Sacramental wine

• 1. The Chalice of Benediction

  ›

  Paul the Apostle staked out the theological meaning of sacramental wine in a letter to the Corinthians, posing it as a direct question: "The chalice of benediction, which we bless, is it not the communion of the blood of Christ?" That question has driven centuries of practice, dispute, and meticulous regulation. What liquid may fill that chalice, who may drink from it, and what rules govern its production have all been disputed. Those debates produced some of the most detailed regulations in the history of religious observance.

  12

• 2. The Restricted Cup

  ›

  In the earliest celebrations of the Lord's Supper, both clergy and laity received the consecrated wine by drinking directly from the chalice. That practice did not hold in Western Christianity. Northern Europe presented a concrete obstacle: the climate was unsuitable for viticulture, making wine genuinely difficult to obtain. Over time, access to the chalice narrowed until the celebrating priest alone received the wine. Ordinary worshippers received only the bread.

  Red wine's symbolic connection to the blood of Christ lost much of its importance once most communicants never touched the cup. The argument for choosing red wine weakened accordingly. A reversal came in the twentieth century. After the Second Vatican Council, the Latin Catholic Church moved to restore the earlier practice. Communion under both bread and wine became more broadly available to lay Catholics once again. In Eastern churches, which maintained communion under both forms throughout this period, a different set of priorities governed the choice of wine.

  111247

• 3. Red, White, and Regional

  ›

  Greek Orthodox practice insists on red wine in the Divine Liturgy, chosen to symbolize the blood of Jesus Christ. The Greek Orthodox Church specifically favours Mavrodaphne or Nama. The Russian Orthodox Church favours Kagor. Wines with additives are explicitly disqualified: retsina and wines containing high fructose corn syrup are both forbidden. The Eastern Orthodox tradition's requirements extend further still. Wine used in the Divine Liturgy must typically be fermented, pure, and sweet.

  Altar cloth stains are the reason white wine appears in Western Christian practice at all. For the practical purpose of avoiding stains on white linens, the Latin tradition sometimes uses white wine instead of red. The theological requirement remains unchanged: the wine must be pure grape wine. The Catholic Church, the Eastern Orthodox Church, and the Lutheran Churches all treat the purity of grape origin as fundamental.

  Even water's presence in the chalice was a matter of ritual tradition, with practices varying widely across the major Christian rites.

  4785

• 4. The Water Ritual

  ›

  The Roman, Byzantine, Antiochene, and Alexandrian rites all add a small quantity of water to the wine when preparing the chalice. Its origins lie in common ancient Mediterranean practice. Over centuries, the ritual accumulated multiple symbolic meanings. It has been understood to represent the mystery of Christ's human and divine natures. It also signifies his unity with the Church, and the flow of blood and water from his side at his death. The Armenian Rite alone stands apart, consecrating wine without any previous mingling of water.

  The Byzantine Rite goes a step further, adding hot water to the consecrated wine shortly before Communion itself. This addition carries its own Greek name: zeon, meaning "boiling." It is a distinctive feature of Byzantine practice, adding further symbolic weight to an already layered ritual. The chemical purity of the wine those rituals employ was governed by a separate and equally detailed body of church law.

  5712

• 5. Legal Standards

  ›

  Canon 924 of the Code of Canon Law, issued in 1983, sets out the fundamental requirements in plain terms. The wine must be natural, made from grapes of the vine, and not corrupt. It cannot have soured or become vinegar. Nothing artificial may be added. The result is that naturally fermented pure grape wine is required, free of preservatives and flavorings.

  There are limited exceptions. In some circumstances, the Church accepts mustum, a wine that is only minimally fermented. An 1896 directive from the Congregation of the Inquisition addressed another case. Weak wines could be preserved with grape brandy, provided three conditions were met. The alcohol had to be distilled from grapes. The total alcohol content could not exceed eighteen percent. The addition had to be made during fermentation itself. For some Protestant denominations, the more fundamental question was whether fermented wine had any place in worship at all.

  674

• 6. Grape Juice and Teetotalism

  ›

  Methodist denominations have historically supported teetotalism, and that conviction extends to sacramental practice. Methodist churches use non-alcoholic grape juice in the celebration of the Lord's Supper. The 1916 rubric in the Discipline of the Methodist Episcopal Church made the requirement explicit: "Let the pure, unfermented juice of the grape be used in administering the Lord's Supper." That directive has shaped the practice of descendant Methodist connexions. In wider Protestant practice, both fermented wine and grape juice are used depending on the denomination. Either is considered valid for a communicant who receives in only one form. How that liquid reaches the communicant has been worked out with comparable precision by each tradition.

  328

• 7. Cup, Spoon, and Straw

  ›

  In the Roman Rite of the Catholic Church, the consecrated wine reaches the communicant in one of two primary ways. The first is direct drinking from the chalice. The second is intinction: the priest partially dips the consecrated bread into the wine, then places it in the communicant's mouth. Editions of the Roman Missal issued between 1970 and 2000 also envisioned a third method. A silver tube called the fistula, functioning like a straw, could be used to drink from the chalice.

  The Byzantine Rite developed a different solution altogether. Both the consecrated Body and Blood of Christ are placed together in the chalice. A sacramental spoon is then used to give the communicant a portion of both at once. Lutheran and Anglican churches typically use what is sometimes called the common cup: each communicant receives a small sip from the chalice as it is offered. Other Protestant denominations distribute small individual cups on a tray, although a larger chalice may still be used by the presiding minister. Those requirements for pure, ritually consistent wine have sustained a dedicated supply chain reaching back to the nineteenth century.

  91110154

• 8. Sacred Vineyards

  ›

  Throughout the world, small wineries exist either solely for the production of sacramental wine or with sacramental wine as an auxiliary business. Many are run by religious brothers, priests, or dedicated laity. These operations are modest in scale and often tied directly to the religious communities they serve.

  Australian Jesuits founded what is now the oldest existing winery in the Clare Valley in 1851, established to produce sacramental wines. The winery currently produces over 90,000 litres annually and supplies all of the Australian region's sacramental wine needs. In the United States, the oldest vineyard founded for sacramental purposes that is still producing is O-Neh-Da Vineyard. It is located in the Finger Lakes wine region of New York State. It was founded in 1872 by Bernard John McQuaid, the bishop of Rochester. Similar dedicated wineries serve other religious traditions; the parallel industry for kosher wine follows an equally exacting set of religious requirements.

  14137