October Horse

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  On the 15th of October each year, in the Campus Martius, the great field of Rome named for the god of war, a chariot race ended with a spear. The winning horse of a two-horse team was killed on the spot, its head and tail cut off and carried in different directions across the city, while two rival neighborhoods came to blows over which one would get to display the animal's severed head. This was the October Horse, the Equus October, a rite so old that the earliest reference to it dates to the 3rd century BC, and so durable that it was still being recorded in a Roman calendar from 354 AD, by which point Christianity was already the empire's dominant faith.

  What explains a ritual this strange? Why was a horse sacred to Mars, the infantry god of a people who did not fight from chariots? Why did the sacrifice end a military season rather than open one? And what does the race of a blood-soaked tail across a mile of city streets tell us about how the Romans understood war, agriculture, death, and rebirth as a single tangle of forces rather than separate domains?

  4792047

• 2. War and the Harvest

  ›

  Verrius Flaccus, an antiquarian writing in the age of Augustus, recorded that the horse ritual was performed ob frugum eventum, a phrase usually taken to mean either "in thanks for the completed harvest" or "for the sake of the next harvest." Winter wheat was sown in the autumn, so the timing made agricultural sense. The same moment also marked the army's return from campaigning season, and Verrius captured the two meanings in a single sentence: a horse is suited for war, an ox for tilling.

  The Romans did not use horses as draft animals on farms, and by the late Republic they did not even rely on Roman cavalry in their armies. Polybius, writing in the 2nd century BC, nonetheless specifies that the October victim was a war horse. The sacrifice took place outside the pomerium, Rome's sacred city boundary, presumably because its martial character demanded it. But agriculture, too, was an extra-urban activity; Vitruvius notes that the proper location for a temple of Ceres was also outside the city.

  One scholar quoted in the ancient sources on this point put it plainly: in early Rome, the farmer and the soldier were the same person, and the October Horse should be understood not as a military festival or an agricultural one but as a single expression of how farming and fighting converged. Mars himself bore out this duality. Within his sphere he brought war and bloodshed, but also agriculture and virility, death and fertility simultaneously.

  The Campus Martius where the race was run had, according to Roman tradition, been consecrated to Mars by their ancestors as horse pasturage and as an equestrian training ground for the city's young men. Before Tarquin's grain was thrown into the Tiber after the expulsion of the kings, the fields had been farmed under royal control. J.G. Frazer, in The Golden Bough of 1890, saw in this origin a harvest festival at its core.

  1118192122

• 3. The Rite Itself

  ›

  Festus, a Roman grammarian, left the clearest surviving account of the ceremony. Two-horse chariots called bigae raced in the Campus Martius. The right-hand horse of the winning team was chosen as the victim because in a dual yoke, that horse carried the heavier burden and was understood to be the lead animal, and thus the most potent offering for Mars. A spear brought it down. The historian Timaeus, writing in the 3rd century BC, is the only ancient source that specifies the spear as the weapon; in standard Roman sacrifice, victims were felled with a mallet and a sacrificial axe.

  Once killed, the horse was dismembered. Its head was adorned with bread pendants, a detail added by Verrius Flaccus. Its tail was then carried at a run toward the Regia, the ancient house of the kings in the Roman Forum, roughly a mile from the Campus Martius. A monumental portico built in 193 BC connected the Porta Fontinalis gate to the Altar of Mars in the Campus, and the runner's route crossed east of the city center, along the Servian Wall and up through the Comitium before reaching the Via Sacra. The blood from the tail had to reach the Regia's sacred hearth while still dripping. In 1974, at the request of the scholar Georges Dumézil, a veterinary inspector from the Veterinary Services of Paris conducted an experiment to verify that blood from a severed horse's tail would still flow after a run of that duration. The answer was about three minutes, a timeframe the source describes as tight but achievable for a good runner.

  While the tail traveled east, the head became the object of a street fight. Residents of the Subura and residents of the Sacra Via competed physically for possession of the head. If the Suburan faction won, the head was mounted on the Tower of the Mamilii in their neighborhood. If the Via Sacra faction won, it went to the Regia. The Calendar of Philocalus notes that on October 15, "the Horse takes place at the Nixae," a site within the Campus that was probably an altar to birth deities called the di nixi.

  89121316

• 4. Blood for the Parilia

  ›

  The blood that soaked into the Regia's hearth in October was not simply discarded. It became part of the suffimen, a ritual preparation compounded by the Vestal Virgins for use at the Parilia on the 21st of April. The Parilia was a festival of rural character that also commemorated the founding of Rome. The Augustan poets Propertius and Ovid both mention horse among the suffimen's ingredients, though Propertius hints that horse blood had not always been part of the preparation: "the purification rites are now renewed by means of the dismembered horse."

  The suffimen was not only for horses; it was a lustration, a purifying mixture used on shepherds and their sheep. Suffimentum, in the broader sense, was a preparation for healing, purification, or warding off harmful influence. The agricultural writer Vegetius, in his treatise on veterinary medicine, recommended a suffimentum as a cure for draft animals and for humans prone to emotional outbursts, as well as for driving off hailstorms, demons, and ghosts, which he named daemones and umbras.

  The other animal ingredient came from the Fordicidia, a sacrifice held on the 15th of April. There, an unborn calf was burned whole, and its ash was combined with bean stalks. One late antique source, not always reliable, adds that beans were sacred to Mars. The calendar symmetry here is striking: the Fordicidia fell on the Ides of April, the October Horse on the Ides of October, and the two festivals were separated by a near-perfect division of the year into two halves of 177 and 178 days. Between them, at the precise midpoint, the Parilia united the blood of one and the ash of the other.

  2527291245

• 5. The Head and the Tail

  ›

  Vergil, in the Aeneid, records that when Dido and her colonists began digging to found Carthage, they uncovered a horse's head. The omen told them, according to Vergil, that their race would be distinguished in war and abound with the means of life. The 4th-century agricultural writer Palladius advised farmers to place the skull of a horse or ass on their fields to promote fertility, with the instruction that the animal must not have been a virgin, because the point was to generate growth.

  The location of sexual vitality in the horse's head points to its talismanic force. The substance hippomanes, believed to induce sexual passion, was said to be exuded from the forehead of a foal. Aelian, writing around 175-235 AD, placed it either at the forehead or the loins. Vergil, who called it amor, includes it among the ritual preparations Dido makes before her suicide. Bread pendants garnished the October Horse's head, and the shape of those loaves is not recorded in any ancient source. The same equine decoration appeared at the Feast of Vesta on the 9th of June, when working asses were dressed with garlands from which decorative loaves dangled.

  The tail carried its own meanings. George Devereux and others argued that cauda, the Latin word for tail, was a euphemism for the horse's penis, which would contain more blood for the hearth. The source notes, however, that a phallic potency could be assigned to the tail without any euphemism, given how common phallic symbols were in Roman culture. In the iconography of the Mithraic mysteries, the tail of the sacrificial bull is regularly grasped. In depictions of the Thracian Rider god, the horse's tail is seized in the same gesture of appropriating the animal's power. The tail of the wolf, an animal linked to Mars, was said by Pliny to contain amatorium virus, aphrodisiac force. Dumézil, who first arranged the 1974 veterinary experiment, nonetheless rejected any phallic significance for the tail.

  1791929432

• 6. Indo-European Echoes

  ›

  Georges Dumézil argued that the October Horse preserved traces of a ritual common to Indo-European cultures, centered on kingship and the consecration of royal power through a horse. The Vedic ashvamedha from ancient India and a medieval Irish inaugural sacrifice described by the medieval cleric Giraldus Cambrensis both shared features with the Roman rite. In both the Vedic and Roman cases, the sacrificial victim was the right-hand horse of a chariot team. In the ashvamedha, the horse's head signified spiritual energy and was kept as a talisman for the king; the middle of the animal embodied physical force; and the tail was grasped by the officiant and associated with livestock fertility.

  A trace of horse sacrifice may survive in Continental Celtic coinage. A personal name, Epomeduos, meaning "Horse Sacrificer" in one interpretation, appears on silver coins of the Arverni tribe in Gaul. In the Irish ritual, however, no race was involved; the horse was a mare who appears to have served as the surrogate of the goddess of sovereignty, and king and people consumed her communally from a cauldron. In the ashvamedha, the gender roles of horse and human were reversed from the Irish form.

  Jaan Puhvel, a follower of Dumézil who wrote the essay "Aspects of Equine Functionality," found few direct links between the October Horse and the Vedic rite, primarily because the method of killing differed so sharply and the element of ritual mating was entirely absent from the Roman ceremony. He attributed the absence of any sexual element not to a missing origin but to the Romans' deliberate effort to distinguish their religious practice from what they regarded as Etruscan license. Fundamental differences also lie in the god being honored: the Roman horse dies for a war god, not a king.

  5248283

• 7. The Trojan Question

  ›

  Timaeus, whose 3rd-century BC account is the earliest surviving reference to the October Horse, proposed that the ritual commemorated Rome's role in the fall of Troy. His reasoning was that the Romans, who claimed descent from Trojan refugees, sacrificed a horse each year in the Campus Martius to punish the species responsible for Troy's destruction. Polybius, writing in the 2nd century BC, quoted Timaeus's argument and immediately dismissed it, pointing out that nearly all peoples sacrificed horses before battle, so by Timaeus's logic nearly all peoples would have to be of Trojan descent. Polybius called the explanation "most childish."

  Plutarch, who died around 120 AD, mentioned the Trojan theory as a possibility without endorsing it, noting only that the Romans wished to punish the horse that had betrayed their ancestors' city. Festus recorded the theory as a common popular belief and rejected it on the same grounds Polybius had used.

  Michael Crawford connected Timaeus's interest in the ritual to the appearance of the earliest Roman didrachm, a coin introduced during the Pyrrhic War. It showed Mars on one side and a horse's head on the other. The Pyrrhic War was the very subject of Timaeus's book. Walter Burkert suggested a more cautious middle position: the October Horse cannot be taken as a re-enactment of the Trojan Horse's capture, but some shared ritualistic origin may exist. The Trojans in the myth accepted the wooden horse as a valid votive offering to a deity; they wished to bring its power inside their city walls. The spear that the Trojan priest Laocoön drives into the side of the wooden horse finds its parallel in the spear used by the officiant at the October sacrifice.

  In 46 BC, during discontent among Julius Caesar's troops, two soldiers were killed in the Campus Martius by the pontifices and the priest of Mars, and their heads were placed near the Regia. The historian Cassius Dio described this as a hierourgia, a ritual observance, and both the scholar Wissowa and Dumézil read it as a sacrifice in which human victims replaced the October Horse. Jörg Rüpke suggested that Caesar as pontifex maximus may have taken up the Trojan interpretation of the rite deliberately, given that the Julian family traced its descent to Iulus, the son of the Trojan refugee Aeneas.

  2042434473

• 8. Rebirth, Youth, and Sacred Ground

  ›

  The sacrifice at the Campus Martius was not simply a dedication to a war god. The Calendar of Philocalus places it specifically "at the Nixae," a site that was most likely an altar to the di nixi, birth deities also called Ilithyis. At the Saecular Games of 17 BC, these same deities received a nocturnal sacrifice. Horace composed the Carmen Saeculare for that occasion, performed by a children's choir, and invoked the Ilithyia directly: "In accordance with rite, open up full-term births, Ilithyia: watch over mothers and keep them calm, whether you are best called Lucina or Genitalis."

  The presence of birth deities at a sacrifice for Mars points toward the ritual's connection to initiation. The emperor Julian mentions horse sacrifice in Roman initiation rites, without elaborating. The Campus Martius remained through the Imperial period a place of equestrian training for young men. The Temple of Mars Ultor, dedicated in 2 BC by Augustus, became the site where young men around the age of 14 made a sacrifice to mark their passage into adulthood when they assumed the toga virilis, the toga of a man. Younger, less experienced drivers customarily began their chariot training with the two-horse bigae, the same vehicle used in the October Horse race.

  Some scholars have pointed to Etruscan influence on how Mars was understood in this context. The Etruscan child-god Maris was depicted with a cauldron symbolizing rebirth, and the centaur Mares, ancestor of the Ausones, underwent death and rebirth three times. The scholar John F. Hall, linking these figures to the horse-racing festivals associated with Mars, saw the god as having, in his formulation, "power over death." The chariot races on Roman children's sarcophagi reinforce the connection: they are the most common image on those monuments, and they typically show Cupids driving bigae, the same two-horse chariots of the October rite.

  5885456570