Dig a Pony
John Lennon called the song a piece of garbage. He wrote it for his soon-to-be wife Yoko Ono during early 1969. The track sits in the key of A major and moves in three-quarter time. Originally titled All I Want Is You, the lyrics feature strange phrases strung together like a Bob Dylan style. Ian MacDonald described these words as celebrating countercultural claims that old values were dead. Life became a game while art turned into a free-for-all according to this analysis. Words meant whatever one wished them to mean within this framework. Lennon introduced the composition to George Harrison on January 2 at Twickenham Film Studios.
The band performed live on the roof of Apple Corps building on Savile Row on the 30th of January 1969. Roadie Kevin Harrington held up lyric sheets for John Lennon while he sang. Ringo Starr yelled Hold it because he was putting out his cigarette with both drumsticks in his right hand. Someone blew their nose immediately after Starr's interjection, an action Mark Lewisohn attributes to Lennon. The recording begins with a false start caused by this interruption. The sound of blowing fills the silence before the music resumes its chaotic energy. This moment captures the raw, unpolished nature of the rooftop concert itself.
A studio take from January 22 appears on the 1996 Anthology 3 outtakes compilation. Glyn Johns favored this January 22 recording over the rooftop performance when compiling Get Back in 1969. Both versions begin and end with the line All I want is. Phil Spector selected the January 30 live version for the March 1970 Let It Be album release. He shortened the track by cutting the opening and closing refrains entirely. These edits remained in place for the 2003 Let It Be... Naked mix which also omits the false start. The editing process stripped away the song's original structure significantly.
Apple Records issued Let It Be on the 8th of May 1970 with Dig a Pony as the second track. The sequence placed it between Two of Us and Across the Universe. McCartney's comments in a questionnaire promoting his solo album had resulted in the Beatles' break-up just one month prior. Early American pressings mistitled the song as I Dig a Pony. This error appeared on initial copies distributed to listeners across North America. The mislabeling persisted until corrected in later reissues and remasters of the album.
Richard Williams reviewed the album for Melody Maker calling the track genuinely new Lennon material. He admired the tremendously funky unison guitar riff despite the insane words and wandering tune. John Mendelsohn of Rolling Stone welcomed the song as an example of minimal alteration by Spector. He described it as crossword-puzzlish while noting the urgent old rocker's vocal performance. Neil Harris dismissed the track as pretty execrable in Mojo magazine in 2001. He viewed it as evidence of reduced creativity during the Let It Be sessions. Neil McCormick of The Daily Telegraph called it embarrassing and blamed Lennon directly.
Ian MacDonald described the song as inconsequential fun within his historical analysis. He noted that such whimsy looked distinctly bedraggled by 1969 yet survived in progressive educational minds for twenty years. Mark Hertsgaard deemed it a lyrically muddled love call lacking melody entirely. Yet McCartney's high harmony singing combined with Harrison's lead guitar part made it seem more interesting than reality suggested. Peter Doggett cited lyrics showing Lennon was rightly dismissive of his own work. Chris Ingham called it riffily convoluted gobbledygook with a lugubrious chromatic approach. Spector's editing wisely pared back these excesses according to this perspective.
Continue Browsing
Common questions
Who wrote the song Dig a Pony and when was it written?
John Lennon wrote the song during early 1969 for his soon-to-be wife Yoko Ono. He introduced the composition to George Harrison on January 2 at Twickenham Film Studios.
When did The Beatles perform Dig a Pony live on the roof of Apple Corps building?
The band performed live on the roof of Apple Corps building on Savile Row on the 30th of January 1969. This rooftop concert recording features Ringo Starr yelling Hold it while putting out his cigarette with both drumsticks in his right hand.
Which version of Dig a Pony appears on the Let It Be album released by Apple Records?
Phil Spector selected the January 30 live version for the March 1970 Let It Be album release. Apple Records issued Let It Be on the 8th of May 1970 with Dig a Pony as the second track between Two of Us and Across the Universe.
Why do some critics describe the lyrics of Dig a Pony as gobbledygook or muddled?
Ian MacDonald described these words as celebrating countercultural claims that old values were dead while Words meant whatever one wished them to mean within this framework. Chris Ingham called it riffily convoluted gobbledygook with a lugubrious chromatic approach and Mark Hertsgaard deemed it a lyrically muddled love call lacking melody entirely.
How did early American pressings mistake the title of Dig a Pony?
Early American pressings mistitled the song as I Dig a Pony on initial copies distributed to listeners across North America. This error appeared on initial copies distributed to listeners across North America before being corrected in later reissues and remasters of the album.