Herman's Hermits

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Herman's Hermits logged twenty-four consecutive weeks in the Top Ten of the Billboard Hot 100 between March and August 1965, a run that made them one of the most successful acts the British Invasion ever produced. Five singles drove that streak, including two number ones. And yet the band's name came not from any grand artistic vision, but from a passing comment by a Manchester publican who thought their fifteen-year-old lead singer looked like a cartoon character.

  The singer was Peter Noone. The cartoon was Sherman from Rocky and Bullwinkle. Sherman became Herman, the group became Herman and His Hermits, and that soon contracted to the name that would appear on magazine covers, film posters, and a string of transatlantic hits through the rest of the decade. How a group of teenagers from Manchester got there, what it cost them, and what lingered long after the hits stopped coming are the questions this documentary sets out to answer.

• 2. Manchester to Mickie Most

  ›

  In the summer of 1963, Harvey Lisberg found the group playing at The Collingwood Club in Urmston. He and his friend Charlie Silverman became the band's managers on the 5th of November that year, and set about booking concert dates. Their early attempts to land a spot at Liverpool's Cavern Club failed repeatedly, until Lisberg brought the club's DJ, Bob Wooler, to watch a Manchester performance. Wooler persuaded the club's owner Ray McFall to book them, and a connection to EMI began to form through television executive Johnnie Hamp, who produced a nightly show called Scene at 6.30 from Granada Television, located just near the Plaza Ballroom where the band performed every Saturday night.

  The path to a record deal ran through an unexpected intermediary. The Plaza's manager, Terry Devine, gave Lisberg a contact for Derek Everett at EMI's sales division. Everett pointed Lisberg toward independent producer Mickie Most. After a phone conversation that went nowhere, Lisberg mailed Most a postcard of the group and followed it with two first-class plane tickets and a night in a Manchester hotel. Most recalled later, in a 1982 BBC Radio 1 interview, that he was drawn in by Noone's resemblance to "a young John F. Kennedy" and wanted to see the group live. What he found at the Beachcomber club in Bolton impressed him enough to proceed, though with one condition: sack the bassist and the drummer.

  Lisberg delivered the news at Peter Noone's house. Noone recalled the moment differently in a 1972 interview, placing it, as he said, "typically enough, in a Chinese restaurant" and reflecting that "we were unrecordable" at that point. Replacements came quickly. Bassist Derek Leckenby and drummer Barry Whitwam, both formerly of a local group called The Wailers, won Lisberg and Silverman over with a performance of "Hava Nagila" at auditions. Hopwood later recalled that the group's audition with Most took place at Kingsway Studios on the 19th of April 1964, and that the new lineup assembled in the basement of Charlie Silverman's house on the 22nd of April, where, as Hopwood wrote, "the band immediately sounded better by a long way."

• 3. The Hit Machine

  ›

  On the 26th of July 1964, Herman's Hermits recorded their debut single in a three-hour session at Kingsway Studios. The song was a cover of Gerry Goffin and Carole King's "I'm Into Something Good", a recent US Top 40 entry for a singer named Earl-Jean. Most disliked the recording. His wife convinced him to release it anyway. EMI's Columbia label put it out on the 7th of August, and on the 24th of September it knocked The Kinks' "You Really Got Me" from the top of the UK singles chart. It stayed there for two weeks and became the group's only number one in Britain.

  What followed in the United States was a different scale of success entirely. MGM Records released the group's self-titled first US album in February 1965. It included a track called "Mrs. Brown, You've Got a Lovely Daughter", originally written for a 1963 ITV television play called The Lads. When radio stations began playing it heavily, MGM rushed it out as a single. Its debut on the Billboard Hot 100 in April was the third-highest charting debut of the decade, behind only the Beatles' "Hey Jude" and "Get Back". It reached number one on the 1st of May and stayed there for three weeks. The album reached number two on the Billboard Top LPs chart.

  Mickie Most's production approach was the engine underneath it all. He recruited the best session arrangers and players available, among them Jimmy Page and John Paul Jones, who were years away from Led Zeppelin. Harvey Lisberg, in his autobiography I'm Into Something Good, described Most's ability to pick a hit as "uncanny." The pace of output was staggering. Hopwood wrote that in 1965 alone the group released seven singles and two albums, and played at least 300 days out of 365. When touring kept them away from the studio, Most sometimes prepared backing tracks in their absence, flying the group in for a day or two to record vocals before sending them back on the road. That arrangement created lasting resentment, though Noone later reflected that he and Most had also made their own decisions that excluded the band, and that the other Hermits "rightfully so" came to resent it.

  Billboard magazine ranked Herman's Hermits America's top singles act of 1965, with the Beatles ranking second.

• 4. Films, Fame, and Friction

  ›

  In July 1965, the group spent two days at MGM Studios in Hollywood filming scenes for When the Boys Meet the Girls, a musical starring Connie Francis. Noone played a character named Herman and performed George and Ira Gershwin's "Bidin' My Time." A month later, Noone, Hopwood, and Lisberg visited Elvis Presley on the set of Paradise, Hawaiian Style. In September, the group began work on their first starring MGM feature, Hold On!, which opened the following year and contained nine songs performed by the band.

  Songwriter P. F. Sloan contributed several tracks to Hold On!, including "A Must to Avoid", which he wrote after borrowing Donovan's dressing room and guitar at a Los Angeles club. Sloan later recalled being introduced to Most that evening, with Most mentioning the film project on the spot. "A Must to Avoid" was recorded a couple of weeks later and issued as a single in December 1965, reaching number 8 on the Billboard Hot 100 and number 6 in the UK.

  Peter Noone appeared on the cover of the 21st of May 1965 issue of Time Magazine, in an article titled "Rock N' Roll: Everybody's Turned On". The article called him an "engaging high school dropout who looks like a toy sheepdog." During the previous week, he had been, as the magazine put it, "the man of the moment" with "Mrs. Brown" at number one, "rendered in a heavy Midlands English accent."

  The group had been nominated for three Grammy Awards, including Best New Artist of 1965. They lost that category to Tom Jones. Graham Gouldman, who would later co-found 10cc, wrote several of the group's late-decade hits, including "No Milk Today", which Harvey Lisberg called the best thing they ever did. During the summer of 1967, The Who opened concerts for Herman's Hermits in North America, a detail that captures how much the landscape of rock was shifting around them. By 1968, their popularity in the US was waning, and legal battles with MGM over withheld payments consumed the group's final years on that label.

• 5. After Noone

  ›

  On the 9th of November 1970, Peter Noone and Herman's Hermits performed at the Royal Variety Command Performance at the London Palladium before the Queen Mother. The original plan involved an elaborate Broadway-style number with a rising orchestral riser, which Keith Hopwood described as "absolutely stunning". Michael Grade revised the set to a ten-minute medley that included the Cockney song "Fish and Chips" and "If I Were a Rich Man" from Fiddler on the Roof. Noone was the only member invited to shake hands with the Queen Mother afterward, which Hopwood described as another source of friction within the group.

  Noone officially left Herman's Hermits on his 24th birthday, when the group went out to dinner and agreed to call it a day. In April of that year, RAK Records had issued his debut solo single, "Oh You Pretty Thing", written by David Bowie. It reached number 12 and was the only solo single Noone charted in the UK. The remaining members renamed themselves Hermits, signed with RCA Victor, and recorded at Strawberry Studios. An album called Sourmash, produced by Eric Stewart, was never released. Hopwood left in 1972. Karl Green stayed on until 1980, when he retired from live performance to spend more time with his family. He later opened a plumbing and tiling business in London.

  Derek Leckenby died of non-Hodgkin lymphoma in 1994, leaving Barry Whitwam as the only original member still active with the band. On the 8th of June 1997, Hopwood, Green, and Whitwam played a one-off reunion concert with Noone. Hopwood has since built a career as a film and television composer. The Sourmash album was eventually released in 2000 by Pluto Music under the title A Whale of a Tale! And Others.

• 6. A Name Worth Fighting Over

  ›

  Legal disputes between Barry Whitwam and Peter Noone over the Herman's Hermits name have played out in courts across multiple countries since the 2000s. In 2003, Whitwam's touring band was required to bill itself as "Herman's Hermits Starring Barry Whitwam" in North America. In 2004, Whitwam successfully registered ownership of the name in Australia. Legal commentators noted that the case raised broader concerns about trademark registration without the consent of collaborators, drawing comparisons to disputes involving Glen Shorrock and the Original Little River Band, as well as a 2007 disagreement within The Angels over that group's name.

  Four years after Noone had left the group, Leckenby, Green, and Whitwam had already sought a High Court ruling in England to prevent Noone from using the word "Hermits". The case settled, with Noone agreeing not to use the term. Whitwam later registered the name in the United Kingdom and Europe as well. A hearing in Australia, decided by hearing officer Jock McDonagh, determined that the earlier UK settlement had permitted any of Green, Leckenby, or Whitwam to continue performing as Herman's Hermits. After Leckenby's death, with Whitwam the only surviving member actively touring under that name, the officer concluded that exclusive registration was unlikely to cause public deception.

  A 2009 US tour became the flashpoint that ended Whitwam's American touring entirely. Promoters billed the shows as "Herman's Hermits" in large text with "Featuring or With Barry Whitwam" in small text below. Noone sued. Whitwam recounted the result directly: "I decided it's not worth the hassle going out in America because every time you got booked, you got booked wrong." Noone, for his part, maintains that the name should always have been a collective asset, and continues to perform under the billing "Herman's Hermits Starring Peter Noone", a brand that brought him over 100 concerts per year in both 2024 and 2025. Whitwam and Noone remain on strained terms, while Noone has stayed in contact with Hopwood, with whom he co-released a CD called "Remember When" at the Chiller Theatre Toy, Model and Film Expo in Parsippany, New Jersey on the 25th of April 2026.