MI5

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  MI5 keeps a post office box where most organisations keep an address. PO Box 500, the service's wartime mailing address, gave rise to its internal nickname: Box, or Box 500. That is fitting for an agency that spent most of its history officially denying it existed. The Security Service, to use its formal name, was not placed on a statutory legal basis until 1989, eighty years after its founding. Before that, Parliament had never formally acknowledged it at all.

  The questions worth asking about MI5 are not just about spies caught or plots foiled. They are about what happens when an intelligence agency expands beyond its original purpose, begins watching its own citizens, shelters double agents at its highest levels, and operates in legal grey zones that courts are only now being asked to examine. From its birth in 1909 as a small counter-espionage bureau to its current role tracking terrorism across the United Kingdom, MI5's history is one of constant reinvention under pressure.

• 2. Born from a Bureau

  ›

  Vernon Kell of the South Staffordshire Regiment became the founding head of what would eventually be called MI5. He was appointed to lead the Home Section of the Secret Service Bureau when it was established in 1909 as a joint initiative of the Admiralty and the War Office. The Bureau's original concern was the activities of the Imperial German government, and it split early into naval and army sections. The army section, under Kell, handled internal counter-espionage. The naval section focused on foreign targets and eventually became the basis for what is now MI6.

  Kell led the service with a small staff, working alongside the Special Branch of the Metropolitan Police. The arrangement was deliberately divided: MI5 identified foreign agents and directed investigations, while Special Branch supplied the manpower to carry out arrests and interrogations. The service itself never held powers of arrest, a constraint that shaped its character from the beginning.

  The name MI5 was not always its name. Founded as the Home Section of the Secret Service Bureau in October 1909, it became MO5(g) in April 1914, then Military Intelligence section 5 in September 1916. It was later renamed the Defence Security Service in 1929, and then the Security Service in 1931. The "MI5" label was therefore its official designation for only thirteen years, yet it stuck in public usage permanently.

• 3. The First World War Test

  ›

  The day after war was declared, Home Secretary Reginald McKenna announced to Parliament that within the previous twenty-four hours, no fewer than twenty-one spies or suspected spies had been arrested across the country. MI5's official history puts the actual number of identified agents at twenty-two, and records that Kell had begun writing letters to local police forces on the 29th of July, giving advance warning of arrests to be made the moment war began. Portsmouth Constabulary moved early and arrested one suspect on the 3rd of August. Not all twenty-two were in custody by the time McKenna spoke.

  Whether that operation was the clean success the official history claimed became a matter of serious dispute. In 2006, historian Nicholas Hiley published an article titled "Entering the Lists" in the journal Intelligence and National Security, arguing that the list of arrested agents in the official history was assembled from later case histories rather than reflecting what actually happened at the time. Hiley was given an advance copy of the official history specifically to review it, and subsequently wrote a follow-up piece titled "Re-entering the Lists" pressing his objections further.

  The spy panic of the war years had a structural consequence MI5 did not anticipate. The service had been built up with far more resources than were actually needed to track German agents. With that surplus capacity, it began expanding its activities into areas beyond its original mandate, taking on surveillance of pacifist and anti-conscription organisations and of organised labour. The justification offered was that foreign influence lay behind such movements. By the time the war ended, MI5 had transformed from a small counter-espionage unit into a fully formed political intelligence agency.

• 4. Cuts, Rivals, and Recovery

  ›

  In 1919, the budget-conscious postwar government cut MI5's annual budget from £100,000 to just £35,000, and its staff from more than 800 officers down to twelve. At the same moment, Sir Basil Thomson of Special Branch was appointed Director of Home Intelligence, placed in supreme command of all domestic counter-insurgency and counter-intelligence. MI5's official historian Christopher Andrew, in the official history Defence of the Realm, notes that this left MI5 without a clearly defined role during the Irish War of Independence of 1919-1921. Several of Kell's officers defected to Thomson's new agency.

  The reversal came in 1921. Sir Warren Fisher, the government's inspector-general for civil-service affairs, conducted a review of Thomson's Home Intelligence Directorate and issued a scathing report accusing Thomson of wasting money, running redundant operations, and producing ineffectual results. Shortly afterward, in a private meeting with Prime Minister David Lloyd George, Thomson was dismissed. The Home Intelligence Directorate was abolished. Special Branch returned to the command of the Commissioner of the Criminal Investigation Division at Scotland Yard, and Kell was able to rebuild MI5 from near-extinction.

  During the inter-war years, MI5 also operated in Italy. The source records that it helped Benito Mussolini get his start in politics with a £100 weekly wage. Meanwhile, the NKVD had shifted its recruitment methods and begun targeting elite universities, most notably Cambridge, which traditionally fed the British civil service. The recruits they found there would prove far more damaging than any agent Germany had managed to insert.

• 5. The Cambridge Five and the Double-Cross

  ›

  Kim Philby, Donald Maclean, Guy Burgess, Anthony Blunt, and John Cairncross became known as the Cambridge Five. Recruited from within the university milieu that traditionally supplied the civil service, they succeeded in placing themselves inside the government and the intelligence services themselves. All except Maclean served with MI5 or MI6 during the Second World War. Between them, the ring passed more than 16,000 documents to the Soviets before being undetected until after the war ended.

  While the Cambridge Five represented MI5's most consequential failure, the service simultaneously constructed one of its greatest successes. The double-cross system grew from an internal memo drafted by an MI5 officer in 1936 that criticised the standing policy of arresting and prosecuting every enemy agent discovered. The memo noted that several captured agents had offered to defect, and that such offers were being routinely turned down. It proposed turning captured agents wherever possible and using them to feed false intelligence back to Germany.

  When the system was activated under David Petrie, who had replaced the sacked Vernon Kell after Churchill took power in 1940, it began with an agent named Arthur Owens, codenamed Snow. Enemy agents were offered a stark choice: work as a British double agent or face prosecution and the possibility of the death penalty. Those who agreed were supervised by MI5 as they transmitted fabricated intelligence to the German secret service, the Abwehr. The day-to-day coordination was handled by a sub-committee called the Twenty Committee, named for the Roman numerals XX, which form a double cross. A post-war analysis of German intelligence records found that of roughly 115 agents targeted against Britain, all but one had been identified and caught. The single exception had committed suicide. The system contributed directly to Operation Fortitude, the deception campaign that shaped German expectations of the D-Day landings.

  A smaller parallel operation, overseen by Victor Rothschild and run by MI5 officer Eric Roberts, targeted British citizens sympathetic to Germany. Roberts masqueraded as the Gestapo's representative in London, cultivating Nazi sympathisers and encouraging them to identify others who might cooperate with Germany in the event of an invasion. By the war's end, Roberts had identified around 500 people. MI5 decided not to prosecute any of them. The operation was covered up, and some of Roberts' recruits were even given Nazi medals. They were never told the truth.

• 6. Cold War and Controversy

  ›

  In 1952, Prime Minister's direct responsibility for the Security Service was delegated to Home Secretary David Maxwell-Fyfe. The Cold War brought new pressures alongside old failures. In 1971, MI5 contributed to the expulsion of 105 Soviet embassy staff from the United Kingdom, all known or suspected to be involved in intelligence work, breaking up a significant Soviet spy ring. That was a visible success. The embarrassments were more numerous.

  In 1983, MI5 officer Michael Bettaney was caught attempting to sell information to the KGB and was subsequently convicted of espionage. Following that case, Philip Woodfield was appointed as a staff counsellor for the intelligence services, available to anyone within the agencies who had anxieties about their work that had not been resolved through normal management channels.

  The service's relationship with domestic politics attracted sustained scrutiny. MI5 officer Ronnie Stonham held an office inside the BBC and participated in vetting procedures. A file was maintained on Labour Prime Minister Harold Wilson from 1945, the year he became a Member of Parliament, although official historian Christopher Andrew concluded that Wilson's fears of MI5 conspiracies were unfounded. Home Secretary Jack Straw discovered the existence of his own file dating from his time as a student radical.

  The most damaging unresolved question of the Cold War era concerned the former Director General Roger Hollis. Peter Wright, in his controversial book Spycatcher, presented evidence suggesting that Hollis, or his deputy Graham Mitchell, might have been a high-level Soviet penetration agent within MI5 itself. The Trend inquiry of 1974 found the case against Hollis unproven. Former KGB officer Oleg Gordievsky later supported that conclusion. The matter was never definitively settled.

  In 1991, MI5 publicly revealed its head for the first time and declassified basic information including the number of its employees and its organisational structure. Stella Rimington served as Director General from 1992 to 1996, and the agency's centenary in 2009 was marked by the publication of an official history titled The Defence of the Realm, written by Christopher Andrew, Professor of Modern and Contemporary History at Cambridge University.

• 7. Terrorism, Surveillance, and Legal Limits

  ›

  After the end of the Cold War, MI5 took on formal responsibility for investigating all Irish republican activity within Britain. The transition had implications beyond territory. In 2012, Sir Desmond de Silva conducted a document-based review of the 1989 murder of Belfast solicitor Pat Finucane. The review found that MI5 had spread propaganda against Finucane in the years before his death and had taken no steps to protect him from loyalist paramilitaries. An internal MI5 assessment from 1985 had found that 85% of the intelligence held by the Ulster Defence Association originated from MI5 sources. British Prime Minister David Cameron apologised on behalf of the UK government to Finucane's family following the review's publication.

  Following the September 11 attacks in 2001, MI5 began collecting bulk telephone communications data under a little-understood general power of the Telecommunications Act 1984. This was chosen deliberately over the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, which would have brought independent oversight. The programme remained secret until the Home Secretary announced it in 2015. By July 2006, parliamentarian Norman Baker had already alleged that MI5 held secret files on 272,000 individuals, equivalent to one in 160 adults. The agency operated a traffic-light classification: roughly 10% of files were marked green, meaning active; 46% amber, allowing new information to be added but prohibiting enquiries; and 44% red, prohibiting both enquiries and the addition of substantial new material.

  In March 2018, the government acknowledged that MI5 officers are permitted to authorise agents to commit criminal activity within the United Kingdom. Maya Foa, director of Reprieve, stated publicly that the public and Parliament were still being denied the guidance specifying when British spies could commit criminal offences and how far they could go. In December 2019, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal dismissed a challenge to this policy by four human rights organisations in a 3-to-2 decision. A Bloomberg report indicated that the potential criminal activities authorised under this policy include murder, kidnap, and torture.

  Ken McCallum, who became Director General in April 2020, stated that in the year ending October 2025, MI5 had prevented more than twenty potentially lethal Iran-backed plots. On the 2nd of October 2025, a knife attack at Heaton Park Synagogue in Manchester was declared a terrorist incident, prompting MI5 and counter-terrorism police to increase protective security measures nationwide.