Recusancy

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Recusancy was the formal name given to an act of refusal: the refusal, by Catholics in England, to attend Church of England services after the English Reformation. The word comes from the Latin recusare, meaning to refuse. For more than three centuries, that single act of conscience carried legal consequences. The 1558 Recusancy Acts, passed under Elizabeth I, imposed fines, property confiscation, and imprisonment on those who stayed away from Anglican worship. In the worst cases, the penalty was death. What drove ordinary people to risk everything for a church that the English state had officially discarded? And how did their stubbornness shape English culture, literature, and even the Bible that millions still read today?

• 2. The Weight of the Law

  ›

  Elizabeth I signed the Recusancy Acts into law in 1558, and they stayed on the statute books for a remarkable three hundred and thirty years, until 1888. The punishments they carried were designed to make dissent economically ruinous. Fines drained family fortunes. Confiscated property stripped recusants of the land that anchored their social standing. Imprisonment severed them from their communities.

  Oliver Cromwell suspended the Acts during the Interregnum of 1649-1660, but this was not an act of sympathy toward Catholics. The suspension was mainly intended to relieve Nonconformist Protestants, and certain restrictions on Catholics continued even after Cromwell. The Act of Settlement of 1701 kept barriers in place long after the Interregnum ended. Catholic emancipation did not arrive until 1828-1829, and some restrictions lingered into the 1920s.

  The first statute to address sectarian dissent by name was enacted in 1593. It was titled "An Act for restraining Popish recusants" and defined a recusant as any person convicted of not attending a church, chapel, or usual place of Common Prayer. The law left little ambiguity. Recusancy laws remained in force from the reign of Elizabeth I through to that of George III, though the intensity of enforcement shifted across those generations. For Protestant dissenters, the picture changed under William III, whose Act of Toleration offered significant relief. Catholics, as the Nuttall Encyclopaedia records, were not entirely emancipated until 1829.

• 3. Saints, Martyrs, and Hidden Priests

  ›

  Capital punishment was not rare in the recusant period. Some English and Welsh Catholics executed in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries have since been canonised by the Catholic Church as martyrs of the English Reformation. The recusant period, as one description puts it, reaped an extensive harvest of saints and martyrs.

  Dorothy Lawson gives a face to that abstract harvest. A Catholic noblewoman, she turned the social privileges of widowhood into a form of resistance. She harboured priests in her household, employed Catholic servants, and held religious services for her local community. Members of the Society of Jesus met yearly at her home to discuss the mission in England. She visited recusants imprisoned in gaol. Three of her daughters eventually entered convents on the continent, and a son attended a seminary in Douai.

  The Douai connection appears again in the story of the Douay-Rheims Bible. Expatriate recusants translated the New Testament from the Latin Vulgate in Rheims, France, in 1582. The Old Testament followed in Douai, France, in 1609. Bishop Richard Challoner later revised this translation across the years 1749-1752. That Bible, born from exile and persecution, became the standard Catholic English scripture for centuries.

• 4. Aristocrats and Plotters

  ›

  Among the recusants were some of England's most prominent Catholic families. The Howards, some of whose members carry the name Fitzalan-Howard as Dukes of Norfolk, are considered the most prominent Catholic family in England. The Dukes of Norfolk hold the highest hereditary non-royal rank in the country, serving as hereditary Earl Marshals. Not all Howards remained Catholic; the Earls of Carlisle, Effingham, and Suffolk became Anglican, including a cadet branch of the Carlisles who came to own Castle Howard in Yorkshire.

  Recusancy was geographically concentrated. The north of England, particularly Cumberland, Lancashire, Yorkshire, and Westmoreland, was its heartland. The Weld family offers a counterexample to that northern pattern. A branch originally from Shropshire moved via London to Oxfordshire and Dorset. The three sons of Sir John Weld, who lived from 1585 to 1622 and founded the Weld Chapel in Southgate, all married into recusant families. His eldest son Humphrey began a lineage known as the Lulworth Welds, who built marriage ties to an extraordinarily wide network of Catholic families: the Arundells, Blundells, Cliffords, Erringtons, Gillows, Haydocks, Petres, Ropers, Shireburns, Smythes, Stourtons, Throckmortons, Fitzherberts, Vaughans, and Vavasours.

  At the violent edge of recusancy stood the Gunpowder Plot. Guy Fawkes, described in the sources as both an Englishman and a Spanish soldier, was arrested along with Sir Robert Catesby, Christopher Wright, John Wright, Thomas Percy, and others on the 5th of November 1605. They were charged with attempting to blow up the King and Parliament. The plot was uncovered and most of the plotters were tried and executed.

• 5. Writers, Composers, and Secret Faiths

  ›

  Composer William Byrd is among the most notable cultural figures linked to recusancy. Some of his most popular motets are theorised to have been composed for recusant communities in England, with texts lamenting England's condition and expressing hope for a return to Catholicism. Two volumes of his Cantiones Sacrae, published in 1589 and 1591, contain a number of these works. Byrd also corresponded with the Spanish composer Philippe de Monte. A well-known story holds that de Monte sent Byrd a motet in eight parts set to verses of Psalm 137, and that Byrd replied by setting the verses that follow.

  The poet John Donne was born into a recusant Catholic family, though he later authored two Protestant-leaning writings. At the direct request of King James I, he was ordained into the Church of England.

  William Shakespeare's relationship to Catholicism remains contested. Shakespeare himself and his immediate family were conforming members of the Church of England. His mother, Mary Arden, however, came from a conspicuously and determinedly Catholic family in Warwickshire. The strongest evidence of possible recusancy in the Shakespeare family is a tract professing secret Catholicism, found in the eighteenth century in the rafters of a house that had once belonged to John Shakespeare, the poet's father. The scholar Edmond Malone saw and described the tract, but later declared he believed it was a forgery. The document has since been lost. Anthony Holden notes that Malone's reported wording connects the tract to a testament written by Charles Borromeo and circulated in England by Edmund Campion, copies of which survive in both Italian and English. Conflicting research suggests the Borromeo testament dates no earlier than 1638 and was not produced for missionary use. John Shakespeare did appear on a list of those absent from church services, but the commissioners' record states this was "for feare of processe for Debtte", not religious refusal.

• 6. Beyond England's Borders

  ›

  The vast majority of native Irish people rejected both the reformed Church of Ireland and the dissenting churches, remaining loyal to Catholicism and suffering the same legal penalties as recusants in Great Britain. Their situation was further complicated by land disputes, paramilitary violence, and ethnic antagonism cutting across multiple directions.

  In Scandinavia, recusancy as an organised phenomenon did not survive much past the Liturgical Struggle. Anti-Catholicism eased toward the end of the eighteenth century, and freedom of religion was re-established in the mid-nineteenth century, though individual cases of Catholic sympathy appeared even in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Christina, Queen of Sweden and daughter of Gustavus Adolphus, was among the notable converts of that era. So was Sigrid Undset, who won the Nobel Prize for her novel Kristin Lavransdatter. The number of ethnic Swedes who are Catholic remains fewer than forty thousand. Anders Arborelius, a convert, became the first Swedish bishop since the Reformation. In 2017, he was elevated to cardinal.