Polydactyly

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Polydactyly, the birth condition that produces extra fingers or toes, has shaped the lives of poets, cricketers, pitchers, and at least one Roman whose very name encoded his six-fingered hands. The blues guitarist Theodore Roosevelt Taylor, who played under the name Hound Dog Taylor, was born with polydactyly on both hands and later removed one of his extra fingers himself, around the age of 41. Garfield Sobers, the West Indian cricket legend, reportedly did the same in childhood with catgut and a sharp knife. A boy named Akshat Saxena, born in Uttar Pradesh in 2010, holds the world record for the most digits: seven on each hand and ten on each foot, totaling 34. These are not rare curiosities at the margins of human experience. Polydactyly is the most common defect of the hands and feet, appearing in roughly 4 to 12 out of every 10,000 newborns. What drives this variation? Why do some extra digits function perfectly while others amount to a small flap of soft tissue? And what does this condition reveal about how limbs form in the first place?

• 2. Three Kinds of Extra

  ›

  Antonio Alfonseca, the retired Major League Baseball pitcher nicknamed El Pulpo, meaning the Octopus, carried an extra digit on each of his four extremities. His case is the most familiar kind: postaxial, or ulnar, polydactyly, in which the additional digit appears on the little-finger side of the hand. This form is by far the most common. Ulnar polydactyly occurs ten times more often in African populations than in Caucasian ones. The incidence among Africans is recorded at 1 in 143 live births, compared with 1 in 1,339 live births in Caucasians. In African populations the condition is usually isolated, while in Caucasian patients it is more often part of a broader genetic syndrome, though a retrospective review found only 4 of 37 Caucasian cases were syndromic. Radial, or preaxial, polydactyly sits at the thumb side of the hand. It is most frequent in Indian populations and is the second most common congenital hand disorder overall, occurring in roughly 1 in every 3,000 live births. Here the duplication ranges from a barely visible skin tag to a complete second thumb with its own metacarpal. A far rarer third category, central polydactyly, places the extra digit among the ring, middle, or index fingers. Of these, the index finger is most often affected, while the ring finger is the least likely target.

• 3. Genes and Signals

  ›

  Polydactyly is associated with at least 39 distinct genetic mutations, a figure that reflects how many different points in the developmental process can go wrong. Mutations in Hoxa and Hoxd gene clusters are known to produce the condition. Interactions between Hoxd13 and GLI3 specifically trigger synpolydactyly, a variant that combines extra digits with fused digits. GLI3 mutations at chromosome location 7p13 appear in two separate categories of the condition, postaxial type A1 and preaxial type IV, illustrating how the same gene can produce different anatomical outcomes depending on context. In preaxial polydactyly, a cis-acting mutation located approximately 1 megabase upstream of the SHH gene has been identified. Normally SHH is expressed in a region called the zone of polarizing activity, positioned at the posterior side of the developing limb. In the mutant, a smaller ectopic expression appears on the anterior side instead, triggering cell proliferation that generates the raw material for one or more new digits. A 2020 study added an environmental dimension, finding a relationship between polydactyly and maternal exposure to PM10 air pollution during pregnancy in China.

• 4. Ancient Fingers and Fins

  ›

  Polydactyly in humans is relatively new as a scientific puzzle, but extra digits in the broader history of life stretch back hundreds of millions of years. Polydactyly is believed to have been common in early tetrapods, particularly the extinct amphibians that represented the earliest land-living vertebrates. The number of toes in those animals fluctuated until the early Carboniferous period, when a uniform count began to stabilize. Amniotes eventually settled on five toes per limb, while amphibians fixed on four toes per front limb and five per back limb. In extinct marine reptiles such as ichthyosaurs and hupehsuchians, polydactyly was not a disorder but a non-pathological, re-acquired feature. Some of these animals had more than ten digits packed into their paddle-shaped flippers. Analysis of Maine Coon cats, which are naturally prone to polydactyly, reveals a developmental pattern: two additional toes appear far more frequently than four, and four more frequently than six or eight. Evo-devo researchers treat this as evidence of developmental bias, the idea that anatomy is not just the passive product of random mutation but is shaped by the inherent tendencies of how bodies build themselves. Computer models can now reproduce the symbolic generation of those extra toes, tracing the logic from gene to limb.

• 5. Diagnosis and Syndromes

  ›

  Prenatal ultrasound can detect polydactyly as early as nine weeks into a pregnancy. After a child turns one year old, X-rays become useful for mapping the underlying bone structures. Classification of the condition rests on those images, using a framework that traces back to 1961, when Frantz and O'Rahilly proposed seven categories of congenital limb anomaly. Swanson refined this in 1976, and polydactyly sits under the duplication category. As of 2009, researchers had linked 97 distinct genetic syndromes to one or another form of the condition. Ulnar polydactyly, for example, connects to Trisomy 13, Down syndrome, Meckel syndrome, Ellis-van Creveld syndrome, and Bardet-Biedl syndrome, among others. Radial polydactyly type VII associates with Holt-Oram syndrome, Fanconi anemia, and Townes-Brocks syndrome. Because the roster of related syndromes is long, guidelines call for a geneticist to examine children with congenital upper limb deformities, particularly when more than two or three generations of a family are affected. Research published as of 2009 also showed that the majority of congenital anomalies arise during a four-week embryologic window of rapid limb development.

• 6. Surgery and Its Outcomes

  ›

  Treatment for polydactyly ranges from simple suture ligation in the newborn nursery to staged surgical procedures completed around two years of age. For ulnar type B polydactyly, in which the extra digit hangs from a narrow skin pedicle without bone or ligament, ligation cuts off the blood supply and allows the digit to fall away; the digit is typically gone within an average of ten days. A study of 21 patients treated this way reported no complications of infection or bleeding. A larger study of 105 patients, however, found an overall complication rate of 23.5%, with 16% developing a residual tender bump, 6% an infection, and 1% bleeding. For radial polydactyly involving two severely underdeveloped thumbs, surgeons may use the Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure, which fuses tissue from both thumbs into one composite digit. The average flexion of the interphalangeal joint after this reconstruction is 55 degrees less than the unaffected thumb. The more commonly used technique, ablation with collateral ligament reconstruction, preserves the nail bed and growth plate, reducing long-term nail deformity, but it carries risks of joint instability and size mismatch. A 2014 study recorded a 19% revision rate for preaxial polydactyly due to pain or instability. Central polydactyly carries the most difficult prognosis: a study by Tada and colleagues reviewing 12 patients found that all required secondary procedures to address flexion contractures and angular deviation at the joint level.

• 7. In Culture and Record Books

  ›

  Endre Ady, the Hungarian poet, was born with six fingers; one was removed in childhood. He later read the extra finger as a mark of the táltos, figures in ancient Hungarian belief said to be born with additional bones as a sign of special selection. Robert Chambers, the purported author of Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation, had six digits on each of his four limbs, as did his brother William. The actress Gemma Arterton was born with six fingers on each hand, though the boneless extra digits were removed after birth. At the extreme end of the spectrum, a boy named Hong Hong, born in Pingjiang County, Hunan province, China, has 31 fingers and toes. Kamani Hubbard, born in California in 2009, had 12 fingers and 12 toes, all fully functional. Fourteen members of a Da Silva family in Sao Paulo carry six functional fingers on each hand, with the thumb doubled, and six toes on each foot. Fiction has also returned to polydactyly repeatedly: in The Princess Bride the antagonist Tyrone Rugen is identified throughout as the six-fingered man, and in the 2012 cartoon series Gravity Falls, Stanford Pines uses a tracing of his six-fingered left hand to mark the covers of each of his journals. Yoandri Hernandez Garrido, nicknamed Veinticuatro, meaning twenty-four in Spanish, has six fully formed fingers on both hands and six perfect toes on each foot, a combination that makes his case among the most symmetrical recorded.