Self-Help (Smiles book)

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Self-Help; with Illustrations of Character and Conduct arrived in bookshops in 1859, written by Samuel Smiles. Within a single year, it sold 20,000 copies. By the time Smiles died in 1904, that number had grown to over a quarter of a million. Darwin biographer Janet Browne called it "the bible of the improving middle classes," a phrase that points to something larger than a publishing success. What was it about this book that made a Khedive's palace in Egypt post its mottoes on the walls? Why did socialists loathe it and praise it in the same breath? And how did a failed doctor and struggling journalist come to write one of the most widely read books of the Victorian age?

• 2. A Man Who Failed First

  ›

  Samuel Smiles came to his subject through hard experience. He tried his hand as a doctor and then as a journalist, and neither career brought him much success. He threw himself into cooperative ventures, but those collapsed when capital ran dry. Disillusioned by what he saw as the hollow promises of middle-class utopianism, he turned toward a different kind of thinking. The isolation of self-help gave him intellectual refuge and, eventually, national fame. His argument was built on three ideas drawn from the eighteenth-century Enlightenment. The first was environmental determinism, which formed what Smiles called the "passive" side of his thought: governments had a duty to clear away the barriers that blocked individuals from reaching their potential. The second idea held that a person's intellectual faculty was the last part of them to mature, which pushed Smiles toward stressing self-education and active personal effort. The third was a belief in a beneficent natural order, a conviction that hard work and honest conduct aligned with the grain of the universe. Notably, Smiles rejected the straightforward application of laissez-faire to areas like public health and education, a position that complicated his reputation as a pure individualist.

• 3. What the Book Actually Argued

  ›

  Historian Asa Briggs captured the book's core moral logic precisely. Relying on yourself, Briggs wrote, was preferred both morally and economically to depending on others. It was, Briggs argued, "an expression of character even when it did not endure." The progressive development of society, the book insisted, depended not on collective action or parliamentary legislation but on the widespread practice of self-help. Smiles extolled industry, perseverance, and self-improvement as virtues that shaped character from the inside out. The second edition, published in 1866, added Perseverance to the subtitle, signaling that the book's argument had deepened between printings. The book has since been called "the bible of mid-Victorian liberalism," a label that places it at the center of a specific political and cultural moment, when entrepreneurial improvement was, in Browne's words, "sweeping into every arena of mid-century existence."

• 4. Empires and Mottoes

  ›

  The book crossed language after language with unusual speed. Translations appeared in Dutch, French, Danish, German, Italian, Russian, Japanese, Arabic, Turkish, and in several Indian languages. In the preface to his 1880 book Duty, Smiles noted that Self-Help had been "more widely published and read" in America than in Great Britain itself. The anecdote about the Khedive's palace in Egypt suggests the reach went further still. An English visitor, noticing mottoes on the palace walls, asked where they came from. The reply was: "They are principally from Smeelis, you ought to know Smeelis! They are from his Self-Help." The pronunciation alone tells a story of translation and distance. The founder of Toyota, Sakichi Toyoda, was significantly influenced by his reading of Self-Help. A copy of the book now sits under a glass display at the museum on Toyoda's birth site, a quiet monument to where the book's influence reached.

• 5. Admirers, Critics, and Contradictions

  ›

  G. A. Henty, the English author, published three didactic juvenile novels in the 1880s that bear Smiles' clear imprint. Each was structured as an exposition of the philosophy of self-help as Smiles had expressed it. The book's reception among socialists was more turbulent. Robert Blatchford, a socialist activist, called it "one of the most delightful and invigorating books it has been my happy fortune to meet with" and argued it should be taught in schools. He acknowledged that socialists would find Smiles' individualism uncomfortable, but pointed out that Smiles himself denounced "the worship of power, wealth, success, and keeping up appearances." A labour leader pushed back sharply, calling the book brutal and Smiles "the arch-Philistine," warning that it amounted to "the apotheosis of respectability, gigmanity, and selfish grab." The socialist Robert Tressell, in his novel The Ragged Trousered Philanthropists, dismissed Self-Help as a book fit only for those suffering from "almost complete obliteration of the mental faculties." Yet scholar Jonathan Rose has found that most pre-1914 labour leaders who commented on Self-Help actually praised it. Criticism in workers' memoirs only became common after the First World War. Labour Party MPs William Johnson and Thomas Summerbell admired Smiles' work. The Communist miners' leader A. J. Cook said he "started out with Self-Help."

• 6. A More Complex Legacy

  ›

  Alexander Tyrell, writing in 1970, argued that the middle class held multiple value systems and that Smiles represented just one strand among many. That observation cuts against the idea of Self-Help as a simple ideological weapon. The book elevated Smiles, almost overnight by contemporary accounts, to "celebrity status," making him "a leading pundit and much-consulted guru." What the admiring and the hostile responses share is the recognition that the book carried real weight. The Labour Party MPs who praised it and the labour leader who wanted it burned by the common hangman were both responding to something that mattered. Cook's statement that he "started out with Self-Help" points to a book that shaped people's sense of what was possible, whatever they later became.