Russkaya Pravda

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Russkaya Pravda carries a prince's command across nearly a thousand years: "Live according to this charter, as I have written it for you, and observe it." Yaroslav the Wise spoke those words to Novgorod after a war that nearly shattered Kievan Rus'. What he handed his city was not a trophy or a treaty. It was the beginning of a legal code.

  That code would be rewritten by his sons, extended by his grandson Vladimir Monomakh, and eventually replaced. Kievan Rus' itself would fragment and fall. Yet the Russkaya Pravda survived. It regulated who could seek revenge for a murder and how much a man's life was worth in fines. It even specified what happened to a peasant who borrowed money and could not repay it.

  What makes the Russkaya Pravda remarkable is what it chose not to do. Despite centuries of close ties between Kievan Rus' and Byzantium, the code bears no resemblance to Byzantine law. Its spirit points elsewhere. And understanding where it actually came from is the first step in understanding what kind of society it was designed to govern.

  12133

• 2. A Law Apart

  ›

  The Russkaya Pravda contains no death sentences. It prescribes no floggings, no mutilations, no state-sanctioned executions. For a medieval legal code, this was striking. Scholars have traced this to Norse jurisprudence rather than any continental model.

  The Norse comparison is complicated by a timing problem. The earliest written Scandinavian law books appeared only after Scandinavia had been Christianized, which postdates the Russkaya Pravda's origins. Some scholars have looked to Germanic law instead, particularly a group of early medieval codes known as the Leges Barbarorum. The resemblances exist but are not precise, and a gap of roughly five centuries separates those codes from the Russkaya Pravda. The 9th-century Lex Saxonum has drawn particular attention: its first dozen or so articles closely parallel the first ten articles of the Short Edition.

  The treaties Kievan Rus' signed with Byzantium in 911 and 941 both refer to something called the zakon russkii. That phrase suggests a body of customary law was already functioning before Yaroslav set anything down in writing. Common law, the rulings of the knyaz, and legal proceedings had all been shaping behavior for generations. What drove Yaroslav to commit any of it to writing was a conflict with his own family.

  121310

• 3. Born of War

  ›

  In 1013 or 1014, Yaroslav stopped sending the annual tribute that Novgorod owed Kiev. His father Vladimir began assembling an army, and Yaroslav brought in Varangian warriors to reinforce his own forces.

  The Varangians proved destructive inside Novgorod. The city rose against them, killing many. Yaroslav executed several prominent Novgorodians in retaliation. Then word arrived that Vladimir had died. He made peace with Novgorod and marched south, defeating his half-brother Sviatopolk.

  The Novgorod chronicle records what happened next. Scholars have debated the Short Edition's origin at length. The majority view holds that Yaroslav issued a written law connected to Novgorod's support in the war. The second part of the Short Edition, the Pravda Yaroslavichey, was almost certainly not part of that original document. It covered questions the first law had not addressed.

  The Pravda Yaroslavichey is named for its opening line. That line begins: "The law established for the Russian land, when Iziaslav, Vsevolod, Sviatoslav, Kosniachko Pereneg, Mikyfor the Kievan, and Chudin Mikula met together." Scholars most often date that gathering to 1072. New provisions were also added in the wake of revolts in Kiev, Novgorod, and Rostov-Suzdal province during 1068-1071. Those upheavals pushed the drafters of the Expanded Edition to address social groups the first law barely acknowledged: smerds, zakups, and kholops.

  121332

• 4. Justice and Its Price

  ›

  When a man was killed in Kievan Rus', his closest male relatives had the right to seek vengeance. The Russkaya Pravda did not abolish this blood feud; it narrowed it. Only the victim's nearest male kin could pursue the killer. If no such relatives existed, the killer owed a fine to the knyaz, the local prince. That fine, called a vyra, had to be shared by the killer's community.

  When the victim was a woman, the fine fell to half the standard rate, called poluvir'ye. The Pravda also protected the health and honor of free people in feudal society. It set compensation for mutilation or insult. Its rules extended to theft in city or countryside, damage to forests and hunting grounds, trespassing, debt, and inheritance.

  The Expanded Edition addressed three categories of feudal-dependent peasants. Smerds were tied to the land. Zakups had taken a feudal loan, also called a zakup, and were bound to their creditor's service until they repaid it. Kholops occupied the lowest position; they could be killed or sold, like property.

  The Pravda Yaroslavichey added a new layer of collective liability. Communities were held responsible when soldiers of a knyaz were killed on their territory. Tiuns, starostas, and otroks, the various ranks of the knyaz's administration and military, all fell under this provision. Arson, deliberate cattle mutilation, and organized encroachment on wealthy landowners' property carried severe punishment.

  After the 1113 revolt in Kiev, the Expanded Edition introduced a law capping what moneylenders could charge. Exorbitant interest had apparently been a grievance serious enough to fuel an uprising. The Pravda also preserved the trial by water or iron as a last resort for establishing guilt. The legal process relied on witnesses, oaths, and physical evidence; investigators were obligated to screen for false accusations.

  What preserved the Russkaya Pravda was its adoption by Russian Orthodox monasteries. The monastic collections that housed it became the code's only path to the modern world.

  1213112

• 5. Three Editions and a Rediscovery

  ›

  Three versions of the Russkaya Pravda exist. Scholars call them the Short Edition, the Extensive Edition, and the Abridged Edition. The shortest runs to around 850 words; the longest is roughly four times that length. The Abridged Edition is known only from two copies, both made in the 17th century.

  The Extensive Edition, or Prostrannaya Pravda, circulated far more widely. Around a hundred copies have survived. About three-quarters of them were found inside kormchie books, collections of canon law used by the Russian Orthodox Church. The rest turned up in other monastic collections, including a compilation known as the Merilo Pravednoye.

  Modern scholarly attention to the code began in 1738, when Vasily Tatischev found it embedded in a manuscript of the Novgorod chronicles. The chronicle had placed the Russkaya Pravda under the entry for the year 1016. Tatischev annotated the text and passed it to the Russian Academy of Sciences, but publication was delayed. It did not appear in print until 1786.

  Around the same time, August Ludwig von Schlözer published a separate edition using a different manuscript. The first dedicated study of the code appeared in 1756. F. Strube de Piermont delivered it as an academic address titled "Discours sur l'origine et les changements des loix russiennes." V. Krestinin published the Prostrannaya Pravda separately in 1788. The accumulated scholarship of two centuries was eventually gathered in a three-volume edition produced by the Soviet Academy of Sciences, edited by Boris Grekov.

  The Russkaya Pravda had ceased to function as active law several centuries before Tatischev's rediscovery. Understanding what replaced it means returning to Moscow and a very different kind of ruler.

  159124

• 6. The Sudebnik and the End

  ›

  In 1497, Ivan III replaced the Russkaya Pravda with a new legal code called the Sudebnik. This was not a minor revision. The state centered on Moscow was consolidating rapidly, and the Sudebnik drew together the fragmented regional laws under a single framework. The era of legal fragmentation that the Russkaya Pravda had governed was over.

  The Sudebnik superseded several regional codes, including the Pskov Judicial Charter and the Novgorod Judicial Charter. Among those, the Pskov Judicial Charter stood out. It had been the most significant piece of legislation in the gap between the Russkaya Pravda and the newly unified state. Ivan III's grandson, Ivan IV, went further with the Sudebnik of 1550.

  What the Russkaya Pravda could not do was end legal fragmentation entirely. The Sudebnik of 1497 is described as the first milestone of a newly unified Russian state.

  121311