Gelato
Gelato is an Italian word that means nothing more than frozen. In Italy it covers every kind of ice cream, from the cheapest cone to the fanciest scoop. In English, though, the word has come to name one particular style: dense, silky and strongly flavored. It holds about 35% air, which is far less than American-style ice cream. That small difference changes everything about how a spoonful feels. So who first made it, and who deserves the credit? How does a frozen dessert stay smooth instead of turning icy? And how did a craft once tied to royal courts end up in machines and record-setting wafers?
Two Florentines who lived in the 16th century, Cosimo Ruggeri and Bernardo Buontalenti, are credited by some sources with inventing gelato. Ruggeri is said to have created one of the first gelati, fior di latte, for a court competition. The challenge, set at the court of Catherine de' Medici, was to present "il piatto più singolare che si fosse mai visto", which means the most singular dish that had ever been seen. Buontalenti, described as an innovator in ice conservation, made a frozen treat around 1565. It combined ice, salt, lemon, wine, milk, sugar, egg and honey, plus orange and bergamot flavouring. Other sources tell a quieter story, in which Sicilian cooks slowly adjusted the recipe for sherbet until it became the earliest form of gelato. Nobody can name a single inventor with confidence. The sources agree on one thing: the dessert soon travelled beyond Italy.
In the 1530s, Catherine de' Medici took gelato with her to Paris. For a long time afterward it stayed a luxury, reserved only for nobles. That changed in 1686, when a Sicilian named Francesco Procopio dei Coltelli arrived in the French capital. He carried a gelato-making machine that had belonged to his grandfather, also named Francesco. He opened Café Procope and began selling the dessert. Procopio became a French citizen and won a royal license from Louis XIV. That license made him the only producer of the frozen dessert in the kingdom. He was among the first to sell gelato directly to ordinary customers, and his work helped spread it across the rest of Europe. For this he is sometimes called the father of Italian gelato. The invention itself, however, depends on what happens in the mixing bowl and the freezer.
Artisanal gelato in Italy generally contains 6-9% butterfat, which is lower than other styles of frozen dessert. It also carries more flavoring, and that gives it an intense taste with a creamy, dense and rich texture. Sugar does much of the hidden work. It binds to the water in the mixture and interferes with the normal formation of ice crystals, so the dessert cannot freeze solid. The crystals that do form stay small, which is why the result feels smooth. Commercial producers often sweeten gelato with inverted sugar, sucrose, dextrose or xylitol, and they may add a stabilizer such as guar gum. The process starts with a custard base, mixed with milk and sugar. The mixture is heated to 85 °C (185 °F) to pasteurize it. Then it is cooled to 5 °C (41 °F) and mixed until it reaches the desired texture, before it is frozen.
Order stracciatella and you receive fior di latte, the plain base, with chocolate chunks scattered through it. The original fior di latte has no flavor added and no eggs. That makes it the blank page on which the other flavors are written. Crema, whose name means custard, sits beside vanilla, chocolate, hazelnut, almond and pistachio among the traditional choices. Modern shops add a wide range of fruit flavors to that list. The shelf of flavors is old, but the machinery that makes it practical is surprisingly recent.
In 1945, in Bologna in the region of Emilia-Romagna, Bruto Carpigiani began selling gelato-making equipment. He also created the Motogelatiera, the first automated gelato machine. Its batch freezer made frozen desserts easier to store. Carpigiani remains a big manufacturer of gelato machinery. Emilia-Romagna later hosted a very different kind of showpiece. In 2011, in Rimini, the 32nd edition of the International Exhibition of Handcrafted Gelato, Pastry, and Bakery saw the creation of the largest ice cream cone in the world. It was built from over 2,000 wafers and stood 2.81 m tall. The cone weighed 70 kg. A team of seven artisans built it, led by the chocolatier Mirco Della Vecchia.
Updated
Common questions
What does the word gelato mean?
In Italian, gelato simply means frozen and is the ordinary word for any kind of ice cream. In English it usually names the dense, intensely flavored style that comes from the Italian artisanal tradition.
How is gelato different from American-style ice cream?
Gelato holds about 35% air, which is substantially less than American-style ice cream. Artisanal Italian gelato also generally has 6-9% butterfat and more flavoring, which makes it denser and more intense.
Who invented gelato?
The sources disagree. Some credit the 16th-century Florentines Cosimo Ruggeri and Bernardo Buontalenti. Others say Sicilian cooks gradually changed the sherbet recipe until it became the earliest gelato.
What is the difference between fior di latte and stracciatella?
Fior di latte is a plain base with no flavor and no eggs. Stracciatella is fior di latte with chocolate chunks added.
Why is gelato so smooth?
The sugar binds to water and interferes with normal ice crystal formation. That keeps the crystals small and stops the dessert from freezing solid.
Who was Francesco Procopio dei Coltelli?
He was a Sicilian who brought his grandfather's gelato-making machine to Paris in 1686 and opened Café Procope. He gained a royal license from Louis XIV and is sometimes called the father of Italian gelato.
All sources
50 references cited across the entry
- 1StoryMinus 12˚ Craft Ice Cream
- 2Ice Cream vs. Gelato vs. Sherbet vs. Sorbet: What's the Difference?MasterClass — September 28, 2021
- 3Gelato FAQsecco un poco
- 4Gelato vs. Ice Creamsweetcycle — 19 July 2017
- 5Plotting freezing point curves for ice cream and gelato mixesMichael Mullan — dairyscience.info
- 6Why You Haven't Heard of America's Greatest Gelato MakerCharlotte Druckman — 30 May 2017
- 7Conservation de sorbets et glacesHervé This — 11 May 2019
- 8Olive Oil GelatoWarner Bros
- 9Il gelato artigianalePasticceria Mosaico di Aquileia — 31 July 2017
- 10Traditional Frozen TreatsKQ2 Ventures LLC — 28 June 2015
- 12NewsWhat's The Difference Between Ice Cream, Frozen Custard, and Gelato?Mary Beth Quirk — July 14, 2017
- 13Come fare il gelato in casa: 3 trucchi per risultati da gelateriaLucia D'Ulivo — May 15, 2018
- 14May is Artisan Gelato MonthBea Davis
- 15Gelato v Ice Cream: Temperature & MethodBravo Gelato
- 17Nutrition Facts on Gelato Compared to Ice CreamM. T. Wroblewski — 6 December 2018
- 18NewsItalian University Spreads the 'Gelato Gospel'Sylvia Poggioli — NPR — 17 June 2013
- 19JournalColloidal aspects of ice cream—A reviewH. Douglas Goff — June 1997
- 20JournalThe Influence of Polysaccharides on the Glass Transition in Frozen Sucrose Solutions and Ice CreamH.D. Goff et al. — May 1993
- 21Gelato in the Italian-English dictionaryCambridge Dictionary
- 22Gelato in the English dictionaryCambridge Dictionary
- 23Chi inventò il gelato? Sfida fiorentina tra Buontalenti e RuggeriMarco Gemelli — 9 May 2013
- 24BookThe Oxford Companion to Sugar and SweetsDarra Goldstein — Oxford University Press — 2015
- 26BookScienza e tecnologia del gelato artigianaleLuca Caviezel — Chiriotti — 2016
- 27Gelato: A history of the world's favorite dessert and traditionally authentic gelaterias in Florence.Destination Florence Convention & Visitors Bureau scrl
- 28Buontalenti, l'artista che inventò il gelato fiorentino15 August 2016
- 29NewsItaly opens world's first gelato culture museumStephen Jewkes — 1 October 2012
- 30BookRenaissance Fun: The Machines Behind the ScenesPhilip Steadman — UCL Press — 13 April 2021
- 32Procopio Cutò e il gelatoAlex Revelli Sorini et al. — Accademia Italiana Gastronomia e Gastrosofia
- 33BookIl genio del gelato. Francesco Procopio Cutò. Storie d'amore, di talento e di alchimia tra Palermo e ParigiLuciana Polliotti — Fausto Lupetti Editore — 2017
- 34NewsFrancesco Procopio dei Coltelli: the man who invented gelatoOlga Stornello — Sicilian Post — 1 November 2018
- 35BookGelati gelatiLuciana Polliotti — Mondadori — 1999
- 36BookI pochi segreti e le molte virtù del gelato artigianale di tradizione italiana: spunti di riflessione sul mestiere di gelatiere nel terzo millennio (con una galleria di ricette, anche storiche)Luca Caviezel et al. — Longarone Fiere — 2010
- 37BookGelato!: Italian Ice Creams, Sorbetti & GranitePamela Sheldon Johns — Ten Speed Press — 2000
- 38BookPike Place Market Cookbook: Recipes, Anecdotes, and Personalities from Seattle's Renowned Public MarketBraiden Rex-Johnson — Sasquatch Books — 2003
- 39Moramarco, p. 208. The father of Italian gelato is Francesco Procopio dei Coltelli, a Sicilian aristocrat who established a chain of coffee houses throughout Europe in the late seventeenth century.
- 40NewsThe inside scoop on making gelatoSheri Jennings — 23 September 2010
- 42History
- 44JournalSensory Characteristics of ice cream produced in the United States and ItalyKelly R. Thompson et al. — June 2009
- 45Ice Cream HardnessMay 31, 2021
- 46JournalKinetics of ice crystallization in sugar solutions and fruit juicesA. Monem Omran — July 1974
- 47NewsDanisco unveils gelato concept for industrial productionSarah Hills — William Reed Ltd — April 1, 2009
- 48Cosa è la bilanciatura?August 12, 2021
- 50LucaDisney