Double agent

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  A double agent carries two identities at once, and the strain of that arrangement has ended careers, ended lives, and occasionally changed the course of wars. In the field of counterintelligence, a double agent is an employee of a secret intelligence service for one country whose official purpose is to spy on a target organization, but who is in fact spying on their own country's organization for that very target. It is a role built on sustained deception, and the question the listener might reasonably ask is: how does anyone survive it? The answer, it turns out, lies in a careful architecture of trust, managed information, and sometimes brute coercion. This documentary traces how double agents come to exist, how they operate, what keeps them in place, and what finally brings them down.

• 2. How Double Agents Are Made

  ›

  Execution is the most common lever used to turn a captured spy. When an intelligence service catches an agent working for a foreign power, the threat of death is frequently enough to persuade that agent to switch sides, feeding information back to the organization that just caught them. This process is called turning, and it is how many of the best-documented double agents in history were created. Not all double agents arrive through coercion, though. Some are recruited from the start by a target organization that plants them inside the controlling one. William Sebold, code-named Tramp, was a German-born U.S. citizen coerced by the German Abwehr into becoming a spy. He took a different path: he exposed the Abwehr's entire Duquesne Spy Ring to the FBI. A double agent who is subsequently caught and pressured to deceive their new handlers earns a further designation. The term for that situation is re-doubled agent, and the writer F.M. Begoum defined the category precisely: someone whose duplicity in doubling for another service has been detected by the original sponsor and who has been persuaded to reverse affections again. Beyond the re-doubled agent sits the triple agent, a spy who pretends to be a double agent for one side while genuinely functioning as a double agent for the other. Unlike a re-doubled agent, whose reversal is forced by exposure, a triple agent has typically maintained loyalty to their original side throughout.

• 3. The Currency of False Information

  ›

  Double agents are often very trusted by the organization they are deceiving, and that trust is the mechanism that makes them useful. A controlling organization will feed its double agent true information, but information that is either useless or actively counterproductive, so that it can be passed along convincingly to the target. The target believes the agent is delivering genuine intelligence; the controlling organization uses that channel to shape what the target knows. This makes the double agent a vehicle for disinformation. Counter-espionage operations rely on exactly this dynamic: the double agent identifies other agents, passes along carefully curated falsehoods, and helps map the opposition's networks from within. Juan Pujol Garcia, code-named Garbo, operated as a British double agent inside German intelligence during World War II. He earned both an MBE from the British and an Iron Cross from the Germans, a dual decoration that captures, in a single biographical detail, just how convincingly the system could work. Eddie Chapman, code-named ZigZag, infiltrated the German Abwehr while feeding intelligence to MI5. He is reported to be the only British citizen ever awarded the Iron Cross by Germany.

• 4. The Double-Cross System

  ›

  World War II produced the most documented concentration of double agents in recorded history. Many of them operated under a British programme referred to in the source material simply as the Double-Cross System. Among its agents were Mathilde Carre, code-named La Chatte, a French operative; Roman Czerniawski, code-named Brutus, a Polish agent; and the Norwegian pair John Herbert Neal Moe and Tor Glad, who shared the joint code-name Mutt and Jeff. Roger Grosjean, a French Air Force pilot code-named Fido, worked for the British under this system. Walter Dicketts, code-named Celery, was a former Royal Naval Air Service officer. He was sent to Lisbon and then into Germany to infiltrate the Abwehr and report on invasion plans for Britain. Dicketts survived an intensive five-day interrogation in Hamburg, and was later sent back to Lisbon to persuade an Abwehr officer named George Sessler to defect, then conducted further undercover work in Brazil. The Serbian brothers Dusan and Ivan Popov each worked simultaneously for the Yugoslavian agency VOA, the British MI6, and the German Abwehr. Dusan, code-named Tricycle among other names, held the rank of colonel in the British Army. Ivan, who carried the code-names LaLa, Aesculap, Dreadnought, and Hans, held the rank of Obersturmbannfuhrer in the Gestapo. Dusan Popov was himself recruited by the German intelligence officer Johann-Nielsen Jebsen, code-named Artist, who was an anti-Nazi German working for MI6 between 1941 and 1945.

• 5. Cold War Betrayals

  ›

  Aldrich Ames worked for the CIA from 1957 to 1994, and for much of that period he was reporting to the KGB. His case became one of the most damaging penetrations in American intelligence history. Oleg Gordievsky went the other direction. A Russian KGB officer who began working for British MI6 in 1968, he was abducted in Moscow in 1985 and escaped to the United Kingdom two months later. Robert Hanssen was an FBI officer who sold information to the Soviet Union as a mole inside the very organization meant to catch such agents. Dmitri Polyakov worked for both the FBI and CIA while serving in the GRU, Soviet military intelligence; he was executed in 1988. Oleg Penkovskiy, a GRU colonel code-named Hero, informed the United Kingdom and the United States about the Soviet placement of missiles in Cuba. The Soviets executed him in 1963. The Cambridge Five, a network of British intelligence officers loyal to Soviet intelligence, included Kim Philby, Donald Maclean, Guy Burgess, Anthony Blunt, and John Cairncross. Philby carried the code-name Stanley; Cairncross was Liszt; Blunt was Johnson; Burgess was Hicks; Maclean was Homer. Stig Bergling, a Swedish GRU agent working against the Swedish security service SAPO, handed over the entire Swedish FO-code, a top-secret register of Sweden's defence establishments, coastal artillery fortifications, and mobilization stores. He was convicted in 1979 and sentenced to life imprisonment for treason.

• 6. Agents Outside the Cold War Frame

  ›

  Not every double agent fits into the great-power rivalry that defined the Cold War. Denis Donaldson, a Northern Irish operative, worked for MI5 and the Police Service of Northern Ireland while embedded inside Provisional IRA and Sinn Fein. He was assassinated at his cottage in County Donegal after his identity was exposed by a Northern Ireland newspaper, The Derry Journal. Robert Nairac, an English officer born in Mauritius, operated inside the Provisional IRA for British Army intelligence. He was murdered by the Provisional IRA in County Louth in 1977. Mikel Lejarza, code-named El Lobo, worked against ETA during the Basque conflict that ran from 1959 to 2011. Larissa Swirski, a Russian operative code-named Queen of Hearts, was recruited by the Nazis in Ceuta. After learning about the concentration camps, she changed sides, aligned with British MI6 from 1943 to 1945, and played a role in preventing the Nazis from taking Gibraltar. Aimen Dean, a British citizen born in Bahrain, worked for MI6 inside al-Qaeda during the Global War on Terrorism. His cover was reportedly blown when Ron Suskind, drawing on CIA sources operating under the Five Eyes UKUSA Agreement, disclosed details in an excerpt of The One Percent Doctrine for Time magazine that could only have originated with Dean.

• 7. The Defector Distinction

  ›

  A double agent is not a defector, and the distinction matters inside the intelligence community. A defector abandons their organization without being posted to function for another service; a double agent continues operating, posted and active, while serving two masters. Some analysts consider defectors to have functioned as agents de facto up until the moment they defected, but formally, an agent must be posted and active for the classification to apply. Vitaly Yurchenko is one figure associated with the re-doubled category: a Soviet intelligence officer whose case raised precisely these questions of where defection ends and re-doubling begins. The events in which double agents have played documented roles span centuries, from the Babington Plot and the Battle of Lexington to the Battle of Normandy, the Yom Kippur War, and the Camp Chapman attack during the Global War on Terrorism. The Wars of the Three Kingdoms in the mid-seventeenth century produced Samuel Morland, an English operative loyal to the Commonwealth of England who spied for the Restoration. The range of conflicts suggests that as long as intelligence services have existed, so too has the temptation, and the utility, of the agent who serves two sides at once.