Sant'Anna di Stazzema massacre

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Sant'Anna di Stazzema is a hill village in Tuscany, and on the morning of the 12th of August 1944, it ceased to exist as its inhabitants had known it. German Waffen-SS troops, accompanied by Italian fascist fighters from the Black Brigades dressed in German uniforms, arrived before most people had finished breakfast. What happened in the next three hours was not the chaos of battle. It was a systematic operation. The soldiers rounded up hundreds of villagers and refugees, herded them into barns, stables, basements, and a 16th-century church, and then killed them. About 560 people died that morning. More than a hundred of them were children. The youngest victim was twenty days old. The questions this story leaves open are not small ones. Who gave the orders? Who carried them out? And what happened when the world tried to hold those men accountable decades later?

• 2. The Morning of August 12th

  ›

  Troops from the 2nd Battalion of SS Panzergrenadier Regiment 35, part of the 16th SS Panzergrenadier Division Reichsführer-SS, entered Sant'Anna di Stazzema under the command of SS-Hauptsturmführer Anton Galler. Their stated purpose was an operation against the Italian resistance movement, but the people they found in the village were not combatants. They were local families and refugees sheltering in the hills.

  The soldiers locked hundreds of people into several barns and stables before shooting groups with machine guns or pushing them into enclosed spaces and throwing in hand grenades. At the local church, a priest named Fiore Menguzzo was shot at point-blank range. Machine guns were then turned on roughly a hundred people gathered there. The pews were used to build a bonfire to burn the bodies.

  Among the at least 107 children killed was Anna Pardini, who was twenty days old. Eight pregnant women also died; one of them, Evelina Berretti, was killed with a bayonet wound to the abdomen. The livestock throughout the village were also killed, and every building was burned. When it was over, the SS men sat outside the burning village and ate lunch.

• 3. Memory and Memorials

  ›

  After the war ended, the villagers rebuilt the church. Two structures were raised in the surrounding area to hold the memory of what had happened: the Charnel House Monument and the Historical Museum of Resistance. A trail connecting the church to a larger memorial site was lined with Stations of the Cross depicting scenes from the massacre.

  That larger site, the National Park of Peace, was founded in 2000. The trail and the park together created a kind of topography of mourning, where the landscape itself guides visitors through the sequence of events.

  The massacre also entered the wider cultural record through fiction. James McBride's novel Miracle at St. Anna drew on the events, and Spike Lee later directed a film adaptation under the same title. The priest Fiore Menguzzo, killed at point-blank range that morning, was awarded the Medal for Civil Valor posthumously in 1999.

• 4. The Long Wait for Justice

  ›

  Apart from divisional commander Max Simon, no one was prosecuted for the Sant'Anna di Stazzema massacre for nearly six decades. That changed in July 2004, when a military court in La Spezia, Italy, opened a trial against ten former Waffen-SS officers and non-commissioned officers who were still living in Germany.

  On the 22nd of June 2005, the court found all ten guilty of participation in the killings. The men convicted included Werner Bruß, born in 1920; Alfred Mathias Concina, born in 1919; Ludwig Göring, born in 1923, who had confessed to killing twenty women; Karl Gropler, born in 1923; Georg Rauch, born in 1921; Horst Richter, born in 1921; Heinrich Schendel, born in 1922; Alfred Schöneberg, born in 1921; Gerhard Sommer, born in 1921; and Ludwig Heinrich Sonntag, born in 1924. All ten were sentenced in absentia to life imprisonment.

  The Military Tribunal of La Spezia and Italy's highest court of appeal both characterized the killings as voluntary and organized acts of terrorism. But the sentences could not be enforced. Germany rejected Italy's extradition requests, meaning every man convicted walked free.

• 5. Germany's Closed Door

  ›

  In 2012, German prosecutors formally shelved their own investigation into seventeen unnamed former SS soldiers who had been part of the unit at Sant'Anna. Eight of those men were still alive at the time. The prosecutors concluded there was insufficient evidence to proceed.

  The statement they issued drew a clear legal line: belonging to a Waffen-SS unit deployed to Sant'Anna di Stazzema was not, by itself, enough to establish guilt. Each defendant, the statement said, required individual proof of participation and the specific form that participation took.

  Michele Silicani, the village mayor, had been ten years old on the day of the massacre and was among those who survived it. He called Germany's decision a scandal and said he would press Italy's justice minister to lobby for the case to be reopened. German deputy foreign minister Michael Georg Link acknowledged that the decision, while within the bounds of the independent German justice system, caused, in his words, deep dismay and renewed suffering to Italians, including survivors and relatives of the victims. The gulf between what the La Spezia tribunal established and what German law could act on remained, as of those statements, unresolved.