Hon-kuchi Naori stratum. Many individual mines produced stone from three stratums in the region including Ohira Uchigumori Hakka Tomae and Nakayama stones. Historically there exist three broad grades of Japanese toishi known as ara-to naka-to and shiage-to. A fourth type called nagura forms a cutting slurry on finishing stones too hard to create it alone. Ara-to probably measures between 500 and 1000 grit using non-Japanese grading systems. Naka-to likely falls within 3000 to 5000 grit range while shiage-to reaches 7000 to 10000 grit. Current synthetic grit values extend from extremely coarse 120 grit through extremely fine 30000 grit sizes.

  • A diamond plate consists of steel coated with diamond grit an abrasive that grinds metal effectively. Diamond particles soldered or electroplated onto the steel substrate form the working surface. The plate mounts on plastic or resin bases sometimes referred to as diamond stones when assembled. Series holes cut into the plate capture swarf cast off during grinding reducing costs by limiting abrasive area. Diamond plates serve multiple purposes including sharpening steel tools and maintaining flatness of man-made waterstones. Truing flattens stones whose shape changes as they wear away over time. Only a thin coating of grit and adhesive wears away on good diamond plates due to hardness. Rubbing the diamond plate on a whetstone provides a modern alternative to traditional truing methods. Highest quality diamond sharpeners use monocrystalline diamonds single structures that will not break easily. These diamonds bond onto precision ground surfaces set in nickel and locked in place via electroplating.

  • No dominant standard exists for the relationship between grit size and particle diameter today. Grit size refers to smoothness of finish produced rather than actual physical size of particles alone. Shape of abrasive particles affects the final result alongside other factors like exposure by binder material. Friability determines whether particles fracture into smaller ones under pressure of grinding or polishing. Hardness of abrasive particles influences performance across different stone types used globally. Chemical composition includes common abrasives such as diamond cubic boron nitride chromium oxide tungsten carbide silicon carbide. Sandpaper uses similar systems where mesh size selects particles included in the abrasive mix. Typical sharpening stone grit sizes range from 200 microns down to 0.5 microns depending on application. A 4 micron particle creates ultra-fine cuts suitable for slicing meat while 8 micron leaves blades sharper than factory edges. Polishing an edge to mirror-smooth finish requires 10000 grit stones measuring half a micron per particle.

Common questions

What natural stones did Pliny describe for sharpening in his Natural History?

Pliny described the use of several naturally occurring stones including oil and water stones used by craftsmen across the Roman empire. He recorded locations of ancient sources for these materials which were utilized throughout the empire.

Where are Arkansas stones quarried and what is their crystal size?

The Ouachita Mountains in Arkansas became a noted source for novaculite stones known as Arkansas stones. Novaculite crystals measure between 3 and 5 microns making them suitable for fine stages of knife sharpening.

When did the Honyama mines in Kyoto Japan close their operations?

The legendary Honyama mines in Kyoto Japan closed their operations since 1967 due to this shift. The widespread availability of high-quality artificial stones has diminished the use of natural stone for sharpening.

How do Japanese sharpening stones differ from Western oilstones regarding lubrication?

The Japanese traditionally use natural sharpening stones wetted with water rather than oil. Using oil on such a stone reduces its effectiveness significantly compared to water usage.

What grit range does shiage-to reach among historical Japanese toishi grades?

Shiage-to reaches 7000 to 10000 grit while naka-to likely falls within 3000 to 5000 grit range. Ara-to probably measures between 500 and 1000 grit using non-Japanese grading systems.