Skip to content
— CH. 1 · THE DRUMMER IN THE MOPTOP —

Jimmie Nicol

~4 min read · Ch. 1 of 6
6 sections
  • James George Nicol stood on a rostrum at the KB Hallen in Copenhagen on the 4th of June 1964. He wore a suit altered to fit his frame and sported a moptop haircut identical to John Lennon's. An audience of 4,500 Beatles fans watched him play drums for the first time that evening. Just twenty-seven hours earlier, he had been a session musician earning thirty or forty pounds a week. Now he was standing next to Paul McCartney during a performance of She Loves You. McCartney counted off the song twice before Nicol began playing. The crowd screamed as if they were seeing their idols again. Nicol later described the experience as strange and quite scary. He noted how girls who ignored him the day before suddenly wanted to touch him after he put on the Beatle uniform.

  • Ringo Starr fell ill with tonsillitis on the 3rd of June 1964 while the band prepared for an Australasian tour. Manager Brian Epstein and producer George Martin needed a replacement immediately. They called Jimmie Nicol from his home in West London. Nicol arrived at Abbey Road Studios for an audition on the same day. He packed his bags and flew out within hours. The group played eight concerts between the 4th of June and the 14th of June 1964. Starr returned to Melbourne on the 14th of June to rejoin the band. Epstein gave Nicol a cheque for five hundred pounds and a gold Eterna-matic wrist watch inscribed with appreciation. Nicol never said goodbye to the Beatles when he left early the following morning. He walked away from the limo and the fame that had surrounded him for less than two weeks.

  • The spotlight vanished once Ringo Starr returned to the group. Nicol found himself back in relative obscurity by late 1965. He declared bankruptcy nine months after being a temporary Beatle. His debts totaled four thousand six hundred sixty-six pounds. Paul McCartney saw news of this financial collapse in the Daily Mirror newspaper. McCartney recommended Nicol to Peter and Gordon who hired him for a 1965 England tour. Nicol later stated that standing in for Ringo was the worst thing that ever happened to him. He remembered earning thirty or forty pounds a week before the headlines died. After the money ran low, he began dying too. He resisted selling his story despite the temptation to cash in on his brief celebrity.

  • Nicol formed Jimmy Nicol and the Shubdubs after leaving the Beatles. They released two singles that failed to achieve commercial success. The band filled in for The Dave Clark Five in Blackpool when their drummer fell ill. Nicol received five thousand fan letters passed to him from an Australian radio disc jockey. He joined the Swedish group the Spotnicks in 1965 and toured the world twice with them. He left the group in 1967 to spend time in Mexico. There he formed Los Nicolquinn with Eddie Quinn and recorded one album through RCA Records. He scored music for the film El Mes Más Cruel. In 1975 he returned to England and became involved with housing renovations instead of music.

  • Rumors of Jimmie Nicol's death circulated in 1988 when he was presumed dead at forty-nine years old. A newspaper published in 2005 confirmed he was alive and well living in London. His son Howie worked as a sound engineer on the Beatles Anthology project. Paul McCartney asked if they could contact Jimmie but his son told him no. The last confirmed sighting of Nicol occurred outside his rented first-floor flat in Kentish Town during the early 2010s. He increasingly shied away from media attention over the decades. He preferred not to discuss his connection to the Beatles nor seek financial gain from it. An autobiography he claimed to be writing never appeared.

  • Paul McCartney walked his dog Martha with Hunter Davies in early 1967 when the sun broke through the overcast sky. McCartney remarked that the weather was getting better and began laughing while remembering Nicol. This event inspired the song Getting Better on Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band released later that year. McCartney referenced Nicol again during Let It Be sessions in January 1969. Tom Hanks noted he was influenced by Nicol's experience when writing the script for That Thing You Do! released in 1996. The film featured a fictional band called The Wonders where a drummer joins them briefly before leaving. Nicol's brief tenure remains one of the most unusual moments in rock history despite its short duration.

Common questions

Who was Jimmie Nicol and when did he play drums for the Beatles?

Jimmie Nicol played drums for the Beatles during eight concerts between the 4th of June 1964 and the 14th of June 1964. He replaced Ringo Starr who fell ill with tonsillitis on the 3rd of June 1964 while the band prepared for an Australasian tour.

How much money did Jimmie Nicol earn from his time with the Beatles?

Brian Epstein gave Jimmie Nicol a cheque for five hundred pounds and a gold Eterna-matic wrist watch inscribed with appreciation. His debts later totaled four thousand six hundred sixty-six pounds after he declared bankruptcy nine months after being a temporary Beatle.

Where did Jimmie Nicol live in London during the early 2010s?

The last confirmed sighting of Jimmie Nicol occurred outside his rented first-floor flat in Kentish Town during the early 2010s. Rumors of his death circulated in 1988 but a newspaper published in 2005 confirmed he was alive and well living in London.

What happened to Jimmie Nicol after he left the Beatles in 1964?

Jimmie Nicol formed Jimmy Nicol and the Shubdubs which released two singles that failed to achieve commercial success. He joined the Swedish group the Spotnicks in 1965 and toured the world twice with them before leaving the group in 1967 to spend time in Mexico.

Did Paul McCartney ever mention Jimmie Nicol in his music or public statements?

Paul McCartney remarked on Jimmie Nicol while walking his dog Martha with Hunter Davies in early 1967 which inspired the song Getting Better on Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. McCartney referenced Nicol again during Let It Be sessions in January 1969 despite asking if they could contact him later.